- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents HiBrain, a structure-calibrated multi-order hypergraph framework for brain disorder classification. It models second-, third-, and fourth-order functional interactions, with higher-order cumulants defined relative to lower-order dependencies and further calibrated using subject-specific gray-matter information. The resulting relations are then integrated through evidence-aware ROI–hyperedge attention and cross-order propagation, while a conditional admission mechanism selectively regulates the contribution of higher-order information to the final prediction. Experiments on ASD, MDD, and SCZ datasets, with external validation on ASD, demonstrate consistent improvements over the evaluated graph- and attention-based baselines.
Critical strengths
- The paper presents a well-motivated approach to higher-order brain network modeling. Conditioning higher-order cumulants on lower-order relations and combining them with subject-specific structural information provides a meaningful extension beyond simply constructing hyperedges, and the extensive experiments consistently support the proposed framework.
Critical weaknesses
- The interpretation of gray-matter information as structural support for functional hyperedges is not fully convincing. ROI-wise gray-matter measurements characterize regional morphology but do not directly establish anatomical connectivity among the ROIs forming a hyperedge. Therefore, the proposed calibration may be better understood as multimodal feature conditioning rather than explicit structural validation of higher-order relations.
- The evaluation protocol is not strictly independent of the held-out data. The temporal block count is determined using scan lengths from the entire loaded cohort, including validation/test subjects and even the external ABIDE-I cohort, and this choice affects temporal views and candidate-selection statistics. In addition, the main results use a single model seed and do not report statistical tests against the strongest baselines.
Questions for authors
- What evidence supports interpreting gray-matter-based calibration as structural support for a functional hyperedge, rather than as an additional morphological feature used for multimodal conditioning?
- How does HiBrain compare with recent higher-order brain network methods such as HyperDiag [1] and MuHL [2]? Such comparisons would help clarify the empirical advantage of the proposed higher-order modeling strategy.
[1] Ma, Yulan, et al. "HyperDiag: Temporal–Regional Hypergraph Learning via Topology-Enhanced State Propagation for Brain Disease Diagnosis." AAAI (2026).
[2] Sim, Jaeyoon, et al. "Learning Multi-Scale Hypergraph for High-Order Brain Connectivity Analysis." ICML (2026).