- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This work introduces a mismatch-aware flow-matching framework to refine molecular conformer predictions. This model can be trained and then applied without per-model tuning. When the refiner is applied RMSD-based conformer ensemble metrics improve.
Critical strengths
- The application of the refiner is well describes and does result in small reduction in steps
- Extensive ablations on the impact on the refiner on the set benchmarks and evaluated mdoels.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper discusses the goal of generating low energy conformers yet energy-based benchmarks are not performed [1, 2]. This work should also be benchmarked against and discussed as it related to low energy structures and energy-based benchmarks.
- Given the focus of the work is to introduce a new flow matching theoretical framework why isn't this applied to other tasks like for example 3D molecule generation Protein design or images? With only the AMR benchmarks with known flaws and minor improvements its hard to understand if this is hacking the benchmark or there is generalizable theoretical value for structure-based diffusion or flow refiners.
- Does not compare against AverageFlow[3] (both DiT non SE3 equivariant, and Nequip based)
[1] LoQI https://chemrxiv.org/doi/full/10.26434/chemrxiv-2025-k4h7v/v3 [2] https://pubs.rsc.org/dd/article/4/11/3282/889094 [3] AvgFlow https://arxiv.org/html/2507.09785v1
Questions for authors
- How does the refiner impact the energy metrics presented in [1]. In general its hard to assess the impact of the refiner as computational chemists do not use RMSD to know if the conformer is good or not as at test time you often do not have a reference as that is the whole point of the model.
- How do the Coverage results change as a function the delta? Do stricter cutoffs lessen or improve the impact of the refiner?
- How does the refiner work when applied to Average Flow at 1,2, and 100 steps?
- How does the refiner compared to xtb relaxation in both energy, rmsd, and time cost?
8 comments
W2 Study Scope We thank the reviewer for encouraging us to consider other tasks, which helps us clarify the rationale and scope of our method. Our explanation is based on the representations used to predict coordinate updates. With a fixed molecular graph, relative atomic geometry can remain similar to that encountered during training even when the assigned time does not match the actual coordinate-error scale. We have revised Section 3.3 to discuss this mechanism further and added a Monte Carlo analysis in Appendix O to provide supporting evidence. Across 20 groups of one million trials, the results for the error interval [−0.1, 0.1] are:
| Two-pixel RGB descriptor (%) | Atom-pair distance (%) | Three-atom angle (%) |
|---|---|---|
| 0.00440 (0.00160) | 5.63084 (0.02621) | 25.72525 (8.91133) |
Values are mean(std) across groups. The interval is measured in normalized intensity units, Å, and radians, respectively. A pixel hit requires all six channel errors to fall within the interval simultaneously. Under these simulation settings, distances and angles satisfy the interval criterion approximately 1,280 and 5,850 times as often as the joint RGB descriptor. Many coordinate configurations share similar distances or angles, supporting the possibility of encountering familiar local geometry despite time mismatch. Image-restoration studies [1] show the initial noise scale to zero from degraded images produces blurry outputs high FID. why successful refinement without added noise cannot be assumed to transfer directly to images.
Extending the method to other tasks requires studying whether their representations remain robust under time mismatch. We view conformer refinement as a particular setting whose geometric representations can support this behavior. Identifying which tasks and representations permit such refinement, and where it fails, is an interesting direction for future research.
[1] Ohayon, Michaeli, and Elad. Posterior-Mean Rectified Flow: Towards Minimum MSE Photo-Realistic Image Restoration. ICLR 2025. Paper
Q2 the performance under standard delta cutoff
We thank the reviewer for suggesting an evaluation across coverage thresholds, which provides a more comprehensive assessment of the Refiner’s effectiveness. The conventional cutoff of δ = 0.5 Å is relatively permissive for QM9: median COV-R is already 100% for all baselines below, and median COV-P is 100% for most of them. This limits its ability to distinguish improvements in geometric accuracy. We therefore use δ = 0.05 Å to provide a more discriminative evaluation.
Following previous work, we also report results at δ = 0.5 Å. Our refiner achieves the best performance
| Method | COV-R Median (%) ↑ | COV-R Mean (%) ↑ | COV-P Median (%) ↑ | COV-P Mean (%) ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OMEGA | 100.0 | 85.5 | 100.0 | 82.9 |
| GeoMol | 100.0 | 91.5 | 100.0 | 86.7 |
| GeoDiff | 100.0 | 76.5 | 33.5 | 50.0 |
| Torsional Diffusion | 100.0 | 92.8 | 100.0 | 92.7 |
| MCF-B | 100.0 | 95.0 | 100.0 | 93.7 |
| DMT-B | 100.0 | 95.2 | 100.0 | 93.8 |
| Etflow | 100.0 | 95.4 | 100.0 | 92.8 |
| Etflow + Refiner | 100.0 | 95.8 | 100.0 | 94.4 |
W1/Q1: Energy-based evaluation
Thank you for raising this point. We agree that RMSD alone is insufficient to assess the physical quality of generated conformers. We already report an energy-related evaluation in Appendix D, “Chemical Property,” Table 6,
Following the protocol of Jing et al. (2022), we evaluated the same 100-molecule subset, selecting min(2K,32) generated conformers for a molecule with K reference conformers. After GFN2-xTB relaxation, we compare the generated and reference ensembles in terms of energy (E), dipole moment (μ), HOMO–LUMO gap (Δϵ), and minimum energy (Emin).
Median absolute errors in ensemble properties. Ensemble averages use Boltzmann weighting; Emin compares the ensemble minima. E, Δϵ, and Emin are in kcal/mol, and μ is in Debye. Lower is better.
The Refiner reduces the energy error from 0.68 to 0.20 for MCF-L and from 0.23 to 0.21 for ET-Flow. The minimum-energy error also decreases from 0.04 to 0.02 and from 0.02 to 0.01, respectively. These results provide evidence of improved agreement with reference energy statistics beyond RMSD.
We further report chemical-property errors before xTB relaxation. As shown in following tables, our refiner (20+20 steps) consistently reduces all reported errors relative to baseline (50 steps) under both uniform and Boltzmann weighting, demonstrating improvements in the generated conformers before geometry optimization.
Median errors with uniform weighting, before xTB relax.
Table 2. Median errors with Boltzmann weighting at 298.15 K, before xTB relax optimization.
Before xTB relaxation, our refiner consistently reduces all reported chemical-property errors relative to ET-Flow under both uniform and Boltzmann weighting, indicating improvements beyond geometric similarity.