- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a brain-inspired bidirectional hierarchical learning framework for dynamic functional brain connectivity analysis. The idea is to model brain information processing through both bottom-up functional aggregation and top-down functional regulation. The proposed framework consists of three main components: a neuro-inspired node activation learner, a high-order subnetwork organization learner, and a top-down functional regulation module. Multiple Hi-Brain layers are stacked to capture hierarchical interactions. The proposed Hi-Brain approach was evaluated on two fMRI datasets, ADNI and a Parkinson's disease dataset. The results generally look promising. It is argued by the authors that the proposed approach provides both improved diagnostic performance and a more biologically plausible framework for brain connectivity analysis.
Critical strengths
The main strength of this paper is, as I see, its attempt to integrate multiple levels of brain functional organization into a unified learning framework. Rather than focusing exclusively on node-level connectivity or predefined functional subnetworks, the proposed approach explicitly models node activation, subnetwork interactions, and global information feedback. The combination of spiking neural networks, MoE, and optimal transport is technically interesting, particularly the use of global representations to refine lower-level features.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited methodological novelty and insufficient justification of the brain-inspired design. Although the overall framework is interesting, its main components are largely established techniques, including e.g. SNNs, MoE, GCNs, optimal transport, and hierarchical feature refinement. The novelty of the proposed approach is not well articulated relative to existing approaches. A lot of related works have been published over the recent years. The literature review could be largely improved and in more depth (so that the novelty could be highlighted). The connection between the computational components and the claimed biological mechanisms is not sufficiently established. For example, the authors argue that SNNs are suitable for modeling neuronal activation, but fMRI BOLD signals represent indirect, temporally smoothed measurements of neural activity rather than neuronal spikes. The biological interpretation of applying an SNN directly to these signals therefore requires stronger justification. Similarly, the top-down regulation mechanism resembles conventional feature feedback or residual refinement. It is not clear what distinguishes this mechanism from existing hierarchical neural architectures beyond its biological interpretation.
-
The empirical evidence does not fully substantiate the claims of biological plausibility and interpretability. Although the classification results are promising, the experiments primarily demonstrate predictive effectiveness rather than faithful modeling of brain information processing. The hierarchical temporal prediction experiments evaluate whether signals at one level can predict signals at another level, but successful prediction does not necessarily establish bottom-up information integration or top-down functional regulation. In particular, predicting a brain region from other regions demonstrates statistical dependence rather than directional regulatory influence. There is also insufficient analysis of whether the learned activation patterns and functional subnetworks are stable across subjects or cross-validation folds. Given that biological plausibility is a central motivation of the paper, more rigorous validation is needed to support this claim.
Questions for authors
-
What is the specific methodological novelty (relative to the state of the art)?
-
Could you justify the use of SNNs on fMRI BOLD signals? What evidence supports the claim that the SNN-based activation learner captures biologically meaningful neuronal activation?
-
How does the optimal transport module explicitly capture high-order interactions among functional subnetworks? Why the resulting transport plan should be interpreted as high-order functional collaboration rather than a globally constrained pairwise alignment?
-
Can you provide stronger evidence for the claimed bidirectional regulation mechanism? Could you clarify how the experiments distinguish genuine top-down regulation from statistical correlation or general representation learning?
-
How were cross-validation and hyperparameter optimization conducted? Were the hyperparameters selected using nested cross-validation, and were the same data splits and tuning budgets applied to all baseline methods?