- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents MOSAIC, a hierarchical generative modeling approach for molecule and materials design. By assigning atoms to local spatial slots while retaining continuous coordinates, MOSAIC aims to improve locality, controllability, and scalability. The approach is demonstrated on molecular generation and polycrystalline materials, including autoregressive assembly of systems containing more than one million atoms.
Critical strengths
- The same representation is applied to rather different molecular and materials settings allowing some degree of generality.
- Scalability to generation of polycrystalline structures with >1M atoms.
- The molecular experiment shows that local support can substantially improve connectivity compared with a global-anchor baseline.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty relative to existing hierarchical spatial generators is insufficiently established. The paper itself identifies Uni-3DAR as the closest prior work, which already uses hierarchical spatial decomposition and fine-grained coordinates. MOSAIC appears to differ mainly in its mesh-anchored slot representation, continuous local displacements, and its use within diffusion/flow-based generation.
- The manuscript could be simplified substantially. The relatively simple central idea is surrounded by considerable architectural and application-specific detail, confusing the main contributions.
- Molecular generation performance is not competitive with the strongest presented baseline: MOSAIC reaches 77.2% connected-valid versus 84.7% for MegalodonFlow, with a particularly large gap in PoseBusters validity (54.1% vs. 89.8%). The latter points at fundamental issues with respect to downstream usability for molecular design.
- The million-atom experiment demonstrates computational scalability, but provides less evidence for physical fidelity at that scale. More analysis of structural defects, relaxation stability, energies, or accumulation of autoregressive boundary errors would strengthen this result.
Questions for authors
- What is the precise capability enabled by MOSAIC that cannot be achieved with Uni-3DAR or a similar hierarchical spatial representation? Given that Uni-3DAR is identified as the closest prior work, why is there no direct comparison?
- Could the authors disentangle the contributions of hierarchical spatial support, continuous within-cell coordinates, multiple slots per cell, and the local coordinate prior?
- Spatial conditioning seems to require substantial prior knowledge of the desired structure—for example, desired group centers for molecules or prescribed grain morphologies and orientations for polycrystals. How useful is this form of conditioning when the spatial arrangement itself is unknown and should be discovered?
- How does error accumulate during autoregressive block assembly, and how physically stable are the resulting million-atom structures after relaxation?
4 comments
Author response to diPo
W4. Physical fidelity of million-atom generation
Thank you for highlighting the need for stronger physical validation. We have now performed EAM potential energetics, all-mobile relaxation and boundary-resolved analysis on a 1,116,011-atom generated structure. After 3,000 relaxation (FIRE) iterations with the Ni99 potential, without deleting atoms, energy decreases from −1.978 to −4.290 eV/atom, FCC order increases from 26.32% to 46.05%, and the fraction of atoms with neighbours below 2 Å falls from 23.375% to 0.279%, approximately an 84-fold reduction. Minimization reached the iteration limit with residual contacts and forces. These results demonstrate substantial structural recovery; however we acknowledge that converged equilibrium and stability remain unestablished.
Q1. Novelty and capability relative to Uni-3DAR
Thank you for raising this question. We have addressed this in detail in W1.
Q2 Decomposing effects of support, continuous coordinates and prior.
Thank you for suggesting this clarification. The components serve distinct roles, which our experiments separate as follows: • Spatial support (existing ablation) Stage 1 allocates atom counts from coarse to fine while preserving the requested total. Our submitted matched EGNN comparison holds this hierarchy fixed: changing spatial support and its coordinate prior jointly raises connected validity from 24.3% to 65.9%. • Local prior (new): Using a shorter, matched training budget of 150,000 updates, we compare Gaussian and cell-uniform priors with identical predicted supports and matched coordinate variances. On 50 matched GEOM requests, they produce 27/50 and 25/50 connected-valid molecules, with nearly identical atom stability (81.20% and 81.25%). We therefore observe similar aggregate performance between the two prior families. • Continuous coordinates(new): On 1,000 generated molecules and 1,000 real GEOM conformers, rounding to 0.05 Å largely preserves validity, while 0.20 Å reduces it to 6.6% and 8.9%, respectively. This highlights the role of continuous offsets: the coarse mesh organizes space, while fine within-cell positions preserve bond geometry and molecular connectivity. • Multiple slots: Several atoms often occupy the same 3.2 Å cell. With only one slot per cell, only one could be represented and the remaining atoms would be missed. Multiple slots retain all these atoms. We will clarify these differences in the revised manuscript and add these additional ablations.
Q3 Importance of spatial conditioning and what happens without it?
Thank you for raising this critical fundamental question. In our molecular model, Stage 1 generates the spatial layout and local occupancies from atom count alone; therefore spatial prompts are optional for the molecular generation presented in the manuscript. However, our view is that fully unconditional sampling is not a sufficient objective for large, heterogeneous atomistic systems. Importantly, such information can be available before a complete atomic structure is known. Cryo-EM provides experimental three-dimensional electrostatic-potential maps of protein complexes, informing their shape and atomic organization (Pfab et al., 2021); X-ray diffraction-contrast tomography measures three-dimensional grain shapes and orientations (Ludwig et al., 2009); and phase-field simulations produce evolving morphology and orientation fields (Pusztai et al., 2005). We aim to complement progress in unconditional generation of small systems by addressing the spatial organization and controlled assembly needed for large, heterogeneous atomistic structures, something SOTA misses. We therefore regard generation conditioned on experimental or physically evolved spatial information as a central scientific objective, with the generator supplying just the unresolved atomic detail.
