- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a post-generation selection framework for molecular conformer sampling that aims to build compact conformer ensembles with high coverage and precision under a fixed output budget. Instead of improving the generative models themselves, the authors focus on selecting representative conformers from an oversampled candidate pool produced by frozen, pretrained generators.
The proposed framework consists of three main components: (1) a reference-likelihood classifier that estimates the probability of each candidate matching a reference conformer, (2) a latent reference-field inference method to estimate the distribution of unseen reference conformers, and (3) a redundancy-aware greedy selection strategy that balances coverage and precision. Based on this framework, the authors introduce CovSelect, which prioritizes coverage, and RefSelect, which provides a tunable trade-off between recall and precision.
Experiments on GEOM-DRUGS demonstrate improved conformer coverage compared with existing generative baselines, while RefSelect achieves a better recall–precision balance. Additional evaluations on out-of-distribution datasets, independently generated reference conformers, and different output budgets further demonstrate the effectiveness and generalizability of the proposed selection framework.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is well-structured and clearly written. The proposed framework is presented in a logical and coherent manner.
-
The observation that existing generative models may already produce diverse conformers but struggle to retain representative structures under a fixed output budget provides a compelling motivation for the proposed selection framework. This perspective highlights the importance of post-generation selection as a complementary direction to improving generative models.
-
The paper provides a relatively comprehensive experimental evaluation across multiple datasets, including GEOM-DRUGS and several out-of-distribution benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
-
Although the proposed method demonstrates improvements under a fixed output budget, the experimental comparisons do not control for the actual number of generated conformers. Specifically, CovSelect and RefSelect select 2n conformers from an oversampled pool of approximately 16n candidates, whereas the raw generative baselines directly produce only 2n conformers. This discrepancy raises concerns about the fairness of the comparisons, as the observed improvements may be partially attributed to the substantially larger candidate pool rather than the effectiveness of the proposed selection strategy. Consequently, the current experiments do not fully establish the method's advantages under comparable computational budgets.
-
The paper lacks a comprehensive analysis of the computational overhead introduced by the proposed framework. Beyond generating a larger candidate pool, the method requires feature extraction using pretrained interatomic potentials, pairwise RMSD computation, reference-field inference, and greedy selection. However, the paper does not report the corresponding runtime, computational costs, or scalability. Without these measurements, it is difficult to assess the practical benefits of introducing an additional selection stage, particularly when compared with directly generating more conformers using existing models.
-
The methodological novelty appears somewhat limited, as the proposed framework primarily combines existing techniques, including gradient-boosted classification, Richardson–Lucy deconvolution, and facility-location-based greedy selection. More importantly, several key modeling choices are not sufficiently justified. For instance, the reference-field inference relies on a Poisson approximation, but the paper provides limited theoretical or empirical evidence supporting this assumption. Similarly, the choice of the coverage kernel and its influence on the inferred reference distribution are not thoroughly investigated. Given the availability of alternative probabilistic models and kernel functions, a more systematic analysis is needed to establish the necessity and robustness of these design choices.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors clarify how much of the reported improvement comes from the proposed selection strategy rather than the substantially larger candidate pool? Would the proposed method still outperform the baselines under matched generation budgets?
-
What are the computational and runtime costs of the proposed framework, including candidate generation, feature extraction, reference-field inference, and greedy selection? Does the improvement in conformer coverage justify the additional computational overhead compared with directly generating more conformers?
-
What motivates the use of a Poisson approximation for modeling the reference distribution? How sensitive is the method to this assumption and the choice of the coverage kernel? Would alternative probabilistic formulations or kernel functions yield similar results?
I will increase my scores if the author provides enough evidence.