- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
ApoFlowMol is a model based on flow matching for jointly designing novel 3D ligands while evolving the apo pocket of the protein. The authors introduce ApoFlowMol$\chi$ fixing N–C$\alpha$–C updating side chains torsions and ApoFlowMol-Link to preserve chain-linked backbone and side-chain peptide kinematics connectivity by construction. They evaluated the model on the Apo2Mol benchmark. Additionally, they show that lead guided side-chain flexible docking can directly produce adapted pockets that improve downstream for fixed pocket generators (like FLOWR) without any retraining.
Critical strengths
ApoFlowMol provides principled geometric guarantee to preserve the peptide C-N connectivity, trying to address a failure mode in flexible pocket generators.
Even though the general concept is known, they provide insights in how this pocket adaptation guided by sidechain flexible docking, can directly offer advantages using fixed-pocket generator (FLOWR) without any retraining of the model.
Critical weaknesses
-
In table 1, the improvements on the vina scores are small −7,90 vs −7,74 kcal/mol. I see that this can be a limitation with the data itself.
-
In table 1, ApoFlowMol-Link-SDE shows QED 0.39, SA 0.32 and LogP −1.51, mismatching the data distribution QED 0.60 SA 0.77 LogP 2.05, and getting worse scores compared to Apo2Mol QED 0.54 SA 0.54 LogP 3.60. This suggest that the small improvements over docking scores estimates cause significantly worse scores on metrics such as drug likeness.
-
In table 2, FlexDock seems to outperform the main contribution on some metrics. I think that limiting the results to 100 systems can reduce the statistical power of the results.
-
The kinematic reconstruction for C-N is not learnt for the peptide-link geometry (sec 4.2 line 376). I would better frame this aspect as an architectural guarantee rather than empirical result in the paper.
-
No comparison of sampling cost vs baselines. An ablation showing inference time costs and scaling the model at different sizes is missing. This makes it hard to compare to the existing alternatives.
-
The comparisons omit several recent flexible pocket methods despite being discussed in related works: DynamicFlow, FlexSBDD, DrugFlow.
-
The RdKit molecular validity and PoseBuster valid on the generated molecule are not reported anywhere.
Questions for authors
-
Will code, trained weights and data be released?
-
I see that the references sometimes follow different formats, ie they sometimes present or not present the url. Can you uniform that?
-
I think that table 5 in the appendix has an inconsistent abbreviation Ave/Med. In the rest of the paper you use "Avg." "Med.".
-
Can you provide matched budget comparisons for FlexDock vs ApoFlowMol-Link?
-
Why does SDE sampling produce such poor LogP and SA values providing slight improvements on Vina docking scores?
-
Can you provide more insights into how does the hierarchical architecture scale with pocket size? and what is the inference time per complex comparing your method to other recent methods like Apo2Mol, YuelDesign, and FLOWR?
-
Would it be possible for completeness to report the results on the full test set of 478 systems? This would also contribute to validate how reliable it is your initial subset of 100 systems.
-
How sensitive are results to t>0.65 threshold for activating interaction losses? Did you try to tune it in your setting? It would be interesting to see an ablation on this parameter.
Response to Reviewer
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. We address each weakness and question below.
Responses to Weaknesses
W1. Small docking improvement.
We agree that the Vina improvement is modest. Our main contribution addresses geometrically constrained pocket adaptation alongside ligand generation, further evaluated in Table 2 (Page 8).
W2. Molecular-property trade-offs.
We acknowledge the lower QED/SA and shifted LogP. Considering ligand properties and docking performance together, we regard ODE as the stronger overall configuration. SDE's molecular-property performance remains a limitation.
W3. FlexDock and evaluation size.
FlexDock is explicitly presented as a separately budgeted analysis (Table 3, Page 9). We consider the 100-system evaluation sufficient for the comparisons reported in this study.
W4. Architectural guarantee.
We agree. Peptide-link preservation is described as a property of the kinematic construction (Pages 4–5), distinct from empirical pocket-quality checks.
W5. Sampling cost.
We added runtime comparisons with Apo2Mol, YuelDesign, and FLOWR (Appendix G.10, Pages 33–34; Table 19A, Page 36).
W6. Additional baselines.
At submission, our search did not identify publicly available code and trained weights enabling reproducible comparisons with DynamicFlow and FlexSBDD.
W7. Molecular validity.
Table 2 (Page 8) evaluates 500 original attempts per method. Link-ODE achieves 82.0% RDKit-valid and connected outputs and 64.6% confirmed PoseBusters passes, versus 87.4%/26.4% for Apo2Mol and 39.8%/13.0% for YuelDesign.
Responses to Questions
Q1. Resource release.
Yes. We plan to release code, trained weights, and evaluation resources through GitHub and an open-access repository such as Zenodo after acceptance.
Q2. Reference formatting.
Thank you. We have standardized the reference formatting, including URL presentation.
Q3. Abbreviations.
We have standardized the table abbreviations to "Avg." and "Med."
Q4. Matched-budget FlexDock comparison.
Table 19B (Page 36) now reports key FlexDock timings: docking takes 8.98–17.24 seconds for one previously selected lead per pocket, and pocket export takes 0.76–1.05 milliseconds. Ranking, preparation, rescue searches, and FLOWR generation are excluded. The initial protocol evaluates three leads per interaction center, each with three independent docking seeds (Table 19B, Page 36). Total cost therefore depends on screening success; this is not a matched-total-budget comparison.
Q5. SDE molecular properties.
We have not yet determined the cause of the lower LogP and SA values in Link-GR-SDE. Our results show an empirical trade-off between docking scores and molecular properties. Considering these metrics together, we regard Link-GR-ODE as the stronger overall configuration for direct generation.
Q6. Scaling and inference time.
Table 19A (Page 36) covers 92–445 pocket heavy atoms and 12–34 ligand heavy atoms. Link-GR-ODE takes 1.17–2.57 seconds per molecule and is fastest in seven of nine settings under native sampling settings, excluding external postprocessing.
Q7. Full test-set evaluation.
Our current computational resources do not permit completing the 478-system evaluation within the discussion period. We acknowledge this limitation.
Q8. Interaction-loss threshold.
We adopted t>0.65 from DynamicFlow without tuning or a threshold ablation. Its sensitivity remains unquantified.