- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents PepMap, a pocket-conditioned multimodal flow map for peptide co-design. By learning finite-time transitions over the joint state and combining the flow matching objectives with other consistency supervision, this method shows strong results on the benchmark for structural and binding metrics at low sampling steps.
Critical strengths
- Accelerating peptide generation is a meaningful research problem.
- The low-NFE results are promising.
Critical weaknesses
- The method seems to be a direct application of flow-map self-distillation. It's reasonable to say the peptide generation problem is a multimodal generation problem, and we need to ensure some joint consistency during training and sampling. But I'm still confused about the concrete difficulty when adapting flow-map to such a problem. Once the flow map has been defined over the joint state of different modalities, I think it's natural to use this formulation.
- The analysis of low-NFE generation performance is not sufficiently detailed to explain the method'pros and cons. I would like to see both finer-grained comparisons of final generation results and trajectory-level analysis, showing how sequence, backbone, and pocket compatibility evolve.
- Presentation issues: In Figure3, the triangular markers above the plotting area are not explained, and such overlapping makes it difficult to read/understand. In Figure 4, the second panel in the second row contains really long connecting lines crossing the protein pocket, and it's unclear what they mean.
Questions for authors
- What is the minimal difference between PepMap and directly applying an existing flow-map self-distillation framework to a peptide generation problem? What's the difficulty of the adaptation, and how do you solve these problems?
- Can you provide more fine-grained comparisons, e.g. 1,2,3,5,10 NFE? I wonder if improvements across different modalities or metrics occur at the same time/candidates?
- Can you fix the pocket, peptide length and initial noise, and show representative succesful/unsuccessful generation trajectories? I want to see the evolution of different modalities.