- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes GPCRLMD, a model for generating all-atom GPCR–ligand trajectories from an initial complex structure. It combines an Atom-Anchored Thermal VAE, which regularizes latent coordinates around input structures, with residual latent flow matching to generate future displacements relative to the initial frame. The model also uses GPCR-specific features, including transmembrane-helix indices and ligand pharmacological classes. The authors evaluate it on 115 sequence-held-out GPCR test systems at multiple trajectory horizons, compare it with BioMD and ensemble-generation baselines, and report improvements on several flexibility, ensemble, and interaction metrics, along with faster inference.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses a relevant and challenging modeling problem. Modeling receptor and ligand motion jointly at all-atom resolution is useful for studying GPCR conformational ensembles. The residual latent formulation and explicit ligand-aware conditioning provide a coherent approach.
-
The evaluation covers multiple systems, horizons, and biological observables. The held-out GPCR evaluation, comparisons with a retrained BioMD baseline, ablations, and analyses of ligand contacts, torsions, and receptor flexibility provide evidence beyond coordinate reconstruction alone. The reported inference cost is also promising for generating ensembles.
Critical weaknesses
-
The evidence supports ensemble matching more directly than kinetic fidelity. Section 1 says the generated motions are “consistent with known ensemble and kinetic properties,” and Section 5.2 claims recovery of essential metastable states. However, most reported metrics compare frame or ensemble distributions: RMSF, Wasserstein/PCA distances, contact frequencies, and Jensen–Shannon divergence of TICA projections. TICA can identify slow modes, but comparing projected distributions does not establish correct transition rates, lagged autocorrelations, or relaxation times. The TM2–TM6 examples are qualitative and do not fill this gap. This matters because the paper presents GPCRLMD as a dynamics simulator and makes claims about kinetic behavior; the current results establish ensemble fidelity more clearly than temporal or kinetic fidelity.
-
It is unclear where the long-horizon energy correction is used, and how it is implemented. Section 4.1 describes Energy-Guided AAT-VAE as an extension, and Appendix E.1 describes gradient-based correction after flow generation. The paper does not say whether this correction is used for the 500 ns results in Table 1, the 1 μs case study in Appendix D.10, both, or neither. It also omits the optimization step count and step size . Finally, the update is written on the generated residual , while the energy is defined on decoded Cartesian coordinates, leaving the optimized variable unclear. These details matter for reproducing the long-horizon results and interpreting their runtime.
Questions for authors
Q1: Do the reported TICA results measure only the distribution of projected conformations, or do they also test time-dependent behavior? Can the authors provide a quantitative comparison of lagged autocorrelation, transition probabilities/rates, or relaxation times on the held-out trajectories? If the intended claim is ensemble generation rather than kinetic simulation, could the claims be scoped accordingly?
Q2: Is the Appendix E.1 energy-guided correction used for the 500 ns results in Table 1, the 1 μs case study in Appendix D.10, both, or neither? If it is used, please specify , , the variable being optimized, whether gradients pass through the decoder, and whether reported runtimes include this step.
3 comments
Response to Reviewer L8vG (2/3)
Table 2: Exploratory kinetic agreement of GPCRLMD using full-protein C$\alpha$ features
| Kinetic evidence | Agreement metric, median [Q1, Q3] | Valid systems |
|---|---|---|
| Implied timescales ↓ | ITS log error: 1.240 [0.994, 1.558] | 105/115 |
| Generator transition rates, ↓ | Rate log error: 0.642 [0.460, 0.867] | 78/115 |
| Completed dwell times ↓ | Dwell log error: 0.613 [0.454, 0.809] | 105/115 |
| MFPT ↓ | MFPT log error: 1.002 [0.858, 1.290] | 105/115 |
| tIC1 ACF relaxation time → 1 | Prediction/GT: 0.156 [0.047, 0.420] | 115/115 |
| tIC2 ACF relaxation time → 1 | Prediction/GT: 0.185 [0.058, 0.595] | 115/115 |
Note: Values are medians [25th, 75th percentiles] across systems. A system is considered valid for MSM transition analysis if its generated trajectory visits at least two of the reference-defined Markov states and contains an observed interstate transition. Lower log errors indicate better agreement (0 = perfect), while an ACF relaxation-time ratio of 1 indicates perfect agreement.
