- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes C2FPlace, a three-stage macro placement framework: (1) a population of 20 initial layouts built by repeated WireMask-guided greedy placement with random tie-breaking; (2) coarse-grained steady-state evolutionary search using tournament selection (size 5), random-subset partial rip-up-and-replace across the whole canvas, a two-phase rip-up ratio schedule ([0.4, 0.7] → [0.1, 0.4]), and elitist worst-replacement; (3) fine-grained “critical macro tuning” that identifies macros providing bounding-box extremes of nets and refines them via structure-preserving coarse-grid displacement combined with fine-grid offset search. Although I believe the paper contains substantial substance, I find several flaws that prevent it from meeting the bar required for ICLR.
Critical strengths
- EGPlace's fitness-softmax parent selection and score-guided macro subset, and RollPlace's rectangular-region selection, both bias reconstruction proposals; C2FPlace's tournament selection + spatially-unconstrained random subset + scheduled ratio is a coherent response.
- The 1000-minute unified budget with convergence curves rerun on the authors' own hardware (Fig. 2) is commendable and often missing in this literature.
- OpenROAD v2.0 + ASAP7 PPA evaluation (WNS/TNS/NVP/power) on ICCAD2025 goes beyond HPWL-only claims; the authors honestly report that Stage 3 HPWL gains do not always translate to timing gains.
Critical weaknesses
- The motivation is that selection mechanisms drive diversity, yet no ablation isolates them. I find that tournament vs. fitness-softmax selection, random vs. score-guided/region-based macro subset, and the diverse-population vs. single initialization, but all of them are within the same framework. This could come from the initialization diversity or budget rather than the proposed selection scheme. I strongly believe that this is the most significant experimental gap.
- All five evaluated circuits contain 0 macros, ariane with 136 macros. However, the paper does not provide a clear justification. Only saying "its placement setting differs" is not enough and too vague. I assume applying the method to standard-cell placement is a different problem regime, the scalability claim should be reframed and ariane should included.
- Baseline numbers are taken from EGPlace and ROllPlace paper rather than rerun. This is unprofessional and it is unclear whether the headline 17.8% improvements hold under identical compute, especially since C2FPlace allocates its budget explicitly? Please explain.
- I believe stage 3 is a marginal contributor. The paper yields only .31% average HPWL on ISPD2005 and on ICCAD2025 it degrade WNS/TNS on ac97_top and pci_bridge 32. I do believe the work as claimed effectiv contradicts the paper's own numbers, either the claim or the title emphasis should be tempered.
- The novelty of the paper is incremental . For example, Tournament slection, annealed rip-up ratio, bounding box critical refinement, and fine grid offsetting are each standard techniques. The contribution is a careful recombination rather than a new principle.
- I do not know if this is intend. There is no significance testing. Several stage 3 deltas are within noise. The objective is HPWL under non-overlap only. No congestion, routability analysis on ISPD2025 is provided. The HPWL ->PPA disconnect is noted but no analyses are provided as well? Any reasons for this?
several typos I would not list them all, but name a few. In line 402-406, the sentence is broken. Line 430, "rwith" what is this? ... Line 131, there are two schedule...
Questions for authors
- Can you provide the selection-mechanism ablations (tournament vs. softmax; random vs. score-guided subset) under identical budgets?
- Why exactly is ariane excluded, and can C2FPlace handle genuine mixed macro + standard-cell designs?
- What defines the fine-offset candidate set in Stage 3, and how sensitive is it to resolution?
- Why does DREAMPlace still win on adaptec4 — any circuit characteristics explaining this?