- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
EGGPlacer adds guidance to a diffusion macro placer at inference time, without retraining. At each DDIM step, the predicted clean placement is refined for a few steps on a composite energy. The energy has three parts: (i) a full-netlist WA wirelength computed after running a few DREAMPlace Nesterov steps for the standard cells with macros fixed, (ii) a smooth overlap term between macros and obstacle rectangles from dense standard-cell regions, and (iii) a thermal term from a learned set-based surrogate of HotSpot. The correction is added back into the DDIM update, and a greedy legalizer runs at the end. On 20 ChiPBench designs with the ORFS flow and HotSpot, EGGPlacer has the lowest mean ORFS HPWL, routed wirelength (2.18% below RollPlace) and peak temperature (4.90% lower temperature rise than ChipDiffusion). DREAMPlace remains better on HPWL after DREAMPlace refinement. The paper also shows that HPWL from ORFS tracks routed wirelength better than HPWL from DREAMPlace (Spearman 0.918 vs 0.660).
Critical strengths
Strength 1: The evaluation goes past macro-only HPWL. All methods are run through the same ORFS placement and routing flow and through HotSpot on 20 public designs. The observation that mHPWL, DREAMPlace HPWL and routed wirelength can rank methods differently (Tables 1, 3 and 4) is useful for the learning-based placement community, which mostly reports mHPWL.
Strength 2: The guidance mechanism is simple and practical. It works on a pretrained diffusion model without retraining, it treats the analytical placer as a black-box response with stop-gradients, and the total runtime (about 95 s per design) is much lower than EfficientPlace, ChipDiffusion and RollPlace (Table 2).
Critical weaknesses
Weakness 1: The thermal part is weakly supported. The surrogate is trained on 1,200 HotSpot placements drawn from the same 20 benchmarks used for evaluation, partly generated by earlier EGGPlacer versions, and the split is by placement, not by design (Appendix F.1). So generalization to unseen designs is not tested. The measured effect is also very small. Under joint guidance, HotSpot shows a 0.278 °C peak reduction, while the surrogate predicts 1.020 °C (Appendix F.5). Relative to the unguided variant, the full method lowers the temperature rise by only 2.0%. In addition, macro power is scaled by 10x to create hotspots, and none of the baselines optimize temperature, so the thermal comparison is one-sided.
Weakness 2: The wirelength gains are small and not tested for significance. Routed wirelength is 4.99 vs 5.10 for RollPlace, and the mean rank is 2.80 vs 2.85 for FlowPlace (Table 3). EGGPlacer is averaged over 3 seeds, but every baseline is a single run, and no per-design variance or test is given. Means over 20 designs of very different sizes are dominated by the largest designs. EGGPlacer also calls DREAMPlace inside every reverse step, yet its HPWL after DREAMPlace refinement is still worse than plain DREAMPlace (6.08 vs 5.64). Timing, DRC violations and congestion from ORFS are not reported, even though the end-to-end flow produces them.
Questions for authors
- How does the thermal surrogate perform with a design-level split, that is, trained on some designs and tested on unseen ones? Do the thermal results in Table 3 hold when the surrogate has never seen the evaluated design?
- Can you report per-design standard deviations for EGGPlacer, multiple runs for the stochastic baselines, and a paired test for routed wirelength and peak temperature?
- What are WNS, TNS, DRC count and routing overflow from ORFS for each method? A 2% routed wirelength gain is hard to interpret without these.
- Were the guidance weights and schedules tuned on the same 20 designs used for evaluation?
- Would a simple thermal-aware baseline, for example DREAMPlace with a macro power density term, give a similar temperature reduction?
Suggestions for future work:
Evaluating with the original macro power (without the 10x scaling) and on designs with real high-power macros would make the thermal claim more relevant to practice.
4 comments
Response 2 to Reviewer RSpk
Q1
How does the thermal surrogate perform with a design-level split, that is, trained on some designs and tested on unseen ones? Do the thermal results in Table 3 hold when the surrogate has never seen the evaluated design?
Response
We thank the reviewer for asking whether thermal prediction and guidance remain effective on designs excluded from surrogate training. For the accuracy, evaluation, and experimental setup of the thermal model, please refer to our responses to W1 and W2 from Reviewer AsWA. Our design-held-out experiments show mixed results: thermal guidance improves peak temperature on bp_multi57 but slightly degrades it on VeriGPU. Therefore, consistent thermal improvements on unseen designs cannot yet be established.
