- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
MacroSPA adapts a pretrained diffusion macro placer to spatial preferences specified by synthetic or optimizer-generated layouts. It adds Minkowski Guided Refinement and sparse constraint evaluation. Experiments on IBM, ISPD and ChiPBench demonstrate prior adaptation, downstream improvements over the unadapted pipeline, and improved inference scalability.
Critical strengths
- SPA adapts a frozen placer with matched controls, showing changes in spatial priors and downstream benefits.
- MGR and sparse constraint evaluation provide useful geometric repair and substantial inference savings on large circuits.
Critical weaknesses
- Data quality and total cost are insufficiently established. Appendix B.3 samples legal layouts and rewires connectivity to favor short connections; this does not establish quality for realistic fixed netlists. Quality criteria and sensitivity to poorer pretraining/target samples are missing. Dataset-generation costs, including synthetic data and DREAMPlace teacher runs, are unreported. Runtime comparisons with DREAMPlace and other solver-based methods are absent, leaving the practical trade-off unclear.
- SPA combines standard residual adapters, LoRA, and head tuning, so its distinct contribution needs stronger evidence. Downstream component ablations and comparisons with parameter-matched adaptation alternatives are missing.
Questions for authors
Please explain the weaknesses above.
6 comments
Response to Reviewer JJLJ – Part 2 / 3
Target samples. The spatial profile matters, and a modest corpus suffices.
- Profile. Random and Clustered targets are our examples of poorer target samples. They share Peripheral's circuit sampling, macro sizes, degree sequences, and connectivity-generation rule. Both reach comparable or slightly lower macro-only HPWL, yet their downstream wHPWL is 1.42% to 4.14% higher (Table 12). Relative to the no-SPA pipeline, wHPWL changes by −2.20% with Random, −2.48% with Clustered, and −3.98% with Peripheral on IBM, and by +1.84%, +1.39%, and −2.19% on ISPD. A poorly chosen profile therefore reduces the gain on IBM and removes it on ISPD.
- Coordinates under fixed netlists. On ChiPBench, we train three SPA states on the same synthetic netlists constructed from the Dispersed layouts, varying only the target macro coordinates (Section 4.4, L454–457). Compared with Compact, Relaxed reduces WNS violation magnitude on six of eight circuits and TNS violation magnitude on five. Across all eight circuits, the median reductions are 18.4% and 22.5%, respectively, with small median increases in routed wirelength and congestion. Dispersed yields the lowest routed wirelength and congestion on all eight circuits (Table 30). Relative to Compact and Relaxed, the median reductions range from 7.3% to 7.6% for routed wirelength and from 12.3% to 17.4% for congestion.
- Source. DREAMPlace-generated targets reduce downstream wHPWL further than synthetic targets, by 3.71% on ibm01–09 and by 2.87% on ibm10–18, which are excluded from adapter training (Table 13).
- Sample count. Among 10, 20, 50, and 100 targets per group, 20 gives the lowest downstream wHPWL in all three groups. Macro-only HPWL changes by at most about 6% relative to the 20-sample corpus, with no consistent trend. Downstream wHPWL varies more, most on Bigblue (Appendix F.4).
(c) Dataset-generation cost
Dataset-generation costs, including synthetic data and DREAMPlace teacher runs, are unreported.
Target generation takes seconds for synthetic data and minutes for DREAMPlace teachers. The table lists the full cost, which we have added to Appendix F.5. Target generation was timed on ChiPBench. Target generation and SPA training are performed once per target setting and shared by all circuits in the group (Appendix D.1.2). All reported times are averages over three runs.
| Stage | Cost | Frequency |
|---|---|---|
| Pretraining corpus (40K layouts) | 41.5 min | Once |
| Base pretraining (3M steps) | 36.8 GPU-hours | Once, shared by all benchmarks and priors |
| Synthetic targets (20 samples) | 1.03 s + 0.45 s validation | Once per target setting |
| DP-teacher targets (30 DREAMPlace runs) | 320.21 s | Once per target setting |
| SPA training | 47.5 s per 1K updates (2K–4K updates) | Once per target setting |
(d) Runtime and practical trade-off
Runtime comparisons with DREAMPlace and other solver-based methods are absent, leaving the practical trade-off unclear.
