- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TangentMol (Local Tangent Consistency) for few-step 3D molecular generation. It addresses the inconsistency between continuous coordinates and discrete chemical structures (atom types, bonds, charges) during large single-step updates in diffusion models. Validation on GEOM-Drugs and CrossDocked shows that TangentMol (teacher-free, solver-free) significantly improves chemical validity, stability, and distribution quality, outperforming baselines with strong ablation support.
Critical strengths
The paper crisply identifies the continuous-discrete consistency gap as the dominant failure mode in few-step 3D molecular generation and resolves it through a unified local tangent objective obtained from a single joint JVP, pairing Euclidean regression for coordinates with a logit-shift softmax target for the three categorical fields. Because the formulation is a pure training-time additive loss that leaves architecture, backbone, and sampler untouched at inference, the reported gains admit a clean attribution absent from most concurrent diffusion-Mol works. This is borne out empirically: TangentMol retains state-of-the-art connected validity, molecular stability, and FCD at the practically relevant extreme operating points (4/8/16 NFE on GEOM-Drugs; 10–30 steps pocket-conditioned on CrossDocked), precisely where VEDA, FlowMol2, and FlowMol3 collapse, while preserving geometric fidelity (strain energy, bond-length alignment) instead of sacrificing it for discrete correctness.
Critical weaknesses
A notable strength of TangentMol is that the tangent loss is presented as a plug-and-play regularizer, which makes the broad framing in the introduction—covering both equivariant diffusion and flow-matching generators—natural and appealing. However, the current experimental suite does not yet substantiate the full scope of that claim: every TangentMol-trained model uses VE-diffusion backbones (VEDA-FS / PocketVE), while FlowMol-family models are only evaluated as unchanged external baselines. The authors acknowledge that porting to flow-matching requires adapting the shared JVP direction and the categorical transition targets. I would encourage minimal series experiments in the revision (or a clear timeline in the rebuttal) that includes the flow-matching instantiation trained with the proposed loss under matched settings.
Questions for authors
Q1. Hyperparameter selection protocol
The paper reports and (with RMS normalization) as the optimal setting, obtained from a grid over QM9 4-step. Was this grid evaluated on a proper held-out validation split, or directly on the same test split that produces the main Table 1 numbers?
Q2. Transfer assumption for flow-matching
Does the current TangentMol instantiation rely on VE-specific properties, or is the 'plug-and-play' design expected to reuse the same RMS normalization () for flow-matching backbones?
Q3. Revision suggestion
I encourage including flow-matching training (not just baselines) in the revision.
Thank you for the authors' response. My concerns have been addressed, and I will raise the score.