Q2
Can you report per-design standard deviations for EGGPlacer, multiple runs for the stochastic baselines, and a paired test for routed wirelength and peak temperature?
Response
We thank the reviewer for requesting multiple-run results and paired statistical comparisons to assess the reliability of the reported improvements.
First, per-design standard deviations for EGGPlacer are provided in Tables 7–10 of our original manuscript (Table 10-13 in revised manuscript).
Second, we will add multi-seed evaluations for all stochastic baselines. The updated mean ranks for EGGPlacer, FlowPlace, and RollPlace are shown below. For each design, we average each method’s three results, rank all six methods, and then average the ranks over the 20 designs. Lower ranks are better. The full multi-run results will be updated in the revised manuscript.
| Method | Routed WL Mean Rank ↓ | Peak T Mean Rank ↓ |
|---|---|---|
| EGGPlacer | 2.650 | 1.600 |
| FlowPlace | 2.850 | 4.150 |
| RollPlace | 3.350 | 3.150 |
Third, regarding the paired statistical test, we conducted systematic paired comparisons for the full EGGPlacer pipeline, the thermal-only variant (woa, T-only), and the analytical-only variant (wot, A-only) against the FlowPlace and RollPlace baselines, covering both routed wirelength and peak temperature. For the statistical analysis, we first average the results from three random seeds for each method on each design. We then compute the mean difference across all 20 benchmark designs, along with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) derived from the Student’s t-distribution for paired samples. In the table below, each entry presents the mean reduction [95% CI], where the difference is defined as baseline method − evaluated method.
| Baseline Method | Evaluated Method | Routed WL Reduction (10⁶ μm) | Peak T Reduction (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|
| FlowPlace | EGGPlacer (A+T) | 0.3147 [−0.3097, 0.9392] | 2.377 [0.975, 3.779] |
| FlowPlace | woa (T-only) | −0.1013 [−0.2312, 0.0286] | 2.682 [1.415, 3.949] |
| FlowPlace | wot (A-only) | 0.3635 [−0.2859, 1.0128] | 2.099 [0.848, 3.350] |
| RollPlace | EGGPlacer (A+T) | 0.2596 [0.0534, 0.4658] | 1.326 [0.560, 2.093] |
| RollPlace | woa (T-only) | −0.1565 [−0.7155, 0.4026] | 1.631 [0.856, 2.406] |
| RollPlace | wot (A-only) | 0.3083 [0.0847, 0.5320] | 1.048 [0.443, 1.653] |
For the targeted paired comparison between analytical-only guidance and joint analytical–thermal guidance, please refer to our response to Q2 from Reviewer wT1b.
Response 3 to Reviewer RSpk
Q3
What are WNS, TNS, DRC count and routing overflow from ORFS for each method? A 2% routed wirelength gain is hard to interpret without these.
Response
We appreciate the request to evaluate timing and routability alongside routed wirelength. We did not incorporate dedicated energy terms targeting WNS, TNS, DRC count, or routing overflow in our formulation, and these metrics were therefore not reported in the main manuscript. Nevertheless, EGGPlacer remains highly competitive on these ORFS timing and routability metrics. We will add these results in the appendix, including the three-seed mean values and mean ranks over the 20 benchmarks.
For each metric, we average results across three seeds per benchmark. We rank the methods within each benchmark, average tied ranks, and then aggregate the values and ranks across the 20 benchmarks. Bold font denotes the best mean value and the best mean rank for each metric.
ORFS timing and routability results across 20 benchmarks. Each cell shows the mean value followed by the mean rank in parentheses.
| Method | WNS ↑ (ns) | TNS ↑ (ns) | DRC count ↓ (×10³) | Routing overflow ↓ (×10³) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DREAMPlace | −1.526 (3.250) | −1246.37 (3.200) | 60.794 (5.200) | 63.724 (3.775) |
| EfficientPlace | −1.803 (4.200) | −1816.38 (4.400) | 1377.387 (4.000) | 252.625 (3.975) |
| ChipDiffusion | −1.658 (4.050) | −1709.23 (4.450) | 464.325 (2.700) | 160.829 (3.800) |
| RollPlace | −1.684 (3.800) | −1281.32 (3.500) | 155.848 (4.150) | 61.402 (3.650) |
| FlowPlace | −1.648 (2.750) | −1742.75 (2.800) | 253.491 (2.650) | 90.552 (2.800) |
| EGGPlacer | −1.479 (2.950) | −1123.13 (2.650) | 144.662 (2.300) | 49.830 (3.000) |
Q4
Were the guidance weights and schedules tuned on the same 20 designs used for evaluation?
