- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CoMoFlow, a flow-matching framework for protein backbone conformational ensemble generation that enables control through collective modes. A sampled coefficient vector conditions the flow for controlled generation, drawn from a learned distribution over the coefficients of protein-specific collective modes. The method is validated on the ATLAS and de novo protein benchmark, focusing on the reconstruction of MD conformational distribution, along with analyses of structural variation and controlled generation.
Critical strengths
- Generation steering through a low-dimensional coefficient space
Projecting collective variation onto a small set of coefficients allows simplified handling on conformational change; varying a single coefficient produces aligned responses along the target mode. Because the space is low-dimensional, it can also be searched directly with CEM (spelling out the abbreviation and a short explanation of CEM procedure somewhere would be good).
Critical weaknesses
- Control is shown only under fixed or unspecified noise, so the robustness of the c → conformation link is not established (Figure 4)
Fig. 4 shows a single generated conformation per coefficient offset, and its noise setting seems unspecified. Since controllability is a core contribution, it remains unclear whether a given c consistently yields the same conformational tendency. For each of the five offsets in Fig. 4, generating multiple samples with independent noise and reporting the variance of the realized change would substantially strengthen the controllability claim. For example, a variation bar on Fig. 4(c) would suffice.
- Additional analyses only against BBFlow, omitting strong baseline in Table 1 (Figure 3, 5)
In Table 1, AlphaFlow-T and ESMFLow-T are competitive with CoMoFlow on several metrics. However, the analyses supporting the claim on variation recovery, targeted conformational exploration, and basin recovery are only done against BBFlow. As a result, it is unclear whether the advantages hold against some baselines. Including AlphaFlow-T and ESMFlow-T in Figures 3 and 5 would make the claims considerably more convincing.
Questions for authors
- Definition of long metric (Figure 3)
In Figure 3, r_long and MAE_long are shown, but I missed the definition of the long; is it simply a residue pair some how far away in the sequence?
- Analysis on transient-contact Jaccard
is notably lower than that of AlphaFlow-T and ESMFlow-T, while it is higher than other baselines. Do the authors have intuition on why CoMoFlow stands behind AlphaFlow-T and ESMFlow-T, while it outperforms them in other metrics?
- Physical validity of generated conformation
Physical validity is evaluated only on single-mode traversals in the Appendix, using residue-pair rates. Could the authors report per-conformation validity for the main ensembles, alongside some representative baselines?