- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a neural operator for sparse-sensor PDE inversion that is designed to respond consistently when boundary conditions, sensor locations, observations, and outputs are transformed together by a symmetry (e.g., rotations and reflections of a square domain). It also proposes a separate diagnostic for whether the sensors carry enough information. Experiments on one Darcy-flow benchmark report lower error than several neural-operator baselines, at a higher computational cost.
Critical strengths
The motivation is reasonable: treating boundary data, sensors, and outputs under one consistent symmetry is a sensible goal for inverse problems.
Critical weaknesses
-
The method is not described clearly enough to understand or evaluate. The paper explains the architecture only at a conceptual level and does not specify how the model is actually built. As a result, I could not understand how the method works, why it should work, or what is new compared to existing equivariant neural operators. This is a fundamental issue rather than a minor clarity problem: without a concrete description, the contribution cannot be assessed or reproduced.
-
The paper is not mature enough for the main track. With about five pages of main text, it reads more like a workshop paper or research proposal: the evaluation plan is described in detail, but results are reported for a single benchmark, and most of the experiments the paper itself identifies as necessary to validate its claims are missing. Addressing this would require substantial new work, not a revision.
Questions for authors
- Could you describe the architecture concretely (e.g., how sensor data and boundary conditions are fed into the model, and what the main layers are)?
- What exactly is new compared to existing group-equivariant neural operators such as G-FNO, or EqGINO, which uses orbit-based kernels? Since EqGINO is listed as a baseline in your experimental protocol, please also report its results.
- Can you report the experiments described in your evaluation plan that are missing from the results?