- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a flow-matching framework for local protein–ligand conformational ensemble generation and probabilistic evaluation. It introduces learned soft scaffold restraints to preserve binding context while allowing ligand and protein side-chain flexibility. The framework further uses token-level log-probability estimates for conformer selection and ligand ranking. Experiments demonstrate competitive structural reconstruction performance, although improvements in downstream activity prediction remain limited.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses local conformational changes and induced-fit effects in fragment-based drug optimization, providing a useful perspective beyond single-pose evaluation.
-
The proposed method achieves strong structural validity and interaction recovery on PLINDER and Q-BioLiP benchmarks, outproming several establieded baselines.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper does not sufficiently demonstrate the independent benefit of likelihood-based scoring over conventional scoring methods. Moreoveer, activity-ranking improvements over the BSA-only baseline are marginal (Spearman: 0.280 vs. 0.317), and the method underperforms Boltz-2.
-
The side-chain-fixed variant performs slightly better than the flexible model on all five structural metrics in the full Q-BioLiP benchmark. Improvements on the induced-fit-required subset are modest and evaluated on only 13 tasks, limiting the strength of the claimed benefits.
Questions for authors
-
can the authors compare the proposed probabilistic evaluator against conventional scoring methods using the same generated conformers?
-
Are the provements from likelihood-derived features over the BSA-only baseline statistically significant?
-
Why does the side-chain-fixed variant outperform the flexible model on the full Q-BioLiP benchmark, despite the emphasis on induced-fit modeling?
3 comments
Response to Question 3 and Concern 3 — Why fixed side chains are slightly better on the full benchmark
Why does the fixed variant outperform the flexible model on all five full-set ligand-centered metrics despite the emphasis on induced fit?
We thank the reviewer for pointing out this apparent contradiction. The full-set average combines two different receptor regimes. Many substitutions occur in receptor pockets that are already preorganized for the new fragment. Keeping those side chains fixed preserves an appropriate pocket state, while sampling them introduces additional variance. Previous flexible-docking studies have similarly found that unnecessary receptor degrees of freedom can increase the search burden and scoring noise [1, 2]. The full benchmark is therefore not expected to show a universal benefit from flexibility.
Our residue-level analysis is consistent with this explanation. Flexibility is more useful for side chains that actually rearrange after substitution but can disrupt residues that are already preorganized. However, this analysis does not fully resolve the performance gap. Even on the induced-fit-required subset, improvements in the aggregate ligand-centered metrics are small or inconsistent. This suggests that the current sampler does not yet reliably focus the additional flexibility on the residues and conformations where it is needed.
We will revise the manuscript to make this limitation explicit and avoid implying that receptor flexibility is universally beneficial. We will also investigate whether the remaining gap arises primarily from flexible-residue selection, conformational sampling, or scoring of the generated states.
References
[1] Armen, R. S., Chen, J., and Brooks, C. L. III. ``An Evaluation of Explicit Receptor Flexibility in Molecular Docking Using Molecular Dynamics and Torsion Angle Molecular Dynamics.'' Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 5, 2909--2923 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1021/ct900262t
[2] Park, H., Zhou, G., Baek, M., Baker, D., and DiMaio, F. ``Force Field Optimization Guided by Small Molecule Crystal Lattice Data Enables Consistent Sub-Angstrom Protein--Ligand Docking.'' Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 17, 2000--2010 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jctc.0c01184
Thank you for your response. I have no further questions.
Response to Question 1 and Concern 1 — Independent benefit over conventional scoring
We thank the reviewer for suggesting this direct comparison. We compared the contact-focused plausibility score with Vina on the same 32 conformers for each of 242 held-out PLINDER targets. Vina gave higher pairwise accuracy for all four tested quality metrics. For example, the accuracies were 55.4% versus 53.0% for lDDT-PLI and 69.7% versus 56.3% for clash count. The narrow quality range within the generated ensembles contributes to the weak ordering but does not fully explain it. Among pairs separated by at least 0.05 lDDT-PLI, Vina still reached 61.7% compared with 56.6% for our score. Thus, the current results do not establish an advantage over conventional whole-complex scoring.
At the residue level, the evaluated residue's own token score ranks the correct χ1 state with 58.2% pairwise accuracy, compared with 50.3% for the mean score of the other residues. Residue-specific selection improves correctness by 5.21 percentage points over the conformer-pool mean. This indicates a modest local signal, not a global scoring advantage. We will revise the framing accordingly and present token decomposition as a local analysis tool rather than a replacement for conventional scoring.
Response to Question 2 and Concern 2 — Statistical significance of the likelihood-derived affinity features
We thank the reviewer for requesting this comparison. The improvement over the BSA-only baseline is not statistically significant on the 39 held-out congeneric series. The full model increases target-mean Spearman correlation by 0.037 with a 95% paired target-bootstrap CI of -0.036 to 0.124 and pairwise accuracy by 0.012 with a CI of -0.022 to 0.052. We therefore do not claim that the divergence-derived features improve affinity ranking over BSA alone. We will remove affinity ranking from the Abstract and main Methods and Results and present it only as an exploratory supplementary analysis.