- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper makes DeepONets exactly equivariant by requiring all of their parts (observation, branch, trunk, and fusion) to respect the same symmetry. It also gives conditions under which finite sensor measurements keep this property. On four PDE problems with different symmetries, the equivariant DeepONets achieve lower errors than baseline DeepONets and FNO references, usually with fewer parameters.
Critical strengths
S1. The framework is clean and general. Treating equivariance as a property of the whole DeepONet factorization, rather than of the trunk alone, is a useful point, and the paper backs it up with both theory and an ablation (the symmetry-aware trunk model).
S2. The experiments cover four quite different symmetry settings, including mixed scalar and vector fields, reflections, and an internal U(2) symmetry. The equivariant models behave consistently across all of them, and the authors are open about limitations such as the larger model needed for Gross–Pitaevskii.
Critical weaknesses
W1. I am not fully convinced the comparisons are fair.
W1.1 The baselines look under-trained. The vanilla DeepONet has one-step relative L2 errors of 0.34 (Allen–Cahn), 0.89 (shallow water), and 0.32 (Gross–Pitaevskii), and its five-step error on shallow water is around 1.0. The symmetry-aware trunk model uses 24.1M parameters on thermoelasticity (vs. about 1M for the proposed model) yet does no better than the vanilla DeepONet. I suspect the "order-of-magnitude" improvements partly reflect weak baselines.
W1.2 It is unclear whether all models see the same input. Section 4 contrasts "a conventional sparse DeepONet" with "a full-observation equivariant model," but the main text does not say how many sensors each model gets. Part of the gap may come from the input rather than from equivariance.
W2. Some natural baselines are missing.
W2.1 There is no comparison with simpler ways of adding symmetry, such as data augmentation or canonicalization (e.g., Shumaylov et al., 2025, cited in the paper). These are needed to show that the full representation-theoretic construction is worth its complexity.
W2.2 Recent group-equivariant neural operators such as G-FNO (Helwig et al., 2023) are not compared, although G-FNO could be applied at least to the Gross–Pitaevskii benchmark on the square.
W3. Efficiency is argued only through parameter counts. Tensor-product nonlinearities are usually expensive, so training time, inference time, and memory should also be reported.
Questions for authors
Q1. (W1.1) How were the baseline DeepONets tuned? It would help to see the tuning budget and training curves. In particular, why does the 24.1M-parameter symmetry-aware trunk model not improve over the vanilla DeepONet?
Q2. (W1.2) How many sensors does each model receive, and where are they placed? Could you add a vanilla DeepONet that gets exactly the same input as the equivariant model (e.g., the same reconstructed coefficients)? That would isolate the effect of equivariance.
Q3. (W2) Could you include (a) a standard DeepONet trained with symmetry augmentation, (b) a canonicalization baseline, and (c) G-FNO where the symmetry group allows it?
Q4. (W3) Could you report training time, inference time, and memory for all models?