- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 3(+1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper reformulates step-by-step state prediction in molecular dynamics as a sequence of composable transformations with explicit physical and geometric structure, enabling parallel trajectory generation through a parallel prefix-scan. The method combines physically structured constraints with parallel computation, with comprehensive experiments reporting improvements in both accuracy and computational efficiency.
Critical strengths
-
Physically structured constraints with a principled mathematical foundation. The method addresses Langevin dynamics with friction and thermal noise by constructing learnable updates using the conformal symplectic group and its Lie algebra, incorporating explicit physical and algebraic inductive biases.
-
Efficient temporal computation. The method organizes local updates into composable algebraic representations and uses a parallel prefix-scan to reduce sequential depth along the temporal dimension, enabling more efficient trajectory generation.
-
Comprehensive evaluation across multiple metrics. Beyond coordinate MSE and RMSD, the paper evaluates interatomic distance distributions, conformal symplectic residuals, and backbone dihedral angles, assessing the structural plausibility of generated trajectories from multiple perspectives.
Critical weaknesses
-
Evidence for physical consistency is largely limited to geometric and conformational statistics. Conformal symplectic residuals, distance distributions, and dihedral angles support structural plausibility but do not establish that the model reproduces the correct stochastic dynamics. Important properties, including temperature and momentum distributions, equilibrium distributions, temporal autocorrelations, and state-transition kinetics, remain insufficiently evaluated.
-
Runtime measurements and reporting require clarification. Some runtimes and speedup factors are inconsistent across the main tables, Figure 6, and the accompanying text. The scope of the reported training times is also unclear.
-
The paper introduces numerous symbols and operations, making it difficult to follow for readers without the relevant background.
Questions for authors
-
Beyond satisfying the imposed geometric constraint, what physical guarantees follow from restricting the updates to conformal symplectic affine transformations? For example, does this ensure the correct temperature distribution, consistency with the underlying potential energy, or other thermodynamic properties? The current evidence appears to rely primarily on geometric diagnostics and the quality of the generated conformations, rather than direct validation of these physical properties.
-
The main text formulates learning as minimizing a path-space KL divergence between full trajectory distributions, whereas the implementation uses positional MSE. Could the authors explain the relationship between these objectives and clarify how the practical training procedure relates to the theoretical formulation?
-
The discussion and evaluation of existing parallel trajectory-prediction methods appear incomplete, limiting the assessment of the claimed acceleration benefits. Could the authors include additional comparisons with relevant state-of-the-art parallel prediction baselines, such as EGNO [1], HEGNN [2], PAINET [3], and FlashMD [4], under a common evaluation protocol?
-
Some reported results appear inconsistent with the stated speedups. The text on page 9 claims an approximately 13× speedup over GLDP, whereas the main tables indicate only approximately 1.1×. Moreover, Figure 6 labels the PVB runtime as approximately 1,150 seconds, which does not appear consistent with the stated 44× speedup. Could the authors reconcile these numbers and clarify the timing protocols?
[1] Equivariant graph neural operator for modeling 3d dynamics
[2] Are high-degree representations really unnecessary in equivariant graph neural networks?
[3] Physics-inspired all-pair interaction learning for 3d dynamics modeling
[4] FlashMD: long-stride, universal prediction of molecular dynamics
3 comments
Q2. The main text formulates learning as minimizing a path-space KL divergence...
We believe this concern stems from an imprecise description in Table 5 and the Training Setup section. We mistakenly referred to the full phase-space state as coordinates, which led to the incorrect description of the training loss and input representation. In fact, the input representation is , and the training loss is computed between and , consistent with the phase-space formulation underlying our theoretical path-space KL objective. We apologize for the confusion and will correct these descriptions accordingly.
Q3. The discussion and evaluation of existing parallel trajectory-prediction methods appear incomplete, ...
The suggested methods address different aspects of learning-based 3D dynamics prediction. In particular, HEGNN primarily focuses on enhancing the expressivity of equivariant representations, while FlashMD accelerates molecular simulations through long-stride state prediction rather than temporal parallelization. In contrast, EGNO and PAINET are more closely aligned with our objective, as they enable parallel prediction of future molecular coordinates.
Accordingly, we conducted additional experiments with these two methods under the same evaluation protocol on ATLAS.
Table 3. Comparison with parallel trajectory-prediction methods on ATLAS.
| Method | MSE ↓ | RMSD ↓ | CSP ↓ | Inference Time (s) ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EGNO | ||||
| PAINET | $9.66 \times10^{-1} $ | |||
| TSL-Flow |
As shown in Table 3, TSL-Flow consistently outperforms both parallel prediction baselines across all evaluated metrics, achieving higher fidelity and lower inference time. This is consistent with the findings of our main experiments.
Thank you for the additional clarification and experimental results, which have addressed most of my concerns. With these results incorporated into the final version, I believe the paper offers a solid theoretical foundation and strong empirical validation. I will therefore raise my score.
Thank you for your careful reading and for raising important questions. We believe the responses below clarify our position and address the points raised in your review. We look forward to continuing the discussion and addressing any remaining questions.
W1/Q1. Evidence for physical consistency is largely limited to geometric...Beyond satisfying the imposed geometric constraint...
Faithful production of MD trajectories requires not only accurate molecular conformations but also consistency with the physical characteristics of the underlying dynamics. In this regard, CSP is included as a physically meaningful measure of consistency with the conformal symplectic behavior inherent in Langevin dynamics, rather than merely as a geometric diagnostic. Together with the established MSE, RMSD, and Pair JSD metrics, our evaluation therefore provides complementary evidence of trajectory accuracy and physical fidelity.
To further substantiate these findings, we conducted additional ensemble distribution evaluations using Root mean W2 and MD PCA W2 on ATLAS, as detailed in Table 1. TSL-Flow achieves the lowest discrepancies across both metrics, indicating improved agreement with the reference molecular distributions.
Table 1. Additional Conformational Distribution Evaluation on ATLAS.
We additionally performed a tICA-based analysis to assess the agreement of slow collective modes between generated and reference trajectories. As shown in Table 2, TSL-Flow achieves the lowest TICA-JSD and TICA-W2 across all compared methods, indicating improved fidelity in the conformational distributions associated with slow molecular motions. These findings are consistent with our main experimental results. The corresponding tICA visualizations are provided in Appendix A.3 of the revised manuscript.
Table 2. Comparison of slow collective dynamics on ATLAS.
W2/Q4. Runtime measurements and...Some reported results appear inconsistent with the stated speedups...
We thank the reviewer for identifying the error in Figure 6. The inference time was measured as the wall-clock time required for each model to generate a trajectory up to the specified number of timesteps. However, some values were inadvertently entered incorrectly in Figure 6, leading to discrepancies in the reported speedup factors. Based on the corrected results, TSL-Flow achieves an approximately 1.4× inference speedup over GLDP, with a substantially larger advantage over PVB. Importantly, these corrections do not alter the overall conclusion of our ablation study regarding the computational advantage of TSL-Flow. We have updated Figure 6 and the corresponding statements accordingly, and appreciate the reviewer’s careful observation.
W3. The paper introduces numerous symbols
The mathematical notation and operations introduced in this work are necessary to rigorously formulate a framework that unifies stochastic Langevin dynamics, conformal symplectic geometry, and Lie-algebraic temporal composition. While we consider these mathematical components essential to the proposed formulation, we recognize that some of the notation may be less familiar to readers from different backgrounds. We will simplify some of the more notation-heavy parts to improve readability.