- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
PepARD introduces an all-atom peptide design framework capable of simultaneously generating the amino acid sequence and three-dimensional structure of a peptide, tailored to the binding pocket of a target protein. The method employs a dual-stream equivariant autoencoder to represent sequence semantics and molecular geometry, utilizing a receptor-conditioned diffusion model to generate candidate peptides. Additionally, adaptive reward steering is designed to balance structural plausibility, collision avoidance, and sequence quality.
Critical strengths
The authors introduce gradient guidance with a set of physical objectives to steer the generation towards valid regions. Instead of relying on a fixed set of reward weights, PepARD allows these weights to be adjusted throughout the optimization process. This approach may offer useful insights for multi-objective optimization.
Critical weaknesses
-
Overall, the co-design performance of PepARD has several aspects severely inferior to existing methods. According to the co-design success rates reported in the paper, PepARD achieves 40.9% on PepBench, which is significantly lower than the 59.4% achieved by PepFGLD. The binding energy of PepARD on PepBench is -19.90, which is also significantly worse than the best baseline, achieving -34.35. Furthermore, across other metrics, the performance of the proposed method does not differ substantially from the baselines.
-
Many of the proposed contents exist in previous work. The full-atom latent diffusion as well as the invariant and equivariant latent space exist in the baseline PepGLAD. The proposed AMEGNN and its RollerPooling are also adopted by the baseline PepGLAD. The physical guidance are widely adopted in baselines like PepTri and PepGLAD. It is weird to claim the methodologies in the previous baselines as core contributions. Also, the paper lacks a section of related work to discuss the difference between this work and previous ones.
Questions for authors
Could the authors provide qualitative or quantitative evidence illustrating how the adaptive reward weights evolve during the iterative optimization process, and how these shifts relate to the improvement of individual optimization objectives? For instance, do different target proteins or distinct optimization stages lead to systematically different weight-adjustment trajectories? Furthermore, compared to approaches that employ uniform or fixed weights, do these adaptive adjustments result in superior final structures?
2 comments
Thanks
Thanks for the response, which partially addressed my concerns and thus I have raised the score. However, I still think the methodology novelty is quite limited, therefore I am still leaning towards rejection.
Response to Reviewer 83nP
Thank you for the thoughtful review.
1. Co-design Performance (Weakness 1)
On PepBench, PepARD trails PepFGLD in reported success (40.9% vs. 59.4%), with similar ΔG scores (−19.90 vs. −19.86). The diversity gains over PepTri are modest. UniMoMo reports a lower nominal ΔG (−34.35kcal/mol) alongside more atomic clashes (>45% vs. <5% for PepARD) and lower contact consistency (0.439 vs. 0.791). On PepBDB, the reported success rates are close (50.2% vs. 49.7% for PepFGLD). We will clarify baseline sources, success criteria, and relaxation settings in Table 2.
2. Attribution and Contribution (Weakness 2)
We will revise the contribution statement to credit PepGLAD for full-atom latent diffusion with invariant and equivariant representations, and dyMEAN and PepGLAD for AMEGNN and RollerPooling. PepARD's main contribution is learning reward weights from the current candidate state and refinement step over ten post-diffusion updates. We will explain how this mechanism differs from the sampling guidance in PepGLAD, PepTri, and PepFGLD in a dedicated Related Work section.
3. Adaptive Reward Weights (Question)
Compared with uniform weights, adaptive weighting raises co-design success from 39.9% to 40.9% on PepBench and from 27.6% to 50.2% on PepBDB (Table 1). In FixSeq, DockQ increases from 0.590 to 0.643 on PepBench and from 0.366 to 0.386 on PepBDB, while PepBDB all-atom RMSD increases from 9.53 to 9.62A˚ (Table 3).