- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents DNA Flow, an equivariant flow-matching model. It generates a sequence-conditioned heavy-atom ensemble of double-stranded DNA by first generating a centerline row of base-pair frames and modelling per-base rotations and offsets of that rod. It achieves this by embedding inductive biases and domain-specific knowledge into the method. This happens both in the data representation as it's denoised and by splitting the generative modelling load across frequencies. The flow-matching-trained model handles part of the modelling, namely sequence-specific equilibrium modelling. A worm-like chain model models low-frequency modes, and correlated noise models higher-frequency modes. The model is trained on hierarchical chain growth chains, which in turn ensemble chains from atomistic MD fragments.
Regarding contributions, the paper is the first generative deep learning model for DNA conformational ensembles. The method is validated by comparing against aggregate statistics of DNA ensembles, such as phased A-track bending, mean-field R-squared, etc., as well as by well-designed experiments on sequence specificity. A notable absence is comparison to physical force fields, which are the current state of the art.
Critical strengths
The paper fills a relevant gap in the literature: no single generative model generates sequence-conditioned, heavy-atom-resolution double-stranded DNA ensembles.
This work seems to draw on substantial expert knowledge and inductive bias in its design, split across frequency modes, chain representation, and related choices.
Critical weaknesses
It lacks comparisons to baselines commonly used in the field. For instance, Table 1 reports only DNA flow values, and the external comparisons are not very strong. These are either ablations (for instance, using flow matching exclusively for generation) or comparisons to AlphaFold 3, which is a generative model, but it is not necessarily an ensemble generator because it was not trained as one. But the biggest missing pieces are baselines that are well known in the field. For instance, the cgDNA family of coarse-grained MD models. While these models are coarse-grained, they can be backmapped to atomic resolution, which may be expensive and thus worse than the approach presented. Still, this is not obvious, and these comparisons should be made.
As a non-domain expert, I am hesitant to state how certain I am about this weakness. Given that we split the frequencies and model some of the low-band frequencies with a physics-based model that isn't sequence-specific, doesn't that imply the distribution isn't sequence-specific in the long-wavelength range? Sequence specificity only shows up in the parts that are actually modelled by the generative model? That goes against the paper's stated point.
Questions for authors
First, does the method compare with cgNA+ samples rebuilt to atomic resolution with respect to the measures used in the paper to verify DNA flow?
What does DNA Flow offer over running hierarchical chain growth directly on a new sequence, and how do the two compare in cost?
Is my assessment of long-range, sequence-dependent bendability correct? If so, how could it be successfully modelled? Why can't it be modelled? Does it matter that this isn't modelled?
4 comments
Thank you for the detailed response and the substantial new experiments. They answer my questions, and I appreciate how openly the revision now states the method’s limits.
I continue to value the methodological contribution. Splitting the deformation field by spatial frequency and giving each band its own generative mechanism is a clean idea. The plain-CFM ablation shows it matters for a learned generator, and bringing this class of model to DNA opens a space that so far had no learned atomistic ensemble generator.
My concern about practical utility remains, which is not necessarily disqualifying, as a methodological contribution does not necessarily always beat SOTA. By your own numbers, a rigid-base Gaussian performs better on base-pair statistics and length transfer, has comparable sampling cost to HCG, and produces fewer clashes. DnaFlow’s advantage over such a baseline therefore rests on its atomistic decoding and its ability to be fine-tuned.
One experiment would clarify this. Decode the Gaussian’s rods with DnaFlow’s strand head (computing the latent and rod embedding from those rods), and compare against DnaFlow end-to-end on D7 and clash counts. With the decoder held fixed, any difference isolates what the learned rod trunk contributes. If the two arms perform similarly, the contribution is best framed as a learned backmapper with a physics-structured prior. If DnaFlow’s own rods do better, that makes a much stronger case for the learned generator.
If the experiment does not fit in the discussion period, I would encourage including it in the final version.
Decoding the Gaussian's rods with DnaFlow's strand head
Decoding the Gaussian's rods with DnaFlow's strand head
Thank you for the positive assessment and for proposing this experiment. We ran it, and the revision reports it in App. A.25 (Table 13), next to the Gaussian it uses.
Setup. The paper checkpoint is unchanged. The rigid-base Gaussian of App. A.25 draws one rod per member, which replaces the rod trunk's output; the latent is computed from that rod as in training, and the strands sit on that rod (median deviation of the read-back frames below 5×10⁻³ for every sequence). We scored Table 1's held-out sequences, 5 per length with 200 structures per arm, with on the base-pair frames read back from the decoded strands and clashes per 100 bp (MolProbity 0.4 Å, heavy atoms) before minimization. The reference's own rods, decoded the same way, are the control.
| N (bp) | DnaFlow end to end | Gaussian rods + DnaFlow decoder | reference rods + DnaFlow decoder |
|---|---|---|---|
| / clashes | / clashes | / clashes | |
| 20 | 0.048 / 19.3 | 0.027 / 17.3 | 0.017 / 11.5 |
| 60 | 0.045 / 20.7 | 0.029 / 16.0 | 0.019 / 12.1 |
| 80 | 0.048 / 22.4 | 0.024 / 15.8 | 0.015 / 12.1 |
| 110 | 0.073 / 35.3 | 0.030 / 17.6 | 0.024 / 13.0 |
Result. DnaFlow's strand model is agnostic to the source of its rod. On the Gaussian's rods it gives a lower by 25–60 % at every length and fewer clashes; after the reference library's minimization (App. A.21) the clash counts come much closer (3 sequences per length: Gaussian rods 11.0 vs DnaFlow 11.2 at 40 bp, 10.0 vs 12.3 at 80 bp).