Comparison with BioMD.
(1) MSM Recovery Rate: GPCRLMD exhibits observable interstate transitions in 105/115 systems (91.3%), compared with only 22/115 (19.1%) for BioMD, indicating substantially broader transition coverage in the reference-defined state space.
(2) Paired Error Comparison: On the 22 systems where both methods yield valid MSM transition estimates, GPCRLMD also achieves lower ITS, dwell-time, and MFPT errors (Table 3 below). Although BioMD shows a lower generator-rate error on this small subset, GPCRLMD provides much broader reliable rate coverage (67.8% vs. BioMD's 13.9%), highlighting superior robustness and generative stability.
Table 3: Paired full-protein MSM comparison on commonly valid systems
| Paired agreement metric | GPCRLMD | BioMD |
|---|---|---|
| MSM Recovery Rate | 91.3% (105/115) | 19.1% (22/115) |
| ITS log error, n = 22 | 1.037 | 1.479 |
| Dwell log error, n = 22 | 0.510 | 0.763 |
| MFPT log error, n = 22 | 0.963 | 1.070 |
| Generator-rate log error, n = 16 | 0.774 | 0.529 |
| Reliable rate coverage | 67.8% (78/115) | 13.9% (16/115) |
These results provide complementary evidence that GPCRLMD captures time-dependent conformational changes and interstate transitions more broadly than BioMD.
(3) Limitations of the kinetic analysis
We emphasize that these results should be interpreted as exploratory comparative evidence rather than converged absolute kinetics. Reliable estimation of GPCR kinetics requires extensive sampling of repeated transitions among metastable states. However, the 500-ns MD trajectories used in our training and evaluation datasets provide limited coverage of biologically relevant GPCR state transitions, particularly those involving the inactive–intermediate–active conformational landscape, which can unfold over multi-microsecond timescales. Indeed, none of the reference-MD-derived full-protein MSMs passed the Chapman–Kolmogorov consistency test under the current state discretization, suggesting that even the reference trajectories do not support fully converged kinetic estimates.
We have revised the claims in Sections 1 and 5.2 to clarify the scope of the original TICA results. Furthermore, we have added Section 5.3 in the revised version, which provides quantitative kinetic evaluations of time-lagged autocorrelations, relaxation times, and state-transition statistics, while acknowledging the limitations of estimating converged kinetics from 500-ns trajectories.
Response to Reviewer L8vG (3/3)
(4) Metric definitions
We provide the definitions of the kinetic metrics used in the above analyses. All comparisons are performed in shared, reference-MD-defined state spaces: a two-state space based on the TM2–TM6 distance and a TICA/MSM state space based on full-protein C$\alpha$ coordinates.
We consider five complementary kinetic properties:
- Implied timescales (ITS): characterize slow conformational relaxation processes.
- Continuous-time generator rates: quantify directed state-to-state transition rates.
- Dwell times: measure conformational state persistence.
- Mean first-passage times (MFPTs): quantify the average time required to reach one state from another.
- Autocorrelations (ACF): characterize temporal correlations and relaxation times.
For each protein , all errors were calculated in the shared GT-defined TICA/MSM state space.
-
MFPT log error Let denote the set of directed state pairs . The per-protein MFPT error is:
-
MSM transition matrix satisfies , where is the continuous-time generator matrix. The per-protein transition probability matrix MAE is , and the transition-rate error is
-
Let denote the mean duration of completed dwell events in MSM state . Let denote the states with positive finite completed dwell times in both ensembles. The per-protein dwell-time error is:
-
Let denote implied timescale mode , evaluated at MSM lag time .. Let denote all matched lag-time/mode combinations with positive finite implied timescales in both ensembles. The per-protein ITS error is:
W2&Q2. It is unclear where the long-horizon energy correction is used, and how it is implemented. Whether gradients pass through the decoder, and whether reported runtimes include this step. The paper does not say whether this energy correction is used for the 500 ns results in Table 1, the 1 μs case study in Appendix D.10, both, or neither. It also omits the optimization step count and step size. The optimized variable is unclear.
