- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4(+1)
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
PepRIG generates peptide sequences and all-atom conformations conditional on a fixed receptor pocket and peptide length. Shared multiscale interface features and gradients of a scalar latent compatibility potential couple semantic and geometric denoising. Evaluation measures reference recovery on LNR and PepBDB.
Critical strengths
Component ablations and independent-head replacements support the proposed coupling mechanisms (Tables 2-3). The full model improves sequence recovery and structural metrics over both replacements, providing evidence beyond simply supplying interface information. The evaluation extends beyond separate per-metric oracle maxima. Mean-candidate gains and same-candidate joint success support broader improvement on LNR. At Table 4's strictest thresholds, joint successes increase from 122 to 142 among 3,720 candidates per method. FastRelax preserves the LNR DockQ advantage.
Critical weaknesses
-
Methodological Ambiguity & Lack of Innovation: The Reciprocal Binding Potential (RBP) trick is severely ill-defined. The Methods section fails to clarify whether RBP is a rule-based function, a traditional ML model, or a Deep Learning module, making the core algorithmic contribution opaque. Furthermore, the framework lacks novelty; target-binder co-adaptation and energy landscape guidance have already been achieved by prior work such as EpiCoCo (ICML 2026).
-
Insufficient Empirical Validation: The experimental section lacks a clear, comprehensive main table, and the current baseline comparisons are insufficient to convincingly demonstrate the model's superiority.
Questions for authors
-
Can you explicitly define the technical nature of the RBP mechanism? Please clarify whether it is a parameterized deep learning function, a rule-based formula, or another specific method.
-
How exactly does your proposed framework theoretically and empirically differentiate its co-adaptation and energy landscape guidance from EpiCoCo (ICML 2026)?
-
Can you provide a complete main results table with an expanded, rigorous set of baseline comparisons to justify your performance claims?
We appreciate the time and care the reviewer put into evaluating our work. We respond point by point below.
1. Technical nature of RBP (W1, Q1)
RBP is a trainable neural module. A shared multilayer perceptron scores each peptide–receptor residue pair from the noisy peptide features, receptor features, distance encoding, and diffusion time. The pair scores form a single scalar potential (Eq. 7). Its negative gradients with respect to the semantic and geometric latents give the two denoising corrections (Eq. 8). With the autoencoder frozen, we train RBP jointly with the denoiser by supervising these corrections with the injected diffusion noise (Eq. 11). The scalar is a learned denoising potential, not a hand-designed energy or an affinity predictor.
2. Distinction from EpiCoCo (W1, Q2)
EpiCoCo adapts the MHC geometry alongside the epitope and steers sampling by contrasting predictions from a denoiser conditioned on high versus low affinity (Secs. 2.3–2.5). PepRIG holds the receptor fixed. IGCA recomputes a shared interface representation as the peptide changes, while RBP derives both peptide correction fields from one scalar learned without affinity labels. On a fixed interface graph, the cross-modal Jacobians of the gain-normalized corrections are transposes of one another (Eq. 9). The coupling is thus between peptide sequence and geometry, not between the peptide and a moving receptor.
EpiCoCo tests its guidance on pMHC binding energy, where adding contrastive guidance to co-modeling and affinity prompting changes the reported score from −42.67 to −45.20 REU (its Table 2). Our Table 4 instead tests whether the two corrections benefit from sharing a potential. Relative to two separate gradient-producing potentials, a shared potential raises DockQ from 0.6500 to 0.6531 on LNR and from 0.5011 to 0.5044 on PepBDB, and reduces Local RMSD on both. These ablations test different mechanisms on different benchmarks. They do not rank the two systems head-to-head.
3. Expanded main comparison (W2, Q3)
We added UniMoMo-single (ICML 2025) on LNR and PepBDB, extending the comparison of joint all-atom peptide sequence and structure design methods from three to four baselines per benchmark. The results below combine the unrelaxed scores in Table 1 (40 candidates per target) with the published UniMoMo-single values. Appendix A.15 identifies the source and aggregation for the added results. Bold marks the best reported value per metric within each benchmark.
LNR (93 targets)
PepBDB (142 targets)
PepRIG has the highest reported GDT-TS and Contact-F1 on both benchmarks, together with the highest DockQ and lowest Local RMSD on LNR. On PepBDB, PepTri has the highest DockQ and PepFlow the lowest Local RMSD.