- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates methods for classifying brain disorders using electroencephalography (EEG) and functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS), with the aim of integrating interactions among different anatomical structures while analyzing the working mechanisms of the same functional channel from different structural perspectives. The proposed HHRA model consists of two modules: the HHKC module constructs a pairing map, a supermap of adjacent channels, and an induced anatomical supermap based on phase synchronization values at the channel level. From these three perspectives, information is transmitted between channel nodes via shared weights, and subsequent classification relies on the aggregation of these representations. HFRA integrates the variability of fractional Laplacian features with Fournette curvature into a single node role index and adjusts these indices according to different perspectives. The evaluation included binary classification tasks on three published EEG datasets and one proprietary fNIRS dataset, with results covering AUROC/AUPRC, view combination elimination, calibration elimination, and hyperparameter analysis. The complete model outperformed baseline models on most metrics, but the additional improvement provided by HFRA was relatively limited and did not necessarily constitute a significant advantage.
Critical strengths
-
HHKC can simultaneously leverage higher-order relationships between each pair of connections, neighboring channels, and perceptual interactions between brain regions to represent different structural generalization biases. Appendix Table 3 clearly illustrates the division of brain regions from these three perspectives; while these three perspectives share information propagation parameters, they retain their respective classification representations (§2.1). This enables the method to achieve feasible architectural designs and provides a concrete interface for investigating the role of anatomical prior knowledge in learning brain signals.
-
Table 1 reports AUROC values of 80.65, 92.22, and 88.04 for this method on the ADFTD, APAVA, and M-fNIRS datasets, respectively, demonstrating superior performance across most metrics. Table 2 also shows that the three-view model without HFRA outperforms the listed single-view and two-view configurations on the ADFTD and M-fNIRS datasets. These results confirm the practical value of incorporating structural views and provide strong empirical support for the adoption of this method. However, these results provide stronger support for multi-view modeling than for specific mechanisms of functional role alignment.
Critical weaknesses
-
When using unit node and hyperedge weights, Equation (16) can be simplified to $ \kappa(v_i,e)=|e|-d_i+1, $ where denotes the number of adjacent hyperedges. The first perspective considers edges only when . If all non-diagonal PLV values are positive, a complete graph is formed, yielding $ \kappa^{(1)}(v_i)=4-K,\qquad \exp(-\beta\kappa^{(1)}(v_i))=\exp!\bigl(\beta(K-4)\bigr). $ For a 53-channel M-fNIRS dataset, the multiplier generated by the default value is approximately . Figure 3 also evaluates ; when , the multiplier is , which would cause an overflow if the exponential function were computed directly in float32. The paper does not describe methods for curvature normalization, exponential truncation, logarithmic domain handling, or higher-precision computations. Therefore, these equations cannot fully account for the stable results reported. Table 3 also omits channels 25, 28, and 29; if the implementation excludes these channels from the regional super-edge, the treatment of zero-degree cases in Equations (9) and (17) must be explicitly clarified.
Furthermore, Equation (15) measures the diffusion-related variability in the learned representation; interpreting this as physiologically significant requires validation. The different roles played from different structural perspectives do not necessarily constitute a harmful conflict that should be eliminated. The paper lacks a comparative analysis with simpler consistency regularizers, as well as an explicit assessment of cross-level generalization. These issues directly affect the credibility of the paper’s most distinctive contribution.
-
In Section 3.1, it is first noted that all datasets are partitioned independently by subject. Subsequently, the sample-level segmentation of M-fNIRS is explained. This is because the samples are not organized by subject. The appendix explicitly states that the dataset contains 1,090 subjects. If each sample corresponds to a single subject, then sample-level segmentation is feasible; otherwise, it must be explicitly ensured that there are no duplicate records or duplicate segmentations across different groups. However, in the current description, this point is not explicitly clarified, nor is evidence provided to address this omission.
APAVA includes 23 subjects, while the TDBrain evaluation subset includes 50 subjects. Therefore, using an 8:1:1 split ratio may result in very small independent test queries. An excessive number of time windows does not increase the number of independent subjects, but it remains unclear whether the AUROC/AUPRC statistical units and the five seeds will affect subject-based segmentation methods. As for the cumulative effect of HFRA, more robust statistical evidence is needed to support it. After adding the 3D model, the AUROC for ADFTD increased by 1.14 points, the AUROC for M-fNIRS increased by 0.33 points, and the AUPRC for M-fNIRS decreased by 0.86 points (Table 2). These results indicate potential advantages, but they do not yet demonstrate consistent and universal benefits.
Questions for authors
-
Please explain the exponential multiplier in the complete figure shown above and specify whether this implementation includes sparsification, curvature normalization, exponential clipping, logarithmic domain processing, or any high-precision computations not mentioned. Additionally, please provide the actual values (α) for the three views in a typical training batch, as well as the ranges for the curvature values, convolution exponents, classification loss, weighted alignment loss, and gradient norm. In Figure 3, does the value approach infinity when β is large? If there are discrepancies between the implementation and the formula, please provide a consistent definition and verify the results after making the necessary corrections.
-
With the three-view architecture, classifier, training budget, and subject partitioning fixed, please compare the full HFRA with the non-aligned approach, diffusion-energy-only alignment, and the credible feature consistency regularizer. Please include a standard Laplace control group with to evaluate fractional-order designs. Report paired comparisons and uncertainty estimates, rather than just individual means. Since the role index depends on the amplitude of the representation, also examine whether these gains primarily reflect changes in feature scale.
-
Why should role differences of the same channel across different levels be aligned, rather than retained as complementary information? Please clarify whether this metric estimates model-specific importance or physiological functional importance, and provide corresponding validation—for example, the predicted relationship of its variation under controlled channel or regional perturbations. Please also provide an operational definition of “cross-level generalization.” If this refers to transfer to unseen levels or anatomical regions, appropriate holdout evaluations are required; if it refers to consistency across the three jointly trained views, please adjust the scope of the statement accordingly.
-
Does each M-fNIRS sample correspond to a different, unique subject? Are there duplicate recordings or multiple segments from the same subject? Please provide the number of subjects, categories, and time windows in each partition for every dataset, and clarify whether these five seeds altered the initialization method, the partitioning method, or both. Are AUROC/AUPRC calculated at the time-window level or the subject level? If any subject appears in multiple partitions, the main comparisons must be rerun using a subject-independent partitioning method.