- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a bottom-up hierarchical graph representation learning framework for fMRI-based brain disease detection. The method first uses Transformer-based gating to estimate ROI importance and reweight node features, then learns soft assignments from ROIs to functional clusters and aggregates them into a coarsened cluster-level graph for downstream brain disease classification. A clustering consistency module further encourages the learned assignment subspace to preserve low-frequency Laplacian eigenvectors, for which the authors provide conditional theoretical connections to the continuous normalized-cut objective. The model is evaluated on multiple brain benchmarks, with additional ablations on the hierarchical components, the number of clusters, clustering stability, and computational complexity.
Critical strengths
- The paper provides a biologically motivated hierarchical representation of brain functional organization. Explicitly learning ROI-to-cluster assignments makes the learned representation more interpretable than standard brain GNNs, and the authors provide theoretical and empirical analyses to support the design.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological novelty is not sufficiently established against recent high-order brain graph methods. Since the main contribution relies on explicitly modeling functional clusters and their higher-order interactions, comparisons with recent high-order approaches such as MuHL [1] and IBAHGT [2] are important for demonstrating the advantage of the proposed formulation.
[1] Sim, Jaeyoon, et al. "Learning Multi-Scale Hypergraph for High-Order Brain Connectivity Analysis." ICML (2026).
[2] Feng, Jingxi, et al. "Information Bottleneck-Guided Adaptive Hypergraph Transformer for Brain Disease Diagnosis." NeurIPS(2026).
- The empirical evidence is not sufficiently convincing. Several strong recent baselines are missing, and the reported p-values test performance against 0.5 rather than improvements over competing methods. Moreover, the large and inconsistent variances make it difficult to determine whether the reported gains are statistically reliable.
Questions for authors
- How does the proposed method compare with recent high-order brain graph methods such as MuHL and IBAHGT? Such comparisons would materially affect my assessment of the methodological novelty.
- The CCM formulation requires to be invertible, but the learned soft assignment does not guarantee full column rank. How often does approach rank deficiency in practice, and how is the inverse handled numerically during training?