- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, HOPE, an energy-driven high-order graph state evolution framework, is proposed for brain network analysis. In the theoretical part, the support properties of sparse assignment of temperature control and the continuous/discrete energy dissipation properties under fixed factors are given. The experiment classifies on three brain network benchmark, and evaluates the zero-shot generalization, ablation, superparameter sensitivity, factor interpretation and efficiency comparison across acquisition phase/cohort, which is superior to baseline in many settings.
Critical strengths
- The modeling perspective of transforming high-order structures from aggregation operators into energy terms is essentially new. The existing high-order graph methods mostly take hyperedge/ high-order structure as the message aggregation path, while HOPE makes the learned high-order factors parameterize the total energy, and drives the state evolution through structure-aware mobility.
- The results of benchmark and phase/cohort zero-shot across three independent brain networks are more convincing. ADNI, PPMI and ABIDE cover neurodegeneration and neurodevelopmental disorders, and the structural/functional network modes are different.
Critical weaknesses
The conclusion of clinical classification is influenced by category imbalance and index definition, and the robustness of core promotion has not been fully proved.
Questions for authors
- Is F1 in Table 1 macro-F1, weighted-F1 or other definitions?
- Is the source domain/target domain of Zero-shot cross-phase/cohort experiment isolated by subjects? Do model selection, hyperparameters and early stopping use any labels or validation data of the target domain?
- Are all baseline in Table 1 retrained under the same 5-fold split, the same input features and the same parameter adjustment budget? Please give the statistical test or the result of each discount.
- Proposition 2 only guarantees the energy dissipation under the fixed factor. Is it possible for the total energy to rise when the alternating factor is inferred? Can you give empirical evidence of global boundedness/convergence?
2 comments
Response to reviewer yXs4 (Part 2)
[Q4] Energy Stability under Alternating Factor Re-inference
[A] We clarify that Proposition 2 guarantees continuous-time energy dissipation under fixed factors, rather than global monotonic descent across alternating factor re-inference. As detailed in our response to Reviewer LeHF [Q3] and Table 13, we separately quantified energy changes during fixed-factor state updates and factor re-inference, confirming that re-inferring the factors can increase . To further assess the complete alternating dynamics, we extended inference to without retraining. As shown in Fig. 5, decreases sharply after initial fluctuations and remains low without sustained growth or divergent oscillations across all three datasets. Classification accuracy also remains largely stable throughout the extended evolution. As a result, these findings provide empirical support for the stability of alternating factor-state evolution over the evaluated horizon, without implying a theoretical guarantee of global convergence.
Response to reviewer yXs4 (Part 1)
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback and for recognizing the novelty of our energy-driven higher-order modeling perspective and the convincing experimental results. We address the remaining concerns, which we hope will further strengthen the reviewer's positive assessment of our work.
[W1/Q1] Class Imbalance and Evaluation Metrics
[A] We clarify that precision, recall, and F1-scores in Table 1 are macro-averaged under stratified 5-fold cross-validation, and we provide additional class-wise results using pooled out-of-fold predictions, as detailed in our response to Reviewer c1KQ [W3/Q3]. Importantly, the strong macro-F1 performance is not driven solely by majority classes, but is supported by consistent classification performance across all five diagnostic groups. Furthermore, the random-seed robustness analysis in Table 12 demonstrates that HOPE consistently outperforms strong baselines across five independent seeds. These results also support the reliability of our classification performance across different random initializations.
[Q2] Subject-level isolation and target-domain independence in zero-shot evaluation
[A] We clarify that all zero-shot experiments, including ADNI cross-phase and PPMI cross-cohort transfer, strictly maintained subject-level separation between source and target domains, ensuring that no subject appeared in both. All model training, hyperparameter tuning, model selection, and early stopping were performed exclusively using source-domain data. Neither target-domain labels nor target-domain validation data were used at any stage. Thus, the reported results demonstrate zero-shot generalization to entirely unseen subjects and cohorts without any target-specific adaptation.
[Q3] Fairness of Baseline Evaluation and Statistical Reliability
[A] We clarify the experimental protocol as follows.
The results show statistically significant differences in favor of HOPE on ADNI and ABIDE (p<0.05), while the improvement on PPMI is not statistically significant. This is understandable given the smaller sample size of PPMI (181 subjects) and the relatively modest accuracy improvement of 1.4%p. Nevertheless, HOPE maintains a higher mean accuracy than MuHL across five-seed evaluations on PPMI (75.95% vs. 73.37%), providing complementary evidence of its performance advantage. Together with the five-seed robustness results, these findings provide further support for the reliability of HOPE's performance improvements.