- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CCA-SRL, which models how local subnetwork features depend on their functional context, then uses deviations from a control-trained model to guide signed graph learning.
Critical strengths
- Context-conditioned deviations provide a useful alternative to treating local subnetworks independently.
- Matched/mismatched contexts, corruption experiments, split-half analyses, and held-out-site checks support the existence of contextual regularity.
Critical weaknesses
- Candidates are mined from diagnostic differences and then selected by disorder–control anomaly-score separation. This is a supervised diagnostic pipeline with normative features; demonstrate that localization remains meaningful beyond selecting discriminative regions.
- Contextual predictability is not necessarily disease-specific. Internal and context features come from the same correlation matrix and may share global strength, motion, or acquisition effects.
Questions for authors
- Are score-reference distributions calibrated separately by candidate, or pooled across heterogeneous candidates?
- Existing work explicitly explores subgraph encodings for brain networks [1-3]. Why these works are not included for discussion and comparison?
[1] Contrastive Graph Pooling for Explainable Classification of Brain Networks. TMI 2024 [2] Long-range brain graph transformer. NeurIPS 2024 [3] Geo-Mamba: Geometry-informed state-space learning of functional brain organization. MIA 2026
5 comments
Question 2
Thank you for pointing out these relevant works. Table N2 reports our comparison with ContrastPool, ALTER, and Geo-Mamba on all three datasets. CCA-SRL has the highest ACC on all three datasets and the highest AUC on OpenNeuro-ds002424 and ABIDE-II; on ADHD-200, its AUC is 63.04%, compared with 63.08% for ALTER. Results are four-fold mean ± standard deviation. -values compare each baseline with CCA-SRL using a two-sided paired -test on corresponding four-fold results ().
Table N2. Comparison with additional baselines.
| Method | OpenNeuro-ds002424 ACC (%) | OpenNeuro-ds002424 AUC (%) | ADHD-200 ACC (%) | ADHD-200 AUC (%) | ABIDE-II ACC (%) | ABIDE-II AUC (%) | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ALTER | 60.89±5.41 | 0.000877 | 67.46±2.40 | 0.010833 | 57.83±4.11 | 0.010715 | 63.08±0.83 | 0.990852 | 56.90±4.68 | 0.047887 | 59.10±3.96 | 0.035624 |
| ContrastPool | 54.81±7.32 | 0.005836 | 54.74±5.88 | 0.000767 | 56.86±2.12 | 0.000232 | 59.86±2.00 | 0.277515 | 54.13±4.06 | 0.012841 | 56.67±3.80 | 0.010957 |
| Geo-Mamba | 55.96±5.84 | 0.003795 | 61.12±2.58 | 0.002752 | 53.15±4.88 | 0.011928 | 53.72±5.93 | 0.035097 | 58.54±3.74 | 0.047823 | 62.94±1.91 | 0.041107 |
| CCA-SRL | 70.38±4.76 | — | 74.52±4.51 | — | 64.33±2.14 | — | 63.04±5.40 | — | 63.07±0.73 | — | 64.19±1.18 | — |
Dear Reviewer n9Eu,
Thank you for highlighting the questions surrounding the clinical interpretation of the identified subnetworks and the relationship of our approach to existing brain graph methods. Following your suggestions, we have provided additional evidence and methodological clarifications:
- Clinical relevance (W1): provided patient–control differences in conditional anomaly scores, a within-patient association with ADHD symptom severity, and supporting evidence from external neuroimaging studies.
- Context-conditioned representations (W2): clarified the motivation and methodological scope of modeling deviations from the healthy relationship between a subnetwork's internal organization and its surrounding functional context.
- Candidate-specific calibration (Q1): clarified that each candidate's anomaly score is calibrated against its corresponding healthy-control reference distribution.
- Additional baselines (Q2): added comparisons with ContrastPool, ALTER, and Geo-Mamba across all three datasets, including paired statistical tests (Table N2).
We would be grateful to know whether these responses address your principal concerns, and we would be happy to provide further clarification on any remaining questions.
Best regards,
The Authors
Weakness 1
Thank you for this question. Diagnostic labels are needed in our candidate-discovery procedure to identify connectivity differences between the disorder and control groups and to select candidates with greater anomaly-score separation. For each selected candidate, the model then compares each subject’s internal subnetwork representation with the expectation given its functional context, using a healthy-control reference. We provide three complementary observations on the disease-related meaning of these deviations:
Patient–control differences. In ADHD-200, the representative four-ROI DMN–DAN candidate has higher mean conditional NLL in patients than in healthy controls (13.248 vs. 6.099; Welch BH-adjusted q=0.00853; paper Appendix I, Table 17). This is a group-level difference for a candidate selected using diagnostic labels.
Within-patient symptom association. Symptom scales were not used for candidate discovery, normality-model fitting, or classifier training. In the OpenNeuro-ds002424 ADHD cases with available symptom scores, we tested the covariate-adjusted association between the conditional anomaly measure and symptom severity (Table N1).
The positive association in Table N1 provides clinical evidence beyond the binary diagnostic labels used for candidate selection.
Table N1. Within-patient symptom association in OpenNeuro-ds002424 ADHD cases.
External literature. Liu et al. [1] report ADHD-related connectivity differences involving bilateral angular gyri and superior parietal lobules in an independent adult cohort, corresponding to the four ROI endpoints in our representative candidate. Norman et al. [2] report altered DMN–DAN connectivity in a large ADHD mega-analysis, consistent with our network-level finding; their cohort includes ADHD-200 participants. These observations provide ROI- and network-level convergence, not independent replication of the exact extracted edges or clinical ground-truth localization.
References
[1] Liu, L., Chen, D., Huang, F., et al. Interference of default mode on attention networks in adults with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and its association with genetic variants and treatment outcomes. CNS Neuroscience & Therapeutics, 30(8):e14900, 2024. doi:10.1111/cns.14900.
[2] Norman, L. J., Sudre, G., Price, J., Shastri, G. G., and Shaw, P. Evidence from “big data” for the default-mode hypothesis of ADHD: a mega-analysis of multiple large samples. Neuropsychopharmacology, 48:281–289, 2023. doi:10.1038/s41386-022-01408-z.
Weakness 2
Thank you for this concern. CCA-SRL identifies disorder-related candidate subnetworks using training-set disorder–control differences. Internal and context features derived from the same functional connectivity matrix may share global, motion, or acquisition-related influences. This research mainly focuses on the role of the conditional relationship between a subnetwork's internal functional organization and its surrounding functional context in brain disease diagnosis. Unlike conventional approaches that primarily characterize connectivity patterns themselves, we investigate how deviations from this healthy context–subnetwork relationship provide disease-relevant information. Specifically, we learn the conditional relationship from healthy controls and quantify subject-specific departures from the expected internal organization given the surrounding functional context, using these deviations to guide whole-brain classification.
Question 1
Calibration is candidate-specific. Each subject’s score for candidate k is compared with healthy-control scores for the same candidate k.