DREAMPlace is faster, and the gap narrows with circuit size. We have added DREAMPlace to Figure 5 and to the baseline list in Section 4.3 (L372–373). The figure already included the search-based WireMask-EA.
| Circuit | DREAMPlace (s) | MacroSPA, sparse (s) |
|---|---|---|
| adaptec1 | 18.35 | 100.07 |
| adaptec4 | 43.11 | 100.91 |
| bigblue4 | 90.75 | 201.66 |
| bigblue2 | 148.50 | 270.71 |
Both columns report macro placement time on the same instances as Figure 5. MacroSPA times cover guided sampling, legalization, and MGR (Table 9). The MacroSPA-to-DREAMPlace runtime ratio falls from 5.5× to 1.8× across the four instances. Among learning-based placers, sparse evaluation makes MacroSPA 43.35× faster than ChipDiffusion on bigblue2.
MacroSPA’s benefit lies in an adjustable prior and downstream quality. We would like to emphasize two aspects of MacroSPA. First, the spatial prior becomes an adjustable input. After a one-time pretraining, the same frozen Base acquires a new prior from seconds of data generation and a few minutes of training for 18,562 parameters, whereas an analytical placer optimizes one fixed objective per circuit. Second, this adjustability translates into physical-design quality. On ChiPBench, DREAMPlace ranks first in routed wirelength, while synthetic SPA achieves the best overall average rank (2.90 versus 3.19 for DREAMPlace, Table 2).
Response to Reviewer JJLJ – Part 3 / 3
Weakness 2. Distinct contribution and parameter-matched ablations
SPA combines standard residual adapters, LoRA, and head tuning, so its distinct contribution needs stronger evidence. Downstream component ablations and comparisons with parameter-matched adaptation alternatives are missing.
Under a matched parameter budget, no alternative reproduces Full SPA's downstream gain. We agree that the adaptation components are standard. What we consider most distinctive is the formulation, in which a single pretrained placer acquires distinct spatial priors specified directly by context–placement samples, without quality scores or rankings. Within SPA, the design choice we test here is that the residual adapters take the occupancy features of the current layout as input, before graph message passing. Table 7 ablates components on macro-only metrics without controlling the trainable-parameter budget, so we added a budget-controlled downstream ablation on ChiPBench.
Setup. Three alternatives match SPA's trainable budget to within 1.1%. A and B serve as the downstream component ablations. A removes the adapters, and B removes the fusion LoRA. All variants use the same training data, initialization, training budget, sampling noise, and OpenROAD flow as SPA, and all fine-tune the output head.
| Variant | Fusion LoRA | Trainable params | Tests whether SPA's gain can be obtained by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full SPA | rank 8 | 18,562 | n/a |
| A: Fusion LoRA only | rank 54 | 18,402 | more LoRA capacity |
| B: Adapters only | none | 18,766 | adapters alone, without the fusion LoRA |
| C: Generic adapters + LoRA | rank 8 | 18,438 | the same design without the occupancy input |
Results.
| Variant | Wirelength | Congestion | WNS | TNS | NVP | Power | Area | Improved pairs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full SPA | −2.9% (5) | −0.2% (4) | −20.2% (7) | −35.0% (7) | −14.7% (7) | −0.5% (5) | −0.4% (6) | 41/56 |
| A: Fusion LoRA only | −0.4% (5) | +1.8% (1) | −1.6% (4) | −4.8% (5) | +9.8% (3) | +0.8% (3) | +0.5% (2) | 23/56 |
| B: Adapters only | +0.6% (3) | +0.9% (2) | +6.4% (3) | −14.4% (5) | −2.0% (5) | +0.6% (2) | +0.4% (2) | 22/56 |
| C: Generic adapters + LoRA | +0.9% (3) | −0.3% (5) | −0.1% (4) | −9.1% (5) | 0.0% (4) | −0.1% (4) | +0.2% (2) | 27/56 |
We evaluated each setting three times per circuit and averaged the results. Median circuit-wise change relative to the unadapted pipeline (MacroSPA w/o SPA) on eight ChiPBench circuits. Negative is better. Parentheses give the number of circuits improved. WNS and TNS are measured as violation magnitudes.
