- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper looks at how neural operators learn boundary conditions and how errors and uncertainty propagate through multi-physics cascades. It argues that translation equivariance limits what FNO can learn when solution operators involve nontrivial Dirichlet boundary conditions, and that adding coordinate channels removes this limitation. The paper also introduces Physics-Informed Conformal Prediction (PI-CP), which uses PDE residuals to build prediction intervals that vary across space, and studies how coverage changes when operators are connected in a cascade. The experiments include several PDE problems, an electromagnetic–thermal–structural cascade, and an industrial regression task.
Critical strengths
1.Adding coordinate channels leads to large reductions in prediction error across several physical scenarios. The ablation results provide useful evidence that this design choice helps in practice. 2.The experiments examine both individual operators and cascaded systems, reporting prediction errors and coverage and comparing several uncertainty quantification methods. This gives a useful picture of performance across different settings.
Critical weaknesses
1.I had trouble connecting the coordinate-channel analysis to the models actually used in the experiments. The paper does not explain the padding or boundary handling, both of which can affect whether the full model is translation equivariant. I also found two parts of the proofs hard to follow: how Theorem 1 turns a boundary discrepancy into an interior L2 error lower bound, and how the appendix for Theorem 2 establishes the stronger claim of approximating any continuous operator. Both arguments move fairly quickly, and I would need more detail to understand why the conclusions hold. 2.The cascade coverage analysis also leaves some questions open. Theorem 3 bounds coverage changes using the distance between input distributions, but I could not tell what assumptions it needs about the conditional output distribution. The authors note that relative L2 error is only a proxy for the TV term, but the link between them needs more explanation. On the experimental side, the thermal and structural stages already have coverage below 90% when run individually. The paper shows the further drop caused by the cascade, but it does not fully explain the initial shortfall or how pooled-voxel calibration works. These missing details make it hard to see how closely the experiments support the theoretical guarantees.
Questions for authors
1.What padding and boundary handling do the experimental FNO models use? Is the full implementation translation equivariant in the sense assumed by the analysis? 2.Could you walk through how Theorem 1 obtains an interior L2 error lower bound from the boundary discrepancy? Could you also give more detail on the universal approximation claim in the appendix for Theorem 2? 3.What assumptions about the conditional output distribution are needed for Theorem 3? How do you derive the connection between the TV term and relative L2 error? 4.How are voxels pooled during calibration, and how is coverage computed? Why does coverage fall below 90% even when the stages are run individually?
2 comments
Based on the current manuscript, the authors’ rebuttal, and the feedback from other reviewers, I believe the paper still requires further revision. I therefore maintain my original rating of Weak Reject.
Response: padding note, Thm 1 derivation, Thm 3 retraction, voxel pooling
Point by point.
Q1 (padding): the 2D benchmark models (FNO2d) use zero-padding, 8 cells at non-periodic boundaries, which does break exact translation equivariance; the analysis idealizes the spectral convolution. The 3D cascade models (FNO3d) use padding=0 and are strictly equivariant, so the analysis applies to them directly. Padding contributes only boundary-local position information, not distributed coordinates, and empirically does not resolve the failure: Dirichlet Darcy without coordinate channels sits at 63.4% error. We will add an implementation note to the revision.
Q2: Theorem 1's interior bound: the boundary discrepancy ∥F(k0)−S(k0)∥≥C′∥g−gˉ∥ on ∂Ω propagates inward through the PDE's regularity estimate; C depends on the operator and domain constants. We will write this chain out in the appendix. On the Theorem 2 appendix claim: agreed, it moves too fast; as proven it gives necessity only, and we will downgrade it.
Q3: Theorem 3 is wrong as stated; input-marginal TV is insufficient, and counterexamples from other reviews verify this. The revision restates the per-stage gap as αk+dTV(Qk,Pk), Qk the deployment joint (predicted input, true target), with dTV(Qk,Pk) bounded by input-marginal TV plus an LkE∥y^−y∥ mechanism-response term under a TV-Lipschitz condition; relative L2 enters only through conversion to absolute error. Pooled-voxel calibration pools nonconformity scores across voxels and channels; coverage is marginal over the pooled population, not per-voxel. Stage-2's 83.6% below nominal is the heavy-tailed pooled-score artifact noted in Sec. 4.6. Cascade CP will be rerun with predicted fields passed downstream; results are running now.