- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a molecular conformer ensemble learning framework. It models pairwise relationships between corresponding local structures across conformers. The method also introduces symmetric and antisymmetric relational tensors, together with geometry-aware message passing and also a singleton-centered residual. I find the idea clear and interesting, but have some concerns remained about the method novelty and experimental evaluation.
Critical strengths
- The paper is well organized and the motivation is easy to understand: instead of only pooling conformers, it tries to model aligned local relationships across conformers.
- The method is technically detailed, and the theoretical properties of the proposed operator are stated clearly.
- The empirical study covers multiple molecular property prediction benchmarks and includes several controls rather than only a main-table comparison.
Critical weaknesses
-
The idea of explicitly modeling pairwise relationships across conformers is relatively interesting, but the novelty should be better clarified. For example, the tensor operations are largely adapted from existing constructions. Then, the prior work has already considered cross-conformer interactions, which leads that it remains somewhat unclear why retaining explicit pairwise states is especially useful beyond being a different architectural choice.
-
I also noticed that the Table 2 compares PaST with a parameter-matched attention baseline, but the improvements are relatively small compared to the reported standard deviations. Also, the two variants differ in several aspects beyond the use of explicit pairwise states, so it is hard to pinpoint what actually causes the improvement.
-
The computational cost is another concern. Since the method explicitly constructs pairwise tensors, its memory and computational costs should scale with the number of conformers. Table 4 shows noticeably higher memory and inference cost than FACET at K = 10, while the experiments only evaluate up to 10 conformers.
-
I thinks the singleton-centered residual is an interesting design, but its practical benefit is not fully claimed from the current experiments. Althougn Table 3 uses separately trained models for different conformer counts, it does not show how well a fixed checkpoint handles varying numbers of conformers when inferencing.
Questions for authors
-
What do explicit pairwise states offer over existing methods? Could the authors give a more concrete example to claim the contributions better?
-
Could the authors provide a more controlled comparison with some attention or relational baselines if possible? Which will help isolate the effectiveness of pairwise-state retention more directly.
-
Since the computational cost grows quadratically with the number of conformers, I wonder how well would PaSTNet scale beyond K = 10?
-
Table 3 uses separately trained models for different values of K. What happens if the same trained model is tested with different numbers of conformers? Would singleton subtraction make a difference in this setting?
Thank you for the authors' response. I have reviewed the rebuttal carefully. The authors have addressed the points I raised, and the clarifications improve my understanding of the submission. I'll keep my positive score.