A2: We thank the reviewer for pointing out this ambiguity. We clarify that the optimized variable is the decoded structure, , in Cartesian coordinate space rather than latent space. Therefore, gradients do not propagate through the decoder.
We have corrected Eq. (10) (Eq. (19) in the revised manuscript) as follows:
In our experiments, we set and . This lightweight energy correction is applied to both the 500-ns trajectories in Table 1 and the 1-μs case study in Appendix D.10. Since the generated frames are optimized in parallel, each 100-ns chunk requires only one correction round (150 optimization steps), taking approximately 0.3–0.4 seconds on a single H100 GPU. The runtimes reported in Table 1 of the main paper already include this energy correction overhead.
Response to Reviewer L8vG (1/3)
A1: We sincerely thank the reviewer for highlighting this important distinction. We agree that the original TICA distribution comparisons evaluate conformational occupancy rather than time-dependent kinetics, and therefore cannot establish accurate transition rates or relaxation times.
To directly address this concern, we introduce two complementary quantitative kinetic evaluations: (1) TM2–TM6 distance-based dynamics and (2) full-protein C$\alpha$-based Markov State Model (MSM) analysis. Both are evaluated on the 500-ns generated trajectories obtained by chaining five 100-ns chunks. These analyses explicitly assess time-lagged autocorrelations, relaxation times, and state-transition statistics against reference MD.
(1) TM2–TM6 distance-based kinetic evaluation
We first evaluate the time-lagged autocorrelation (ACF) of the TM2–TM6 C$\alpha$ distance over physical lags of 0–100 ns. This distance serves as an interpretable measure of receptor opening and is calculated between GPCRdb positions 2×46 and 6×37 for classes A, B1, and C, and 2×44 and 6×31 for class F.
For state-based kinetic evaluation, we discretize this distance into two states (low- and high-distance states) using a system-specific threshold determined by two-means clustering of reference MD distances. The same threshold is applied to GPCRLMD and BioMD. We further evaluate transition probabilities at a 10-ns lag, implied timescales (ITS), dwell times, mean first-passage times (MFPT), and Chapman–Kolmogorov (CK) consistency.
As shown in Table 1, GPCRLMD achieves a lower ACF RMSE than BioMD (0.235 vs. 0.331) and a relaxation-time ratio closer to the ideal value of 1 (2.572 vs. 5.886). GPCRLMD also shows lower median errors across the other kinetic metrics, with valid transition estimates obtained for more systems than BioMD. To the best of our knowledge, faithfully reproducing GPCR–ligand kinetics remains a challenging and largely unresolved task for existing deep generative models. Nevertheless, our results demonstrate encouraging improvements over both BioMD on this challenging task. Representative ACF curves are provided in Fig. 10 of our revised manuscript.
Table 1: TM2–TM6 kinetic comparison across 115 common test systems
Note: Values are medians [25th, 75th percentiles] across the 115 test systems; n indicates the number of systems for which each metric is defined. ACF RMSE measures agreement in the full temporal autocorrelation curve. CK deviation measures the consistency of the estimated two-state dynamics across lag times. JSD measures agreement in the TM2–TM6 distance distribution. State-based statistics are calculated on each method's valid subset.
(2) Full-protein Cα-based MSM analysis
To assess more global conformational dynamics beyond a single receptor-opening coordinate, we additionally perform an exploratory MSM analysis in a shared state space defined from reference MD trajectories, using full-protein C$\alpha$ coordinates as features.
Unlike static TICA occupancy comparisons, this analysis explicitly considers the temporal ordering of conformations. We evaluate implied timescales, continuous-time generator transition rates, completed dwell times, MFPTs, and TICA autocorrelation relaxation times.
The results are summarized in Table 2 below.