- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces PepHyD, a hybrid generative framework that combines diffusion-based exploration with Schrödinger bridge transport for target-conditioned peptide co-design. The framework aims to progressively transition from diverse sequence–structure exploration to target-compatible peptide generation.
Critical strengths
Hybrid Generative Framework: Combining diffusion and Schrödinger bridge dynamics is an interesting approach to balancing structural exploration and target-specific refinement.
Critical weaknesses
- Insufficient Motivation: The authors argue that diffusion enables broad exploration, while Schrödinger bridge dynamics guide generation toward target-compatible states. However, standard diffusion models already support coarse-to-fine generation, making the necessity of introducing bridge dynamics unclear. The improvements might simply result from changes in the noise schedule rather than the bridge formulation itself. The authors should provide controlled ablations to distinguish these effects. Furthermore, it remains unclear how the bridge dynamics explicitly enforce binding-interface constraints or offer advantages over conventional conditional diffusion.
- Limited Methodological Novelty: If my understanding is correct, the most import contribution is the combination of diffusion and Schrödinger bridge. Both diffusion and Schrödinger bridge frameworks are well-established, and simply combining them without demonstrating clear advantages raises concerns about methodological novelty. Additionally, the authors present the importance of residue identity, physicochemical compatibility, and geometric complementarity as a contribution, although these are already well-established principles in molecular design. The authors should clarify their actual methodological contributions beyond combining existing approaches.
Questions for authors
- What specific advantages do Schrödinger bridge dynamics provide over standard conditional diffusion? Could the improvements be explained by changes in the noise schedule?
- How are binding-interface constraints explicitly incorporated into the bridge dynamics?
- Figure 2 seems to have rendering problem. On chrome brower, if we zoom in to some extents, the figure will be corrupted completely.