- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2(−1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2(−1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents MolLIFT, a joint 1D–3D Bayesian Flow framework for pocket-conditioned molecular generation. The proposed method introduces a local-frame lifting mechanism that transforms SMILES-derived features into explicit SE(3)-equivariant coordinate corrections. It further incorporates a 3D-to-SMILES feedback pathway to enable bidirectional interaction during generation. Experiments on CrossDocked demonstrate competitive improvements in binding affinity, molecular properties, and diversity.
Critical strengths
-
Geometrically motivated cross-modal architecture. The proposed Local-Frame Lifting (LFL) mechanism provides an interesting approach to incorporating 1D chemical information into 3D molecular generation. Unlike conventional scalar feature fusion, it introduces an explicit equivariant vector pathway for coordinate correction. The mathematical analysis of SE(3)-equivariance is also a strength of the paper.
-
Competitive experimental performance. MolLIFT achieves promising results across several molecular generation metrics. The matched-capacity comparison and existing ablation studies provide useful evidence for the benefits of geometry-aware interaction and explicit coordinate lifting.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient ablation of bidirectional interaction. The Invariant 3D-to-SMILES Feedback (IFB) module is an important component of the proposed bidirectional framework. However, the paper does not independently evaluate its contribution. Without a dedicated w/o IFB ablation, it remains unclear how much the reverse feedback pathway contributes beyond the SMILES-to-3D interaction.
-
Limited evidence for meaningful chemical–geometric correspondence. Although the proposed method improves generation performance, the evidence that LFL learns meaningful relationships between SMILES information and 3D coordinate corrections remains incomplete. Appendix F describes shuffled-SMILES and token-permutation controls, but Figure 5 only reports correct-versus-null comparisons. These additional results would help establish whether the improvements depend on chemically relevant sequence information rather than simply the presence of an additional conditioning pathway.
Questions for authors
Q1. Contribution of IFB Could the authors provide a dedicated w/o IFB ablation to clarify whether bidirectional interaction provides measurable improvements over one-way SMILES-to-3D guidance?
Q2. Chemical–geometric correspondence Could the authors report the shuffled-SMILES and token-permutation experiments described in Appendix F? In particular, it would be valuable to demonstrate that chemically correct SMILES information leads to more accurate and directionally meaningful coordinate corrections than mismatched or permuted sequences. Additionally, could the authors clarify whether similar benefits are observed when using the model's own generated SMILES beliefs rather than ground-truth SMILES?
Q3(Minor). Methodological distinction Appendix E acknowledges that scalar cross-attention can preserve SE(3)-equivariance. Could the authors clarify the additional representational or empirical benefits of explicit local-frame vector lifting over scalar-conditioned equivariant generation? A more focused discussion of related approaches, including LiFT, NExT-Mol, and MolSculpt, would help position the contribution.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer ZxHM (Part 2/2)
Q3-1: Could the authors clarify the additional representational and empirical benefits of explicit local-frame vector lifting over scalar-conditioned equivariant generation, given that scalar cross-attention can also preserve SE(3) equivariance?
A3-1: We agree that scalar cross-attention can preserve SE(3) symmetry; our distinction concerns how sequence information reaches coordinate space. In w/o LF, the SMILES message is incorporated only through invariant scalar atom features and influences coordinates indirectly through later equivariant layers. W/o Vec retains the local-frame-aware scalar interaction but removes the explicit coordinate message. Full MolLIFT additionally predicts invariant coefficients and maps them through an atom-centered equivariant frame using , where contains the invariant coefficients predicted from the SMILES message, is the atom-centered local frame, and is a learnable scale.
Under a rigid transformation , the coefficients remain invariant and the local frame transforms as . Consequently, the complete coordinate message satisfies . Translation does not appear in this transformation because the coordinate message is a displacement vector constructed from relative geometry. The module therefore converts invariant sequence information into a direct SE(3)-equivariant displacement without introducing a global reference frame.
| Method | Cross-modal pathway | Vina Score Avg. | Vina Min Avg. | QED | SA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| w/o LF | Vanilla scalar attention | -6.68 | -7.13 | 0.51 | 0.67 |
| w/o Vec | Local-frame-aware scalar fusion | -6.85 | -7.25 | 0.52 | 0.68 |
| MolLIFT | Scalar fusion + explicit vector lifting | -7.01 | -7.37 | 0.54 | 0.68 |
The progression from w/o LF to w/o Vec to MolLIFT separates the two effects. Introducing local-frame-aware scalar fusion improves average Vina Score from -6.68 to -6.85 and Vina Min from -7.13 to -7.25. Restoring the explicit vector message further improves them to -7.01 and -7.37, respectively, while QED increases from 0.52 to 0.54. Thus, geometry-aware scalar fusion is useful on its own, and explicit vector lifting provides a further empirical benefit beyond scalar-conditioned equivariant generation. Appendix F now clarifies this distinction and provides the equivariance argument, including the degenerate-frame fallback.
Q3-2: Could the authors provide a more focused comparison with related 1D–3D approaches, including LiFT, NExT-Mol, and MolSculpt, to clarify the methodological positioning of MolLIFT?
