- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
CBT-GCL uses population-level connectivity templates to regularize individual brain-graph representations for ASD classification. Two category-specific templates are constructed with the existing Deep Graph Normalizer using training subjects only. Both templates are added to every individual functional-connectivity matrix, and the fused connectivity profiles are also included in the node features.
During training, an individual-graph encoder and a template encoder produce multi-level representations. Semantic Feature Alignment encourages agreement between individual and label-matched template features. Contrastive Feature Enhancement combines their final representations into an augmented view and applies a supervised contrastive objective. The classifier uses the individual encoder’s low- and high-level features. At inference, the auxiliary template branch is removed, although both fixed templates remain part of the input.
Critical strengths
-
The complete method improves classification results on both datasets.
-
The module ablations support the usefulness of the combined training procedure.
Critical weaknesses
-
The experiments do not adequately isolate the proposed template-guidance contribution. Table 3 compares the complete method with a baseline that has neither CBT guidance nor a contrastive objective. Equations 10–12 use diagnostic labels to attract all same-class representations, so some improvement could come from supervised contrastive regularization independently of the connectional templates. The paper does not report a matched contrastive model without CBT guidance. It also does not compare DGN templates with simpler category-wise connectivity templates or learned class prototypes. These controls matter because the proposed auxiliary branch receives only two fixed category templates, selected by the training label. The existing ablations show that the combined procedure helps, but do not establish why learned connectional templates are needed rather than a simpler class-conditioned regularizer. A direct comparison with the template-registration approach discussed as the main motivation is also absent.
-
The evaluation is too limited to establish that the reported advantage is reliable. Section 4.1 uses a random 70/20/10 split of subjects pooled across sites. Given the dataset sizes, the test partitions contain approximately 110 and 75 subjects. Tables 2, 3, and 5 provide point estimates without reporting repeated splits, seed variability, confidence intervals, or paired comparisons. This is consequential because the AUC improvements over the strongest baselines are only 0.009 on ABIDE I and 0.003 on ABIDE II. I cannot determine whether these differences are stable across reasonable splits and training runs. The template-transfer experiment does not resolve this concern: Appendix G still trains the downstream classifier on ABIDE II and changes only the template source. It is useful evidence about template reuse, but not a test of classifier generalization to unseen sites or populations. The current evidence therefore supports a promising within-dataset result more clearly than the broader robustness and diagnostic claims.
Questions for authors
- Clarification of the existing evaluation: Were the reported numbers obtained from one split and one training run, or averaged over multiple runs? Please provide the exact test counts, split stratification, checkpoint-selection rule, and whether all baseline methods used identical subject partitions. If repeated results already exist, their variability would materially affect my assessment. Assessment-changing control: How does the method compare with the same FC encoder and supervised contrastive objective, but without CBT guidance? An input-fusion-only variant would also help distinguish the effects of adding templates to the graph from those of SFA and CFE.
- Assessment-changing control: Does DGN-based guidance outperform category-wise mean or median connectivity templates, or learned class prototypes, with the downstream architecture and losses held fixed? This comparison is important for assessing the specific contribution of the connectional-template construction.
- Clarification of validation scope: Is there any site-held-out evaluation beyond the pooled random splits? If not, please distinguish template-source transfer from classifier transfer in the conclusions. For any such evaluation, templates and all model-selection steps would need to exclude the held-out sites.
Response to Reviewer ZxYL
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for your constructive comments. We have addressed all the comments with specific explanations and supplemented the corresponding experiments. As the author rebuttal period is coming to an end, we would like to ask if your concerns have been resolved and if you have any further questions or concerns. We would be happy to answer any questions while the discussion remains open.
If our responses have resolved all your concerns, we would greatly appreciate it if you could let us know whether you would reconsider the score for this paper.
Thank you again for your time and valuable feedback.
Sincerely,
The Authors