The learned rod trunk therefore adds no accuracy over rigid-base statistics on our reference, and the revision presents DnaFlow accordingly: the strand model composes heavy atoms onto a rod from either the spectrally divided generator or rigid-base statistics. The learned generator is needed where the rod itself has to be trained, as in end-to-end fine-tuning to MD (App. A.26), and spectral division is what makes it work (App. A.22).
Thank you for running this experiment so quickly and for reporting the result plainly.
As I read Table 13, decoding the rigid-base Gaussian’s rods with DnaFlow’s strand model gives a lower D7 at every length and fewer clashes than DnaFlow end-to-end. On this reference, the learned rod trunk therefore adds no accuracy over rigid-base statistics, as the revision now states. I appreciate that the manuscript has been reframed accordingly.
The experiment also shows that the strand model works on rods from another source. I find that useful in its own right, since it could make rigid-base models such as cgDNA atomistic at little cost. In the new framing, however, this decoder becomes the paper’s main contribution, and it has not been compared with standard rebuilding of rigid-base samples into atoms.
I am not yet convinced by the remaining case for the learned generator: fine-tuning to MD. On held-out HexABC sequences, a Gaussian refitted to the MD performs on par with the fine-tuned model (App. A.26). With a decoder that accepts any rod, refitting the Gaussian and then decoding would need no training at all. The only evidence that a trained rod helps is a single 33-mer. I think for the future direction of this project, if the authors were to show that experimental data or high-fidelity MD could be used as training data and that this model could then serve to amortise sampling after having been trained, it would be a much more tangible use case, but I feel this is a different submission.
I still value the methodological idea, and the care the authors have shown throughout the discussion. I keep my score.
Response to Reviewer Et9i
Response to Reviewer Et9i
We thank the reviewer for a clear review and for recognizing the gap DnaFlow fills. We added explicit-solvent MD and a model of the cgDNA class. That Gaussian reproduces our training data's base-pair statistics better than DnaFlow, while DnaFlow generates heavy-atom ensembles and adapts to MD. The long-wavelength point is half right: the mean shape is sequence-specific, the fluctuation amplitude is not.
Comparison to physical force fields. For a 33-mer that no model had seen, against 3 µs of parmbsc1 explicit-solvent MD (App. A.21; lower D7 and higher log-likelihood mean closer to the MD; raw output):
Fine-tuned on half of 170 HexABC sequences, DnaFlow reproduces the other half with a field R2 of 0.874 and a log-likelihood of 0.722 nats/step, close to a Gaussian fitted to the same MD (0.896 and 0.709). Trained on these data alone, it reaches a log-likelihood of only 0.162, so pretraining matters.
W1 / Q1 (cgDNA, cgNA+). We added a cgDNA-class Gaussian (per-context mean and variance, nearest-neighbour couplings), fitted once to our training data, so that model class and force field are not confounded, and once to the HexABC MD, which is closer to how cgNA+ is parametrized. On our reference it beats DnaFlow on base-pair statistics (D7 0.023–0.035 vs 0.036–0.058 up to 100 bp; App. A.25). Against the 33-mer MD, the HCG-fitted Gaussian scores D7 0.090 and log-likelihood 0.89 (DnaFlow 0.068 and 0.95), and the MD-fitted one 0.062 and 0.93 (fine-tuned DnaFlow 0.042–0.045 and 1.11–1.12); this is one sequence. The Gaussian yields base-pair frames only; DnaFlow yields heavy-atom strands, and its sequence field leads k-mer tables (R2 0.866 vs 0.823 / 0.846 for tetramer / hexamer; a second training seed leads the hexamer table by only +0.008). We did not run cgNA+ itself or back-map its samples. AlphaFold3 is not an ensemble model, as the revision now states; it remains only a learned atomistic reference point.
W2 / Q3 (long wavelengths). The mean of the low band is sequence-specific: the latent is drawn as z∼N(μ^(seq),σp2). Phased A-tracts show this: their bend accumulates over about 7 helical turns (31.2°, against 32.2° for a hexamer law of the training data) and follows an independent MD law per step (r = 0.77; −0.24 with the base embedding re-drawn). The fluctuation amplitude σp is set per mode for all sequences. We expect this to matter less for mixed sequences, whose long-wavelength stiffness averages the local stiffness, and more for long A- or GC-rich blocks; a sequence-conditioned σp(seq) is a direct extension (App. A.9).
Q2 (DnaFlow vs running HCG). Per 1000 all-atom conformers of the 33-mer, HCG takes 15.8 min on one CPU core and DnaFlow 1.1 min on one GPU. HCG parallelizes, so about 15 cores match the GPU, and the cost is comparable. DnaFlow needs no fragment library at inference, is a differentiable sequence-conditioned generator, and adapts to a new reference, here MD, from 85 sequences.