Response
We thank the reviewer for requesting clarification of how the guidance weights and schedules were selected. We used the same 20 ChiPBench designs as in the evaluation to guide our selection of guidance strength, as we did not have a separate public benchmark suitable for validation in our evaluation flow. Given the computational cost of downstream ORFS evaluation, we performed only coarse tuning of the guidance strength. More extensive tuning might yield further improvements. All four EGGPlacer variants share the same frozen pretrained diffusion backbone and use the same hyperparameter settings across the three seeds and all designs.
Q5
Would a simple thermal-aware baseline, for example DREAMPlace with a macro power density term, give a similar temperature reduction?
Response
We thank the reviewer for suggesting a simpler thermal-aware baseline. Rather than adding a macro power density penalty directly to DREAMPlace, we evaluate a thermal-aware refinement baseline initialized from DREAMPlace placements using the same differentiable thermal surrogate. Please refer to our response to Q1 of Reviewer wT1b for the experimental setup, results, and paired comparisons with woa variant and the complete EGGPlacer. These results have also been incorporated into Appendix E.4 of the revised manuscript.
Kind Follow-up on Our Rebuttal Submission
Dear Reviewer RSpk,
We hope you are doing well. We wanted to kindly let you know that we have submitted our rebuttal addressing your questions and concerns in detail, including:
- Additional design-held-out thermal surrogate experiments, examining cross-design generalization and its limitations.
- Expanded multi-seed evaluations and paired statistical comparisons, including routed wirelength and peak temperature results with 95% confidence intervals.
- Additional downstream timing and routability evaluations, reporting WNS, TNS, DRC violations, and routing overflow across 20 benchmarks.
- A new DREAMPlace-based thermal-aware refinement baseline, together with clarifications on guidance hyperparameter selection and experimental settings.
If you have a moment, we would be very grateful if you could review our responses and let us know whether any concerns remain that we could further clarify.
We sincerely appreciate the time and effort you have invested in reviewing our work, and thank you for considering our additional evidence and clarifications in your evaluation.
Best regards,
The Authors
Response 1 to Reviewer RSpk
Dear Reviewer RSpk,
Thank you for your detailed feedback on thermal generalization, statistical reliability, and downstream placement quality. We will upload a revised manuscript with all revisions highlighted in blue for ease of reference.
W1
Response
We thank the reviewer for highlighting the need for stronger evidence on thermal generalization, surrogate calibration, and thermal-aware comparisons. For the accuracy, evaluation, and experimental setup of the thermal model, please refer to our responses to W1 and W2 of Reviewer AsWA. For the marginal thermal benefit and its uncertainty, please see Q2 of Reviewer wT1b. For the thermal-aware refinement comparison, please see Q1 of Reviewer wT1b.
W2
Response
We appreciate the reviewer’s concerns about the reliability and practical significance of the wirelength improvements. We address the raised concerns point by point below.
First, while the routed wirelength improvements are modest, our method achieves substantially better runtime and temperature compared with RollPlace, and a clear thermal advantage over FlowPlace, while also achieving a lower mean routed wirelength. Moreover, FlowPlace relies on handcrafted priors that push macros toward the chip periphery, which tends to induce hotspots.
Second, we will add results from three seeds for every baseline in the revised manuscript.
Third, to mitigate the influence of design size on aggregate comparisons, Table 3 reports mean ranks across designs. For additional statistical comparisons, please refer to our responses to Q2 and Q3.
Fourth, EGGPlacer invokes DREAMPlace to supply analytical feedback during diffusion sampling. Our goal is not to beat standalone DREAMPlace on HPWL. Instead, we aim to combine multiple physical objectives via composable energy guidance. We emphasize that placement quality should be judged by routed wirelength from the unified downstream OpenROAD flow, rather than by HPWL alone as an intermediate proxy metric.
Finally, we will supplement the missing metrics including timing, DRC violations, and congestion from the ORFS flow in the revised manuscript.