- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents OctMole, a multiscale framework for 3D molecular generation based on hierarchical octree representations and flow matching. The proposed method first generates molecular spatial occupancy in a coarse-to-fine manner and then predicts atom types and continuous local coordinates. The authors evaluate the approach on QM9 and GEOM-DRUG and demonstrate promising results in molecular quality, generation efficiency, and spatial conditioning.
Critical strengths
-
Interesting and relevant research topic. The paper addresses an important problem in 3D molecular generation. Exploring multiscale spatial representations is a promising direction.
-
Clear presentation. The paper is generally well-written and easy to follow.
-
Reasonable architectural design. The use of hierarchical octree grids is intuitive and well-motivated. Progressively refining spatial occupancy from coarse to fine provides a natural way to capture molecular geometry while avoiding the computational overhead of dense voxel representations. The separation between occupancy generation and atom-level generation is also a reasonable design choice.
-
Promising empirical results. The proposed method achieves strong results on QM9 and GEOM-DRUG, particularly in molecular stability and connectedness on GEOM-DRUG. The experiments on spatial conditioning and the efficiency comparisons with dense voxel representations further demonstrate the potential of the framework.
Critical weaknesses
- Discussion of related works. The paper could provide a more comprehensive discussion of recent hierarchical molecular generation methods, such as [1]. Although the generation settings may differ, a discussion of the similarities and differences would help clarify the novelty of OctMole.
[1] Hu, Jiapeng, et al. Hierarchical Multi-Scale Molecular Conformer Generation. ICLR 2026.
- Ablation of the hierarchical occupancy flow. It is unclear how much of the improvement comes specifically from flow matching rather than the octree representation or the continuous atom-coordinate decoder. It would be helpful to compare the proposed flow-matching approach with an autoregressive approach under the same octree representation and atom decoder, such as [1].
[1] Shuqi Lu, Haowei Lin, Lin Yao, Zhifeng Gao, Xiaohong Ji, Yitao Liang, Weinan E, Linfeng Zhang, and Guolin Ke. Unified cross-scale 3D generation and understanding via autoregressive modeling.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors clarify the main methodological differences between OctMole and existing hierarchical molecular generation approaches, particularly the work by Hu et al. (ICLR 2026)?
-
How much of the empirical improvement can be attributed specifically to hierarchical flow matching? Would alternative occupancy-generation methods achieve comparable results when using the same continuous atom decoder?
-
What causes the relatively low uniqueness on QM9? Is there evidence that the model memorizes training molecules, or is the decrease primarily caused by candidate selection?
2 comments
Thanks for the response from the authors. I will keep my positive rating.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive questions. We clarify the hierarchy and provide a new fixed-decoder comparison and molecule-level diversity analysis.
1. Relation to Hu et al. (ICLR 2026). Both methods use coarse-to-fine generation. Hu et al. generate conformers conditioned on a given molecular graph, with a hierarchy of chemical substructures such as scaffolds. OctMole performs de novo generation of atom counts, types and coordinates. Our hierarchy is a spatial partition: progressively finer octree occupancy defines the support for continuous atom generation. We have added this comparison to the related-work discussion.
2. Autoregressive occupancy with the same atom decoder. Following your suggestion, we feed depth-6 (64^3) support from the official Uni-3DAR checkpoint into our default GEOM-DRUG atom decoder. (Both use the same physical box and cell size; aligning their coordinate systems requires only a translation.) This hybrid method uses OctMole's atom-confidence reranking, retaining approximately 20% of candidates, comparable to Uni-3DAR's native selection rate (20%).
Below, each method has 10,000 final samples evaluated identically, without clash-atom removal or coordinate optimization; validity requires whole-graph sanitization.
Distribution distances (lower is better; length in Å, angle in degrees):
Molecule stability (%) by atom count:
(The AR groups have very few samples above 55 atoms, so conclusions rely on the better-populated bins.)
The hybrid improves molecule stability over native Uni-3DAR by 2.42 points. OctMole further improves molecule stability by 6.27 percentage points and improves all six distribution distances over the hybrid. Its stability advantage persists within size bins. The hybrid retains the AR support's small-molecule bias because its atom count is determined by Uni-3DAR.
These results demonstrate a contribution from our occupancy generator beyond the atom decoder.
3. QM9 uniqueness and training-set overlap. Both overfitting and candidate selection contribute. On equal-size 10k QM9 sample sets, OctMole's uniqueness drops from 98.54% before selection to 80.80% after selection. We also compared generated molecules against the training set using canonical SMILES. Both generated samples and the full training sets are evaluated without clash-atom removal or coordinate optimization; validity requires whole-graph sanitization. Training overlap counts generated samples matching the training set, with valid samples as the percentage denominator.
QM9:
GEOM-DRUG:
We acknowledge molecular-identity memorization on QM9: reranking strongly favors training molecules and amplifies overfitting, plausibly related to its small training set (~100k). On GEOM-DRUG (~5.54M training conformations), OctMole retains 99.98% uniqueness and 99.715% novelty among valid reranked samples, with lower training overlap than Uni-3DAR both before and after selection. Thus, the QM9 limitation does not persist on the larger dataset. We have replaced the original speculation with these quantitative findings.