- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper tries to model the relationship between local temporal events and global brain states. The main hypothesis is that bidirectional prediction between these two representation levels can improve transferable EEG representations. To validate this, they propose BiCSP, which combines frequency-aware processing, regional event encoding, global state aggregation, and 4 self-supervised prediction losses with an EMA teacher. The method then is evaluated on a limited number of EEG datasets using 2 protocals: linear probing and fine-tuning
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
I have serious concerns about the experimental evaluation. The authors only compare with very old methods and miss many strong EEG FM backbones such as LaBraM [1], EEGPT [2], CBraMod [3], REVE [4], and CSBrain [5]. The authors discussed some of these works but never ran any experiments with them. Why don't the authors compare with these stronger baselines? Without these comparisons, I don't find any reason to support acceptance.
-
The downstream evaluation is surprisingly limited. The authors only evaluate on five datasets, but most are related to cognitive states or emotion recognition tasks. There is no motor imagery BCI task such as BCIC-IV-2a, or sleep staging such as SleepEDF, which are common tasks for evaluating EEG FMs.
-
The authors didn't sufficiently validate the hypothesis. The Global State is already obtained by aggregating Event tokens (Eq. 7), while Event-to-State prediction uses the same Event representations to predict a teacher State. For State-to-Event prediction, the predictor also receives visible Event tokens, not just the State. How can we know whether the improvement actually comes from learning bidirectional Event-State consistency? I find this nonsensical.
-
There is no clear description of the pretraining setup: datasets used, # subjects and hours.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.