- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes HyperEvo to address the limitations of fixed hypergraph topologies and insufficient temporal modeling in brain network analysis. Specifically, it introduces a history-aware mechanism to guide discrete node–hyperedge membership updates and employs multi-window attention to integrate temporal features. Experiments on ADNI and PPMI datasets demonstrate improved brain disease classification performance and promising interpretability.
Critical strengths
-
Experiments across eight classification tasks on ADNI and PPMI, together with ablation and parameter sensitivity analyses, demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed framework.
-
The visualization of discriminative hyperedges and brain regions provides insights into disease-related functional network alterations.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological novelty of the proposed framework is limited. Modeling dynamic brain activity using historical states has been extensively explored [1,2]. Moreover, hypergraph-based approaches have been widely adopted for dynamic brain network analysis [3], and recent studies have further investigated adaptive optimization of hypergraph nodes and hyperedges [4]. Therefore, the authors should more clearly distinguish the proposed method from existing studies and highlight its unique contributions.
[1] Asynchronous Functional Brain Network Construction with Spatiotemporal Transformer for MCI Classification. IEEE TMI, 2024.
[2] Dynamic Graph Representation Learning for Spatio-Temporal Neuroimaging Analysis. IEEE TCYB, 2025.
[3] HyperDiag: Temporal–Regional Hypergraph Learning via Topology-Enhanced State Propagation for Brain Disease Diagnosis. AAAI, 2026.
[4] Learning High-Order Relationships with Hypergraph Attention-Based Spatio-Temporal Aggregation for Brain Disease Analysis. IEEE JBHI, 2026.
-
The framework relies on sparse reconstruction to initialize hypergraphs. The authors should investigate whether different initialization strategies significantly influence the learned topology and classification performance.
-
The experiments are conducted on ADNI and PPMI without independent external validation. Additional cross-site or cross-dataset experiments would strengthen the generalization claims.
Questions for authors
-
The history-aware attention and discrete topology editing mechanisms may introduce additional computational overhead. The authors should report model complexity, parameter counts, and runtime comparisons.
-
The identified discriminative hyperedges and brain regions are mainly supported by visualization and literature-based interpretation. Further statistical analysis would improve the reliability of the neurological findings.
-
The three-class classification results on PPMI differ between Tables 1 and 2. For example, the complete model achieves 62.17% accuracy in Table 1 but 62.21% in Table 2.
-
Although parameter sensitivity experiments are provided, the selected addition and deletion budgets vary across classification tasks. The authors should further explain how these budgets are determined and whether they can generalize across datasets without task-specific tuning.
-
In Table 2, the same module is referred to as “w/o WKAF” and “w/o WLAF” for the ADNI and PPMI datasets, respectively.
-
In Table 2, the terms “NC” and “CN” are used interchangeably to refer to normal controls. The authors should carefully proofread the entire manuscript to avoid such minor errors.