- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces FARFlow for few-step protein backbone generation, building on Proteína's Cα-coordinate Transformer and the SoFlow solution-function framework. The method combines three components: (1) zero-anchored span conditioning, which ensures that the added span condition vanishes at zero span; (2) direct endpoint anchoring, which supervises clean-endpoint predictions using paired ground-truth backbones; and (3) fresh-noise replay, which re-noises detached endpoint predictions and supervises the resulting predictions against the same clean backbones to mitigate the training–inference mismatch. Experiments demonstrate high computational designability at 20–100 NFE. However, the generated backbones show relatively high similarity to reference structures in AFDB, indicating limited structural novelty by this metric.
Critical strengths
- The paper introduces an unscaled, zero-anchored span representation to support both local velocity learning and finite-span backbone prediction. It also employs Fresh-noise Replay to construct training inputs from the model's own predictions, thereby mitigating the distribution mismatch between training and inference.
- On the 60-128 residue benchmark, FARFlow-100 achieves 95.8% designability, which is higher than QFlow (88.5%) and RMF (83.2%). Ablation experiments show that retraining with the model's predicted skeleton has better performance than training with the real skeleton with noise (79.2% vs. 76.4%), indicating that Replay can bring additional performance improvement.
Critical weaknesses
- Table 1 only compares QFlow and RMF, where QFlow is the unrectified base version in ReQFlow and not the final accelerated model.As the direct basis FARFlow Proteina, also lack of quantitative comparison under the same NFE.In Table 2, RFdiffusion achieves 94.4% designability using only 50 NFE, while FARFlow-50 achieves only 84.4% and requires 100 NFE to achieve 94.8%. Although FIG. 5 demonstrates the sampling speed advantage of FARFlow, the time-consuming comparison of QFlow and RMF is not included.
- The paper is missing key training and computation configurations, including the source, Size, and protein length distribution of the training dataset, whether the model is trained from scratch, hyperparameters such as learning rate, Batch Size, number of training steps, and loss weight, as well as GPU configuration and training time. The training overhead of adding Anchor and Replay is also not reported. This lack of information affects the reproducibility of the experiment and also makes it difficult to evaluate the actual computational cost of the method.
- The paper mainly evaluates FARFlow at 20–100 NFE, without reporting generation results at 1, 2, 5, or 10 NFE.The experiments only cover backbones up to 250 residues. Figure 3a shows that FARFlow-50's designability decreases from 92% at 150 residues to 80% at 250 residues, motivating further evaluation on longer proteins.The AFDB maxTM of FARFlow-100 in Table 2 is 0.735, which is higher than 0.664 of RFdiffusion and 0.600 of Genie2, indicating that its generated structure is more similar to the known structure. The relationship between high designability and low structural novelty has not been fully analyzed in papers.
Questions for authors
- Why does Table 1 select the unrectified QFlow and not compare the final ReQFlow? Could the authors provide quantitative results for ReQFlow and Proteína at 20, 50, and 100 NFE, and compare the generation quality and the actual running time under the same evaluation conditions?
- Could the authors provide details on the training dataset, model initialization, key hyperparameters, GPU configuration, and training time? How much do Anchor and Replay add to the training calculation cost respectively?
- Could the authors provide representative generation results at 1, 2, 5, and 10 NFE, as well as for proteins with 300–500 residues, to evaluate the method's performance under extremely low NFE budgets and on longer proteins? Moreover, could the authors further analyze whether there is a trade-off between FARFlow's high designability and its relatively lower structural novelty?
Dear Reviewer iQuR,
Thank you again for your constructive comments. As the author–reviewer discussion period is drawing to a close, we would like to kindly ask whether our responses and revised manuscript have addressed your concerns.
Following your suggestions, we have added matched-NFE comparisons with ReQFlow and Proteína, additional sampling-time measurements, detailed training configurations, and measurements of the computational overhead of Anchor and Replay. We have also evaluated FARFlow at 1, 2, 5, and 10 NFE and on longer backbones of 300–500 residues. Furthermore, we have expanded our analysis of the trade-off between designability, structural diversity, and database novelty, explicitly acknowledging the limitations of our method.
These additions have been incorporated into the revised manuscript, with changes highlighted in blue. We would greatly appreciate any further feedback and would be happy to clarify any remaining questions before the discussion closes.
Best regards,
The Authors