A3-2: We expanded both the Introduction and Appendix A. NExT-Mol integrates a pretrained SELFIES language model with diffusion-based 3D conformation generation from molecular sequences. MolSculpt extracts chemical knowledge from a frozen molecular foundation model through learnable queries and injects it into a 3D diffusion model. LiFT incorporates language-derived SMILES priors into pocket-conditioned flow matching through semantic conditioning and adaptive velocity-field modulation. These methods establish the value of sequence priors for geometric generation.
MolLIFT focuses on a different cross-modal interface: the SMILES belief and 3D ligand states evolve jointly in one Bayesian flow, and information is exchanged bidirectionally at every generation step. The forward pathway uses the local protein–ligand environment to retrieve token information and converts invariant sequence-derived coefficients into explicit equivariant coordinate updates. The reverse pathway projects geometric progress into invariant local-frame features that refine the next SMILES belief. The combination of co-evolving states, direct local-frame coordinate lifting, and invariant reverse feedback is the methodological distinction now emphasized in the revision.
The authors have addressed most of my concerns through the additional experiments. Some limitations remain, particularly the lack of guaranteed consistency between the generated SMILES and the final 3D structures. Nevertheless, the rebuttal has strengthened the paper, and I find the improvements sufficient to raise my rating to 3.
Response to Reviewer ZxHM
We thank the reviewer for their thoughtful evaluation and recognition of our additional experiments. We acknowledge the remaining limitation regarding consistency between the generated SMILES and the final 3D structures, and will clarify this limitation in the revised manuscript. We appreciate the constructive feedback, which has helped us improve the paper.
Response to Reviewer ZxHM (Part 1/2)
We sincerely thank the reviewer for their time, careful assessment, and valuable feedback. We appreciate the recognition of MolLIFT's geometrically motivated design, equivariance analysis, and competitive performance. Please see our point-by-point responses below; revisions are marked in blue.
Q1: Could the authors provide a dedicated w/o IFB ablation to clarify whether the bidirectional interaction provides a measurable improvement over one-way SMILES-to-3D guidance?
A1: We added w/o IFB in Table 2 and Section 4.2(v). It disables only 3D-to-SMILES feedback while retaining local-frame-aware scalar interaction and the explicit SMILES-to-coordinate vector message.
Restoring IFB improves every reported metric. This isolated comparison shows that the forward pathway provides the larger performance gain, while invariant reverse feedback contributes an additional measurable improvement by refining the SMILES state used in subsequent flow steps.
Q2-1: Could the authors report the shuffled-SMILES and token-permutation experiments described in the appendix, and examine whether chemically meaningful sequence information produces more accurate and directionally meaningful coordinate corrections than mismatched or permuted sequences?
A2-1: Appendix H.1 and Figures 6–7 now report the random token-permutation and within-batch reassignment controls. In every paired evaluation, we hold the pocket, noisy 3D state, denoising time, coordinate and atom-type beliefs, and stochastic realization fixed. For a control condition b, coordinate improvement is defined as Δb=Eb−Etrue, while negative transfer is defined as NTRb=Pr(Etrue>Eb). Positive coordinate improvement and directional alignment, together with lower NTR, indicate more useful and reliable sequence guidance.
Randomly permuting the correct token order preserves sequence length and composition while disrupting molecular serialization. Its result is consistent with the null control: during most intermediate and late stages, MolLIFT produces larger coordinate improvements, stronger directional alignment, and lower NTR than w/o LF, while w/o Vec is generally intermediate. These results indicate that the learned coordinate guidance is sensitive to meaningful SMILES organization, rather than simply benefiting from an additional input branch.
Within-batch reassignment replaces the condition with another complete molecular sequence. It produces coordinate differences close to zero over most time bins, weak and non-monotonic alignment, and NTR near 0.5. This control changes molecular identity and composition simultaneously and may supply another chemically valid sequence containing transferable composition-level cues. It is therefore an instance-correspondence test rather than a guaranteed negative ligand. The token-permutation experiment provides the cleaner controlled evidence that the learned coordinate guidance depends on meaningful sequence organization. We therefore explicitly delimit the scope of our claim: these results support the utility of informative, correctly organized sequence guidance, but the current training objective does not explicitly enforce one-to-one ligand identity discrimination.
Q2-2: Could the authors clarify whether similar benefits are observed when the model uses its own generated SMILES belief states rather than ground-truth SMILES?
A2-2: Appendix H.2 and Figure 8 remove access to the reference SMILES. For 100 test molecules, the SMILES receiver starts from a uniform prior. At each flow step, the model predicts a soft clean-token distribution, which is incorporated into the current SMILES belief by the categorical BFN receiver. The updated belief is then passed to the next step. Consequently, the belief evaluated at time tk contains the complete model-generated history from t=0 to tk. No reference token or discretized argmax SMILES is supplied, and the accumulated soft belief enters the 3D branch directly.
Against a null sequence on the same controlled reference-anchored 3D trajectory, MolLIFT gives positive coordinate improvement from t=0.25 onward. Directional alignment rises from 0.065 at t=0.25 to 0.818 at t=0.85, while NTR falls from 0.46 to 0.00 and remains 0.02 in the final bin. W/o LF instead becomes negatively aligned after t=0.6 and reaches 0.90 NTR in the final bin. These results demonstrate that path-consistent, model-generated SMILES beliefs provide useful directional guidance without ground-truth SMILES once sufficient geometric information has accumulated. We use the reference-anchored trajectory only to provide a clean coordinate target for this controlled measurement.