- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies molecular diffusion for structure-based drug design. MEGA defines Gaussian coordinate marginals and categorical atom-type parameter trajectories under a shared signal schedule, and uses continuous Concrete observations for joint denoising. The authors also introduce GeoRank, which assigns persistent atom ranks from clean ligand geometry during training and uses randomly assigned ranks during generation. Experiments on CrossDocked2020 evaluate binding scores, molecular quality, and geometric distribution fidelity.
Critical strengths
-
The MEGA results are encouraging. Table 1 shows strong Vina scores together with improvements in PoseBusters validity and conformational strain over the compared methods. The ablations in Appendix H also provide useful evidence for the contribution of the chosen schedule and continuous atom-type observations.
-
GeoRank provides an interesting way to introduce geometric organization during high-noise denoising. It achieves improvements in bond-length, bond-angle, functional-group, and ring distributions, with additional category-wise analyses supporting the geometric gains. The paper also clearly explains how geometric ranks are used differently during training and generation.
Critical weaknesses
-
The large effect of the forward corruption schedule would benefit from further explanation. In Appendix H, replacing the proposed schedule with Linear reduces PB-valid from 89.5% to 48.6% and increases median strain energy from 84.67 to 1302.21. These results support the chosen configuration, but provide limited insight into why this replacement causes such substantial degradation or which properties of the proposed schedule improve molecular geometry.
-
The specific contribution of geometric ordering in GeoRank could be more clearly established. Appendix J compares virtual-anchor and spectral orderings, but both use clean ligand geometry. A control trained with geometry-independent persistent ranks and the same adapter would help distinguish the contribution of geometric information from persistent slot identities and additional message passing. The current results support GeoRank's distributional gains more directly than this particular explanation of their source.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors explain the large performance gaps between the proposed schedule and the Linear/Cosine variants in Appendix H, and confirm whether their training budgets and evaluation settings are matched? An analysis of SNR trajectories or denoising errors across noise levels could help explain these differences.
-
Can the authors compare GeoRank with ranks sampled independently of ligand geometry during training and held fixed throughout corruption, using the same adapter, time gating, and training budget?
-
Does GeoRank's denoising advantage mainly occur at high noise levels? Appendix E.4 reports losses averaged over sampled diffusion times; a comparison across noise levels would more directly support this motivation.
-
Could the authors further discuss the trade-off between GeoRank's improved geometric JSDs and its worse Vina scores, strain energy, and SA? In what settings would GeoRank be preferable to MEGA alone?
-
Could the authors consider including MolPilot [1] in the comparison, given its relevance to scheduling for SBDD? A comparison under consistent dataset splits, post-processing, and evaluation settings would help contextualize MEGA's results.
[1] Qiu et al., Piloting Structure-Based Drug Design via Modality-Specific Optimal Schedule, ICML 2025.
Thanks for the Rebuttal
I appreciate the authors’ detailed rebuttal and the additional controlled experiments, which substantially strengthen the empirical justification for MEGA’s key design choices and address several of my concerns.
However, I remain concerned that the proposed method primarily integrates existing techniques, and its independent methodological novelty is still not sufficiently established.
Overall, I acknowledge the improved empirical evidence and will raise my score accordingly.