1.The framework is evaluated only on ABIDE-I and ADHD-200, comprising 1,025 and 541 participants, respectively. The primary concern is not simply the sample size, but the limited scope of evaluation: both tasks involve established multisite neurodevelopmental disorder cohorts. These experiments provide insufficient evidence for broad applicability or robust generalization. Cross-validation on pooled multisite data does not establish performance on previously unseen sites.
I recommend adding a third independent cohort. If additional data are unavailable, the authors should at least conduct leave-one-site-out or site-grouped outer validation on the existing datasets, report site-specific performance with confidence intervals, and assess the effects of acquisition protocols, age distributions, and diagnostic categories. Claims of broad applicability should be narrowed if the evaluation remains restricted to these two tasks.
2.The abstract states that HADBN “consistently outperforms state-of-the-art methods.” However, on ABIDE-I, HADBN achieves an accuracy of 68.14%, below BrainGNN’s 69.31%, and an AUC of 69.32%, below BrainGNN’s 69.52%. On ADHD-200, HADBN achieves the highest accuracy, but its AUC of 73.48% is lower than STIGR’s 78.11%. The results therefore do not support consistent superiority across datasets and metrics.
The abstract, experimental discussion, and conclusion should be revised to distinguish clearly between metrics on which HADBN improves and those on which it does not. Performance differences should be assessed using paired comparisons on identical data splits, with appropriate confidence intervals. Rankings based solely on mean performance are insufficient to establish statistically significant superiority.
3.The introduction and related work repeatedly discuss static versus dynamic connectivity, fixed aggregation, and limited cross-scale interaction. This extended general background obscures the central questions: which specific limitation of existing hierarchical methods is addressed, what F-based aggregation changes, and why those changes should improve interpretability or generalization. Citation accuracy also requires attention. Section 3.1 attributes the Yeo atlas to Dickstein et al. (2006), but the corresponding reference concerns an ADHD neuroimaging meta-analysis. The reference list additionally contains duplicate entries.
The background should be reorganized around the task requirements, a precisely defined methodological gap, and testable hypotheses. Repeated material should be consolidated, and a concise comparison table could distinguish HADBN from existing hierarchical models in terms of structural priors, aggregation, temporal modeling, and interaction direction. Each claimed contribution should map directly to a methodological component and supporting experiment. Atlas citations and duplicate references should be checked throughout.
4.In the presented attention formulation, queries originate from local representations, while keys and values originate from global representations. The output updates the local representations, explicitly implementing global-to-local information transfer. No corresponding attention operation that updates the global representations is shown, despite the conclusion claiming “bidirectional information flow.” Bottom-up aggregation alone does not establish bidirectional cross-attention. The authors should clarify whether “bidirectional” refers to the overall hierarchical computation or a bidirectional attention module. If reverse attention is implemented, its equations and update order should be provided; otherwise, the terminology should be revised consistently. Comparisons among no interaction, global-to-local interaction, local-to-global interaction, and bidirectional interaction would provide stronger support than removing the entire attention module alone.
5.The hierarchy combines 90 AAL regions, 17 intermediate networks, and seven global networks. However, the mapping from AAL regions to Yeo networks is insufficiently described, particularly for subcortical regions. It remains unclear how outputs from differently sized subsets are assembled, whether assignments can cross predefined network boundaries, and whether parameters are shared across time windows and participants. Consequently, the distinction between learning a hierarchical structure and learning aggregation weights within a fixed hierarchy is unresolved. The authors should provide the complete mapping, masking rules, tensor dimensions, and forward-pass pseudocode, explicitly separating fixed priors from learnable components. Comparisons with fixed mean aggregation and parameter-matched learnable pooling are needed. The paper should also compare its mechanism and performance with relevant hierarchical approaches discussed in the manuscript, including MHNet and BrainHGT, to establish what the proposed hierarchy contributes.
6.The overall objective combines the classification loss with four auxiliary components, while the F-related regularizer itself contains five terms. This introduces substantial tuning complexity, yet Table 3 provides no loss-by-loss ablation. More importantly, the manuscript states that each F-vector is constrained to be nonnegative and sum to one through ReLU and normalization. If these constraints hold exactly, its L1 norm is identically one, rendering the sparsity term in Equation (11) ineffective, while the row-sum penalty in Equation (12) is identically zero. This raises a fundamental question about the validity of the objective, beyond concerns about complexity alone.
The authors should clarify whether these losses are computed before or after normalization, specify any numerical stabilization, and explain how all-zero vectors are handled. Starting from the classification-only objective, they should evaluate the incremental contribution of each auxiliary term and report weight sensitivity and gradient magnitudes. Constant or redundant penalties should be removed. If sparse aggregation is intended, the chosen mechanism must remain effective under the imposed constraints and be supported experimentally.