- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper addresses the task of predicting a MOF structure (the lattice, fractional center, and rotation of each block) from building-block (number and molecular graphs). The authors build on MOF-BFN, retaining its lattice and periodic-center prediction, and changing its rotation representation from quaternions to four “anchor” atom coordinates per block. Rigid rotations are recovered by Kabsch alignment. This improves the loose match rate from 36.4% to 39.8% and the strict match rate from 9.86% to 12.36%.
Strengths
Weaknesses
The methodological novelty is limited, as the contribution primarily changes the orientation representation using established components. The choice of four anchors is heuristic; three non-collinear points suffice in the noiseless case but are not tested. Noise produces nonrigid configurations that must be projected back to rigid poses.
The improvement over the controlled baseline is modest, and the results depend on the configuration. A supplementary control favors Bingham rotation states under different readout and supervision choices.
Critical strengths
The approach is geometrically motivated: the same angular error causes different atomic displacements depending on block size and shape. Anchor coordinates incorporate this dependence but doen't preserve block geometry (requires projection).
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty is limited. The method only tweaks the orientation representation. Further, there is no clear argument for why four anchors should be the best rotation representation. It even comes with downsides, like that noise produces nonrigid configurations that must be projected back to rigid poses.
-
The improvement over the controlled baseline is minor. In Appendix C.6, Table 12 the anchors performs even worse then the Bingham (quaternion) rotation states.
Questions for authors
- Why are three anchors not tested? Three points should suffice (as long as they are non-collinear) in the noiseless case.
- Can you ablate the representation (between Bingham quaternions and Gaussian anchors) separate from the noise schedule? They use different native noise processes, but one could match spatial noise throughout the trajectory?