- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper clearly identifies two critical challenges in applying GNNs to brain disorder diagnosis from a neurological perspective. To address these challenges, the paper proposes CPHU, which is an effective automated diagnostic tool for brain disorders. CPHU introduces CPSE to extract path-aware node representation, and HBSU to resolve message-passing conflicts. Compared with existing methods, CPHU achieves superior performance on binary classification tasks across two public EEG datasets, ADFTD and APAVA, and a private fNIRS dataset, M-fNIRS.
Critical strengths
-
CPHU uses both regional information and whole-brain information to model. Specifically, CPSE encodes signal propagation in the regional and whole-brain graphs, and HBSU can aligns semantic representations across these two scales.
-
The HBSU chooses the most discriminative feature dimensions to align semantic consistency. This strategy focuses the consistency constraints on features that are more sensitive to the classification objective, while allowing the remaining dimensions to retain information specific to each view.
Critical weaknesses
-
Directed signal propagation and cross-scale brain modeling have been studied before. The paper does not adequately discuss closely related methods (Shen et al., 2025; Gao et al., 2024). It also lacks comparisons with some relevant methods.
-
CPHU proposes Causal Path Signal Encoding, but the causal paths are not clear. Neither the graph propagation matrix nor the signal flow embedding can demonstrate causal influence between brain regions.
-
Several methodological details remain unclear. For example, the voting mechanism for topology-aware pooling strategy is unclear, and Eq.(14) appears , but in this paper, is not be defined.
-
Evaluating CPHU on only three datasets provides limited evidence of its generalizability, and using only two evaluation metrics provides limited evidence to support its performance.
-
No experiments directly show that the model learns neural signal pathways and resolves message-passing conflicts.
-
The hyperparameter study is inadequate. Some parameters may affect performance, such as propagation iterations P or the smoothing hops K.
-
This paper is not report key training settings, including the optimizer, learning rate, batch size, number of epochs, and so on.
-
The description of the private M-fNIRS dataset is incomplete. The sampling rate, recording duration, and full preprocessing procedure are not reported.
Questions for authors
-
Brain datasets from other modalities, such as fMRI, can also be used to study neural signal pathways. Why were only EEG and fNIRS selected? Can the proposed method be applied to fMRI datasets?
-
Which properties of the graphs constructed using phase coherence make them suitable for modeling neural signal pathways and resolving message-passing conflicts?
-
In Eq. (14), what value of k was used for each dataset, and how was it chosen?
-
The paper addresses neural signal pathway modeling and cross-scale modeling.Could you add methods specifically designed for these two problems as baseline? Such as DSDirGCN-AM (Shen et al., 2025) and LAG (Gao et al., 2024).
-
STAGIN, MDGL, and ALTER are methods proposed based on fMRI. How were these three baselines adapted to the EEG datasets?
REFERENCES Shen, K., She, Q., Yang, X., Gao, Y., and Fan, Y. Dynamic sparse directed graph convolutional network with attention mechanisms for EEG emotion recognition. Neurocomputing, 658:131749, 2025.
Gao, D., Zhang, H., Li, P., Tang, T., Liu, S., Zhou, Z., Ying, S., Zhu, Y., and Zhang, Y. A local-ascending-global learning strategy for brain-computer interface. In Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence, 38(9):10039–10047, 2024.