- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces AtomSteer, a test-time framework for enforcing structural constraints in pretrained atomistic generative models without retraining. It corrects intermediate endpoint predictions through structure-dependent projections and incorporates accepted corrections into the original sampling process. Experiments on molecular conformers, protein–ligand complexes, and crystals demonstrate improvements in geometric validity, stereochemical accuracy, and crystallographic constraint satisfaction.
Critical strengths
-
The framework enables structural constraint steering without retraining or architectural changes, making it applicable to existing pretrained diffusion and flow models.
-
The structure-dependent projections are well motivated: local coordinate corrections, rigid-fragment rotations, and rigid-body transformations address different violations while protecting surrounding geometry.
-
Experiments across molecular conformers, protein–ligand complexes, and crystals demonstrate broad applicability, with improvements in geometric validity, stereochemical accuracy, and crystallographic constraint satisfaction.
Critical weaknesses
-
The experiments do not sufficiently isolate the contribution of intermediate endpoint projection. A controlled comparison using the same projection operators only after generation is needed, together with ablations of the projection schedule, rigid-fragment corrections, and acceptance checks.
-
The computational cost is insufficiently evaluated. Repeated geometric optimization introduces additional overhead, while the baselines use different particle counts and optimization procedures. Wall-clock measurements and quality–cost comparisons under matched computational budgets are needed to establish practical advantages.
-
The method relies on numerous task-specific choices, including residual definitions, projection schedules, displacement bounds, and acceptance thresholds. Their sensitivity is not systematically examined, leaving unclear how much tuning is required when transferring the framework to new models or constraints.
Questions for authors
none
Final Remarks by the Authors
Dear Area Chair, Program Chairs, and Reviewers,
As the discussion period ends, we thank the reviewers for constructive engagement. Below, we summarize AtomSteer's contributions and the discussion period's key outcomes.
AtomSteer is a test-time framework that steers pretrained atomistic diffusion and flow matching models with structural constraints, without retraining. Each constraint is a residual on the atomistic graph, paired with a structure-dependent projection that moves only the atoms needed to reduce the violation. For example, AtomSteer corrects E/Z stereochemistry by rotating the whole substituent, resolves ligand-protein clashes, and enforces space group symmetry in periodic crystals.
The same framework improves four pretrained models:
All three reviewers recognized AtomSteer's broad applicability, and both reviewers who engaged with our rebuttal raised their ratings to 3.
Reviewer 3nxw found that AtomSteer addresses "an important problem in atomistic generation" and "achieves substantial improvements on several key metrics." Their requests concerned controlled comparisons, computational costs, and the contribution compared with PCFM. Projecting during sampling outperforms applying the same projections only to the final structures (45.2% vs 39.4% Success@1+stereo on Boltz-2), and each projection improves the constraint it targets (Appendices R1 and R2). PCFM projects with a Gauss-Newton step on the full state. Applying the Gauss-Newton control experiment lowers PB-valid on ET-Flow to 66.98%, against 96.93% for AtomSteer (Appendices R2 and R7). Following the reviewer's suggestion, Appendix R3 now describes AtomSteer's efficiency and its comparison with other approaches. The reviewer credited "the detailed comparison between PCFM and AtomSteer" and raised their rating to 3.
Reviewer qKwL described AtomSteer as a "practical and general test time framework" with "strong empirical improvements" that are "consistent across different backbone models." Their requests concerned computational efficiency against unconstrained sampling followed by post hoc correction or filtering, and a more general recipe. Post hoc correction reaches a joint rate of 4.2% on the triangular motif against 30.7% for AtomSteer, and filtering would need 109x and 307x as many samples to match it on the Kagome and triangular motifs (Appendices R1 and R3). Every constraint follows one recipe: a structural residual, structure-dependent projections, bounded corrections, and an acceptance check (Appendix R5). The reviewer has not followed up to our responses but maintains their rating of 3.
Reviewer zmpQ noted that AtomSteer "enables structural constraint steering without retraining or architectural changes," that its "structure-dependent projections are well motivated," and that the experiments "demonstrate broad applicability." Their requests concerned ablations of the projection schedule, wall-clock comparisons, and the tuning required for new models. Correcting every 8th step on ET-Flow retains AtomSteer's gains at 2.0x the time of vanilla sampling (Appendix R3). The transfer to a new model on molecular crystals, CLARI, required no retuning (Appendix R5). Following the discussion, the reviewer raised their rating to 3.
The revised PDF marks changes in blue, where Appendices R1-R7 hold the new experiments, a comparison with related methods (R6), and the comparison to PCFM (R7).
We appreciate the reviewers' thoughtful engagement, which has helped clarify and strengthen the paper's central contribution: AtomSteer is a general test-time framework that pairs each structural constraint with a structure-dependent projection, across molecules, protein-ligand complexes, inorganic crystals, and now molecular crystals. We will incorporate all promised revisions into the final version.
Thank you very much!
Warm regards,
The Authors