- Pfab, J., Phan, N. M., & Si, D. (2021). DeepTracer for fast de novo cryo-EM protein structure modeling and special studies on CoV-related complexes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118(2), e2017525118.
- Ludwig, W., Reischig, P., King, A., Herbig, M., Lauridsen, E. M., Johnson, G., Marrow, T. J., & Buffière, J.-Y. (2009). Three-dimensional grain mapping by X-ray diffraction contrast tomography and the use of Friedel pairs in diffraction data analysis. Review of Scientific Instruments, 80(3), 033905.
- Pusztai, T., Bortel, G., & Gránásy, L. (2005). Phase field theory of polycrystalline solidification in three dimensions. Europhysics Letters, 71(1), 131–137.
Author response to diPo
Q4 Error accumulation during block assembly.
Reciprocal descriptors repeatedly estimated from generated predecessors become unreliable. In our generated 1X8X8 block diagnostic, replacing them with reference-derived reciprocal fields raises FCC from 13.36% to 31.75% and reduces PTM ordered-fraction error from 0.474 to 0.278 (Fig. F 2a,b). The reported million-atom assemblies instead use persistent prescribed grain fields, with phases translated consistently between block origins. An audit of these fields gives 86.22° mean phase inconsistency without correction versus numerical precision with correction (Fig. F2c). This avoids repeated descriptor estimation; generated boundary atoms remain autoregressive inputs. Across three million-atom assemblies, each containing 3,375 blocks, we find no consistent monotonic FCC collapse with generation order. Local structural errors nevertheless remain concentrated near block interfaces. We will add these ablations in the revised version along with Figure F2 in the supplementary material.
Link to rebuttal figures
Author response to diPo
We would first like to thank you for taking the time to review our work. We appreciate your recognition of the improvements enabled by local support, the representation’s applicability across molecular and materials settings, and its computational scalability to systems containing over one million atoms. We address your concerns and questions point by point below.
W1. Novelty relative to Uni-3DAR and other hierarchical spatial generators
Thank you for highlighting the need to make this distinction clearer. The main methodology distinction is how MOSAIC and Uni-3dAR address the generation problem as the system size grows. Uni-3DAR compresses spatial structure into a token sequence and generates through an accumulating autoregressive history. MOSAIC instead assigns multiple continuous particles to coarse spatial addresses and jointly generates the current molecule or block.
The resulting advantages compared to Uni-3DAR are direct spatial control (key functionality) and bounded active context(memory efficient scaling). Spatial fields allow local editing and chemical-group placement. Such control is important for molecular inpainting in drug discovery (Schneuing et al., 2024) and positioning functional motifs in protein design (Watson et al., 2023). For largescale generation like the nickel assembly, each block uses bounded local context, keeping active neural memory independent of the assembled structure’s size. Uni-3dAR to our knowledge doesn’t show such largescale demonstrations. Our molecular implementation is also compact, 15.18M Mosaic versus 89.64M parameters for Uni-3dAR, with lower measured memory, latency and higher connected validity in the matched GEOM comparison (Fig F1). Also, we have now directly evaluated Uni-3DAR on 256 matched-count GEOM pairs using a common evaluator and the Figures are placed in Fig. F1 in the document supplied with this rebuttal. Our comparison scores every raw output from both methods, without the likelihood-based candidate ranking and selective retention used in Uni-3DAR’s reported protocol. MOSAIC achieves 89.1% connected-valid generation versus 81.3% for Uni-3DAR, a paired improvement of 7.81 percentage points. On the same MI300A GPU within each pair, the median paired Uni-3DAR/MOSAIC latency ratio is 1.37 for a fixed number of atoms, including both MOSAIC stages and the peak allocated memory is 225 versus 442 MiB. Uni-3DAR is faster for the smallest molecules. We will clarify these differences in the manuscript and add the direct comparisons shown in Fig F1 to the revised Supplementary Information.
W2. Simplifying the presentation
Thank you for this helpful suggestion. We agree that the central idea should stand out more clearly. We will reorganize the method around this representation moving other domain-specific scientific details on architecture, nickel conditioning constructions and some other information to the appendix.
W3. Comparison and gap with MegalodonFlow
Thank you for highlighting this quality concern of the model. The purpose of the MegalodonFlow comparison is to contextualize the improvement achievable through spatial addressing and the purpose of the EDM derived backbone is to test how much an older, comparatively simple EDM-derived generator can improve through a simple change in spatial representation. MegalodonFlow provides a strong modern SOTA reference, explicitly co-generating coordinates, atom types, bonds and formal charges(unlike MOSAIC EDM). This comparison contextualizes the gains achievable through spatial addressing, while our matched-backbone ablation measures the contribution of local support and its coordinate prior directly. MegalodonFlow remains stronger on the reported molecular-quality endpoints, particularly PoseBusters, but MOSAIC nevertheless offers 3.07× connected-valid throughput under the tested schedules, together with spatial control. Its representation is independent of the particular molecular backbone used here.