- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper attempts to integrate Spiking Neural Networks (SNNs), functional connectivity (FC), and effective connectivity (EC) with the hierarchical structure of brain function to establish a unified modeling framework—ranging from brain region activity to functional subnetworks—and validates this framework using the ABIDE, ADNI, and REST-meta-MDD datasets.
Critical strengths
- The research problem is clearly defined, aiming to unify local temporal dynamics, spatial interactions, and hierarchical propagation.
- Systematic comparative experiments were conducted on three datasets, supplemented by multiple sets of ablation studies.
- The authors examined the impact of various factors—such as functional network priors, brain region parcellations, and effective connectivity parameters—on the results.
Critical weaknesses
- Whether the mathematical implementation of functional network priors truly serves a constraining role.
- Whether the so-called "directed information propagation" supports the paper's interpretation of causality and information flow.
- Whether the visualization of spiking activity substantiates the conclusions regarding neurobiological markers.
Questions for authors
-
I notice that the output X_Tout from the Spiking Temporal Brain Encoder module is expected to be a spike train, whereas X_Sout from the Activity-Guide Spatial Brain Encoder has not undergone spiking conversion. How are these two fused in the Directional Hierarchical Propagation Module? X_Tout is a binary sequence (0 or 1) resulting from spiking conversion, while X_Sout appears to be a non-spiking tensor; could the authors please clarify how these two types of data are fused?
-
In Section 3.3, the paper constrains the associations between brain regions and functional subnetworks by employing an anatomical prior matrix, D. The authors argue that this mechanism guides brain regions to aggregate into functionally coherent subnetworks that are neurobiologically plausible. However, a critical issue regarding this design requires clarification: if the prior matrix utilizes binary (0/1) encoding, setting the scores of disallowed associations to zero is not equivalent to completely masking those associations. For instance, a disallowed brain region–subnetwork association might yield a score of zero after multiplication, yet still receive a non-zero weight following the Entmax operation. Consequently, the current formulation may not effectively achieve the prior-based constraint claimed by the authors. Alternatively, if the prior matrix employs continuous similarity values rather than a binary mask, the authors need to explain the value range, normalization method, and the impact on attention allocation.
-
The paper employs transfer entropy (TE) to estimate directed statistical dependencies between brain regions and applies it to analyze information propagation both within and between sub-networks. As I understand it, transfer entropy characterizes directed statistical dependency conditioned on historical information and cannot be automatically equated with true neural causality. Currently, the paper does not sufficiently detail the critical implementation aspects of the TE estimation process.
-
The description of the activity guidance mechanism in the paper mainly stays at the structural level, and it has not yet clearly explained what substantive constraints it introduces compared with the conventional cross-attention mechanism. Since Query and Key come from different data representations, the author should also clarify the input and output dimensions of each projection matrix, as well as the specific brain area relationship corresponding to the attention score.
If the author addresses the questions above, I will raise my score.
3 comments
Author Response (2/2)
Reply to W3. About the neurobiological interpretation of model representations and biomarkers.
We thank the reviewer for this important comment. We agree that model-generated spikes and attention weights should not be directly equated with neuronal firing rates or physiological connectivity strength. Instead, these quantities represent learned temporal responses and interaction weights within the proposed computational framework. Specifically, the spikes generated by our spiking temporal encoder are latent computational events generated from BOLD signals, rather than recorded neuronal action potentials. Each BOLD frame corresponds to a computational timestep rather than a physiological spike timescale. Similarly, attention weights characterize learned interactions between regional activity and connectivity representations, rather than directly measuring physiological connectivity strength. Our interpretability analysis identifies regional and network-level differences that correspond to brain regions and functional systems implicated in previous neuroimaging studies, providing indirect support for their neurobiological plausibility.
Reply to Q1. About the fusion of temporal and spatial representations.
We thank the reviewer for raising this question. We would like to clarify that the output of the Spiking Temporal Brain Encoder, , is not a binary spike train, but a continuous-valued representation obtained by integrating spike-based and continuous temporal features. Specifically, as shown in Eq. (8), the binary spike representation is first transformed through a learnable linear projection , producing continuous-valued features. These projected features are then combined with the continuous inter-segment representation through element-wise multiplication:$ X_T^{out}=X_{\mathrm{Trend}}+ X_{\mathrm{Inter}}\odot(X_{\mathrm{Intra}}W).$
In this operation, the projected spike features modulate the inter-segment representations, allowing local spike-based temporal responses to interact with long-range temporal dependencies. The resulting features are further combined with the continuous trend representation through addition, producing the final continuous-valued temporal output . Subsequently, in the Directional Hierarchical Propagation Module, is projected into the same feature space as the non-spiking spatial representation . The two representations are then fused through element-wise addition:$ X_{st}=W_TX_T^{out}+X_S^{out}, $ where is a learnable projection matrix. This operation integrates complementary temporal dynamics and spatial information into a unified ROI-level representation for subsequent hierarchical propagation. Therefore, the fusion is performed between dimensionally aligned continuous-valued representations.
