- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
TP3D predicts WNS/TNS from macro placements with separate GNNs for intra-die and inter-die interactions; cross-die paths use latent bridge points. Predicted timing costs guide placement masks and evolutionary refinement. Trained on 1,000 placements from five designs, it is evaluated on seven Open3DBench designs, including two held out. The authors report 10.8% mean WNS and 8.7% TNS improvement over four baselines, with Kendall correlations of 0.606/0.704 for predicted WNS/TNS.
Critical strengths
- The intra-die/inter-die model and latent bridge points reflect distinct 3D path structures; the paper shows HPWL correlates poorly with timing.
- Full-flow timing improves on seven designs, including two held out; TP3D improves WNS on all seven.
Critical weaknesses
- Predictor validation is limited. Reported Kendall correlations are 0.606/0.704 for pWNS/pTNS and 0.567/0.534 for the combined score. The evaluation split is unclear, held-out prediction accuracy is absent, and three runs may not characterize variation from random initialization and swaps.
- Scope and representation are narrow. The method targets two-die F2F bonding. Its macro-only graph summarizes standard-cell paths, but no ablation tests this abstraction.
- There is no explanation of how the authors handle the variability from macro/gloabel placer across different runs. The layouts produced by OpenRoad can be very different with different configurations.
Questions for authors
See the weaknesses above.
4 comments
Dear Reviewer pXfD,
We are the authors of the paper "TP3D: Timing-Aware Die-To-Die 3D Macro Placement". Thank you very much for the valuable comments you provided during the review. We would appreciate it if you could review our responses when you have a chance. We hope they address your concerns and clarify our work. If you find that your concerns have been sufficiently addressed, we would be grateful if you could consider raising your score. If any questions or concerns remain, please let us know. We would be very grateful if you could spare the time to reply.
Best regards, The Authors
Thanks for the rely
Thanks for the effort from all authors to address my questions and concerns. I have no more questions. And I would like to retain my score.
Some questions about public comment
Dear Reviewer pXfD,
We just received a response from the public comment. The comment is "Thanks for the effort from all authors to address my questions and concerns. I have no more questions. And I would like to retain my score." We are confused whether this is from the reviewer. If so, since we have addressed all your questions, we still hope you can consider raising your score. We would really appreciate it if you could. If not, we still hope to get your reply.
Best regards, The Authors
Response to Reviewer pXfD
Response to Reviewer pXfD
We thank the reviewer for this careful audit. We answer each weakness and question in order.
W1: Predictor validation, split and held-out accuracy
The paper does not state the evaluation split clearly, and that was our presentation failure. The setting is five training designs (ariane133, ariane136, bp_be, bp_fe, bp_multi) with 200 placements each, split 80/20 per design; bp_quad and swerv_wrapper are excluded from training, from the normalization statistics and from checkpoint selection. The reported 0.606/0.704 for pWNS/pTNS and 0.567/0.534 for the combined score are test-split correlations.
What we did not state, and should have, is the aggregation. A correlation pooled across designs with different label scales can be inflated by design identity, and it is not the same quantity as within-design candidate ranking, which is what the placement procedure actually needs.
Measured per-design correlations. Kendall τ is computed separately inside each design on that design's test placements, so design identity enters no correlation and the quantity is the one the placement search relies on — ordering candidates within one design. The values are given in Table B.
On the three-run concern: we agree that three runs do not characterise initialization and swap variation. The controls now use five macro seeds per design.
W2: Two-die F2F scope and the graph-abstraction ablation
On the scope. The two-die face-to-face setting is what we measured and all reported numbers are for that setting. The formulation itself is not restricted to two dies: the intra-die and inter-die terms are computed by two separate GNNs, one for macro relations within a die and one for relations across dies. Extending to n dies requires adding the corresponding inter-die relation for each die pair, rather than changing the model structure, and the paired masks generalise in the same way. We have not measured multi-die or TSV-based stacking, and we will state the scope in those terms rather than claiming results we do not have.
On the abstraction ablation. The macro graph, which summarises standard-cell paths into macro-to-macro relations through path-depth features instead of modelling cells as graph nodes, is taken from LaMPlace, and the appendix states this inheritance. We do not claim it as a contribution of this paper, so the ablation the reviewer asks for would test an inherited component rather than anything we introduce. For that reason we have not run it, and we will make the attribution explicit in the text. Ablating the abstraction, for example by comparing the macro-level graph against a cell-level or path-level representation, is a reasonable next step and we will list it as future work.
W3: Run-to-run variation and Open3DBench configurations
Same configuration for every method. Back-end evaluation is carried out with Open3DBench. All methods we compare share one fixed Open3DBench configuration within a design: the same input netlist, clock period taken from the distributed SDC, the same PDK (nangate45), the same standard-cell placement stage (Analytical-M3D), and the same timing extraction stage. The only input that differs between methods is the macro placement file itself. Because no configuration parameter is changed between methods, the improvement cannot come from a different back-end setup.
Table A: TP3D per-design WNS/TNS over five macro seeds
Format: WNS / TNS in ns, mean ± standard deviation; closer to zero is better.
Table B: Per-design Kendall τ
Kendall τ is computed within each design on that design's test placements. swerv_wrapper and bp_quad are held out of training.