- Full SPA improves the most circuit–metric pairs. It improves 41 of 56 pairs over the unadapted pipeline, against 22 to 27 for the alternatives.
- The gap is clearest on timing. Full SPA improves WNS, TNS, and NVP on seven of eight circuits each. No alternative exceeds five of eight on any of them.
- The occupancy input matters at an equal budget. Variant C keeps the same two adapter locations, rank-8 fusion LoRA, and trainable output head, but feeds the node hidden state into the adapters, with the bottleneck widened from 32 to 34. Head-to-head, Full SPA is better than A, B, and C on 41, 38, and 36 of the 56 pairs. Against C, it has lower TNS violations on six of eight circuits and fewer violating paths on six of eight.
Per-circuit results are in Appendix F.1, and Section 4.2 (L323) now summarizes this ablation.
We hope these responses address your concerns. If so, we would be grateful if you would consider updating your assessment. If anything remains unclear, we are happy to continue the discussion.
[1] Chip Placement with Diffusion Models. ICML 2025.
[2] FlowPlace: Flow Matching for Chip Placement. DAC 2026.
[3] IncreMacro: Incremental Macro Placement Refinement. ISPD 2024.
Response to Reviewer JJLJ – Part 1 / 3
Dear Reviewer JJLJ,
Thank you for the detailed and concrete comments. The revision adds a parameter-matched downstream ablation, sensitivity analyses for pretraining data and target samples, cost measurements, and a runtime comparison with DREAMPlace. We respond to each point below.
Weakness 1. Data quality and total cost
(a) Quality for realistic netlists
Quality on real netlists is evaluated directly. We assess the resulting placements on the original benchmark netlists, so the evaluation makes no assumption about the quality of the synthetic training layouts. Relative to the matched no-SPA pipeline, synthetic-target SPA reduces downstream wHPWL on 22 of 25 IBM and ISPD circuits (Table 1) and improves post-route WNS and TNS on seven of eight ChiPBench circuits each (Tables 14–15).
Targets specify a spatial prior, not reference solutions. The synthetic targets are not intended as high-quality solutions for any real netlist. They specify the conditional layout distribution that SPA learns (Appendix A.1). The same formulation also accepts optimizer placements of real netlists, such as DREAMPlace results (Table 13). We have added a clarifying sentence to Section 3.1 (L166–167).
The layout-first construction follows established practice. ChipDiffusion [1] also samples a layout first and then constructs connectivity that favors it, and its models transfer zero-shot to real circuits. In FlowPlace [2], replacing random samples with boundary-aware ones improves the average downstream ranks on ICCAD 2015, from 1.75 to 1.25 for rWL and WNS and from 1.88 to 1.12 for TNS. Our Peripheral profile follows placement practice, where large macros are placed near the die periphery to preserve central space for standard cells and routing [3].
(b) Quality criteria and sensitivity
We use three criteria, at three levels.
The first two can be checked before training. The third is known only after the downstream flow, and Table 12 shows that it is needed.
Pretraining quantity. SPA's gain holds from 5K to 40K layouts. Reducing the corpus from 40K to 5K layouts changes average Base wirelength by 2.3%, and SPA improves all four metrics at every scale. For each circuit and model, we first averaged each metric over three evaluation runs and then averaged the per-circuit values across the eight circuits. Each entry gives the Base average over the eight ChiPBench circuits, followed by the relative improvement of that average with SPA. Positive values are better, and WNS and TNS gains use violation magnitudes (Appendix F.2).
Pretraining quality. A biased corpus mainly degrades timing. We pretrained a Base on a corpus mixed with 10% strongly clustered layouts. Its downstream wHPWL stays within about 1% of the original Base on IBM and ISPD, and its geometry score on ISPD drops by 1.15 points. On ChiPBench, one circuit fails the flow, and the Base is worse in wirelength, WNS, and TNS on six of the seven circuits that complete it, with median changes of +0.8%, +15.6%, and +43.7% (Appendix F.3).