Reply to Q4. About the mechanism and formulation of activity-guided attention.
We thank the reviewer for this valuable comment. We agree that AGA follows the standard cross-attention formulation. Its distinctive contribution lies in the choice of information sources: queries are derived from regional BOLD temporal representations, whereas keys and values are derived from FC representations. Consequently, the attention weight between ROIs and is conditioned on the temporal representation of ROI and the connectivity profile of ROI . This introduces an activity-conditioned inductive bias, allowing spatial aggregation weights to depend jointly on regional temporal characteristics and connectivity patterns, rather than relying solely on FC features. This design specifies the information sources used for attention weighting and feature aggregation, providing an architectural inductive bias rather than an additional constraint.
Regarding the implementation details, let and denote the BOLD time series and FC matrix, respectively. The temporal and FC embedding layers map and , producing . Queries are generated from temporal embeddings, while keys and values are generated from FC embeddings:
$ Q=H_{ts}W_Q,\qquad K=H_{fc}W_K,\qquad V=H_{fc}W_V, $
where . For each head, attention is computed as
For each attention head, specifies the weight assigned to ROI ’s FC-derived value when updating ROI , conditioned on ROI ’s BOLD temporal features. Here, the FC representation of ROI encodes its connectivity profile with all ROIs. The weights are normalized over key/value ROIs , and aggregation is performed across ROIs within each head. The head outputs are then concatenated and projected to obtain the final spatial representation.
Thank you for addressing my questions—best of luck to you! I will increase my rating.
Author Response (1/2)
We are grateful for the reviewers’ insightful comments. Please find our detailed responses below. We hope our responses adequately address the concerns raised and welcome any further questions.
Reply to W1 & Q2. About the role and effectiveness of functional network priors.
We thank the reviewer for pointing out this important distinction. We would like to clarify that the anatomical prior matrix D is a continuous-valued soft prior which contains continuous spatial similarity scores rather than binary constraints. It modulates the learned ROI-to-subnetwork attention scores before Entmax normalization, thereby introducing an anatomical inductive bias without strictly prohibiting associations with low prior values. Specifically, D∈R200×8 represents the associations between 200 ROIs and eight functional subnetworks, including seven cortical networks and one cerebellar/subcortical community. Before attention computation, we apply row-wise L2 normalization across the subnetwork dimension:
$ \widehat D_{ik}=\frac{D_{ik}}{\max(|D_{i,:}|_2,\epsilon)}, $
where the normalized values lie in [0,1]. The normalized prior is then used to modulate the learned attention scores:
$ \widetilde E=E\odot\widehat D^\top,\qquad W_{\mathrm{attn}}=\operatorname{Entmax}_{}(\widetilde E). $
Therefore, this mechanism provides soft anatomical guidance. The continuous-valued prior modulates the learned attention scores before Entmax normalization, allowing anatomical information to influence the attention allocation without strictly restricting ROI-to-subnetwork associations.
Reply to W2 & Q3. About the interpretation and implementation details of directed information propagation.
We thank the reviewer for this important comment. We agree that transfer entropy (TE) estimated from BOLD signals characterizes directed statistical dependencies rather than true neural causality. Accordingly, the directional propagation in ST-DHPNet refers to computational message passing guided by estimated directional dependencies, rather than direct physiological information flow. Regarding the implementation, TE is estimated from regional BOLD time series during data preprocessing, independently of model training. Specifically, each subject's preprocessed ROI time series is independently standardized and discretized using five states quantile-based binning. Pairwise TE is then estimated in both directions using PyInform, with diagonal entries set to zero. The resulting asymmetric matrix (WEC) satisfies (WijEC=TE(i→j)), where the estimated dependence from ROI i to ROI j is used to guide computational message aggregation.
To further examine the contribution of directional connectivity, we conducted additional experiments using four alternative EC configurations: shuffled, symmetric, transposed, and uniform connectivity matrices. Across ABIDE, ADNI, and REST-meta-MDD, the original TE-generated EC consistently achieved the highest mean ACC, AUC, and SEN. In particular, reversing the connectivity directions or removing directional asymmetry generally reduced classification performance, suggesting that preserving the estimated directional structure provides useful discriminative information. We have added explanations for the TE estimation process and the direction propagation in the revised version.