acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Beyond : Sobolev-Kinematic Flow Matching for Extreme Sparse Physical Inversion

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Physical inversion from extremely sparse sensors demands expressive priors. Prevailing paradigms either rely on metrics—causing high-frequency artifacts—or depend on specific differentiable partial differential equations (PDEs) solvers at inference, leading to severe collapse under observation sparsity, massive computational overhead and poor cross-scenario generalization. To transcend this, we propose Sobolev-Kinematic Flow Matching (SK-FM). First, breaking away from standard paradigms, we embed the joint probability flow for scalar fields and spatial gradients directly within the Sobolev space, implicitly learning differential operators without heuristic interpolations. Second, we introduce an equation-free Inference Kinematic Guidance. Leveraging ODE-based terminal state estimation to formulate geometric objectives—spatial derivative consistency and a curl-free constraint ()—we steer the trajectory toward the valid irrotational manifold. This propagates kinematic corrections back into the Sobolev space, successfully bypassing explicit numerical solvers. Extensive experiments across Darcy flow, Helmholtz, Structural Health Monitoring, and Navier-Stokes demonstrate that SK-FM achieves state-of-the-art inversion fidelity at resolution using merely 128 random observations (<0.79%). Remarkably, SK-FM reduces average inversion error by 78% compared to baselines. Finally, uncertainty quantification highlights its potential for real-world engineering applications.

Primary area:
applications to physical sciences (physics, chemistry, biology, etc.)
Keywords:
Physical Inverse Problems, Flow Matching, Sobolev Space, Kinematic Guidance, Extreme Sparsity, Equation-Free Prior

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_MTgkOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The authors present a method to modify flow-matching methods for full-field PDE reconstruction with a Sobolev-norm smoothed output field. They implement a curl of gradient penalty to ensure the resulting gradient fields are physically admissible. Their methodology is tested on a series of PDE benchmarks and shows good performance against the chosen comparisons.

Critical strengths

The paper attempts to address some of the shortcomings of flow-based generative models applied to PDE inversion tasks.

Critical weaknesses
  • The presented results are difficult to interpret, as the experimental setup is poorly explained and using language which is not typical of the field. In particular, in Figure 4 there is limited to no explanation for the tags, inverse/completion. This would need to be made much more concrete. I would advise including much clearer mathematical exposition of the inference tasks being performed.

  • The main contribution seems to be primarily in smoothing the output fields of flowmatching methods to be more compatible with generative tasks related to PDEs which yield smooth solution fields. This is a rather narrow contribution and could be achieved with other smoothing methods if needed.

Questions for authors

Can you please clarify the distinction between inversion and completion? Do you mean inversion as recovery of PDE parameter fields?

Reviewer_zWRvOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Sobolev-Kinematic Flow Matching for physical inversion from extremely sparse observations. It jointly models the inverse field, the dense observation field, and their spatial gradients, and applies derivative-consistency and curl-free guidance during inference. The authors report reconstruction quality, runtime, and uncertainty results on Helmholtz, Darcy flow, structural health monitoring, and two-dimensional Navier–Stokes tasks. The aim is to reduce high-frequency errors without invoking task-specific PDE solvers at inference time.

Critical strengths
  1. The focus on derivative quality is well motivated: small field-value errors do not guarantee small derivative errors. The improvements of SFM over CFM on several tasks in Table 1 provide preliminary support for gradient-aware training.

  2. Generic geometric guidance could reduce reliance on task-specific solvers. The four physical settings, together with ablation, noise, and uncertainty analyses, provide useful empirical breadth.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The experimental setup and evaluation protocol require further clarification. The manuscript and supplementary materials do not provide a sufficiently consistent account of the prediction targets, observed variables, and observation times for some tasks. This makes it difficult to determine the precise inverse problems evaluated in the main experiments. The correspondence between the physics-guided baseline constraints and each task's governing equations also needs explanation, as these details affect the interpretation of the comparisons. In addition, the separation between data used for model selection and final testing should be made explicit. These concerns do not establish that the reported results are incorrect, but they limit how strongly the current experiments support the main conclusions.

  2. The connection between the theoretical claims and the actual method is insufficiently established. Jointly predicting fields and auxiliary gradients is a worthwhile design, but the manuscript does not establish how auxiliary-gradient velocity matching controls the final scalar field's Sobolev error. The two-dimensional Sobolev embedding alone also does not justify excluding unbounded singularities. Similarly, the distributional connection between finite-time deterministic geometric guidance and Langevin dynamics, and the claimed guarantee of reaching the constraint manifold, are not established by the current derivation. The gradient computation and branch-update conventions during guidance should also be stated consistently. Empirically, guidance improves upon the unguided variant on some tasks, but the existing ablations do not sufficiently separate the contributions of consistency and curl constraints to the primary inversion quality. Improved curl-freeness of the auxiliary gradients alone does not establish satisfaction of the governing PDE.

Questions for authors
  1. Please provide a consistent description of the inverse targets, observed variables, channels, and time points for each task, and clarify how the main experimental setup relates to the supplementary materials. Do all methods receive the same observation information?

  2. How do the physics-guided baseline constraints correspond to the governing equations of each task? Please also clarify the data splits used for validation, model selection, and final testing.

  3. How does the joint matching objective control the final field's Sobolev error? Which distributional or convergence claims for geometric guidance are proved, and which are heuristic? What gradient-computation and branch-update conventions are used in practice?

  4. Could you evaluate consistency-only, curl-only, and combined guidance using the same model, initial noise, and observations, and report paired error changes with uncertainty to clarify each constraint's separate contribution?

Reviewer_4bAVOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This work tackles the problem of physical inversion under sparse observations and introduces two new methodologies: (i) a jointly optimized spatial and gradient flow matching objective, and (ii) a correction method for ODE solvers that forces adherence 0 curl for irrotational manifolds. The method is benchmarked on 4 physical systems, showing superior performance against established methods such as DPS and CFM. Additionally, visualizations show that high frequency oscillations are smoothed as predicted by the theoretical analysis of the SK-FM loss function.

Critical strengths
  1. Theoretically motivated, and examples show how the gradient flow is more physical.
  2. The visualizations are nice.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The “most critical problem” (line 59) mentioned by the authors is this mode collapse problem. Where do we see this? I don’t think the authors sufficiently justified this issue. How does mode collapse occur? In line 458, the authors write “For instance, SK-FM achieves 67.6%, 94.7%, and 98.7% in Darcy flow, confirming strictly calibrated posteriors that prevent mode collapse.” How does this prove that mode collapse is prevented? Where do we see mode collapse in other methods? The authors must absolutely clarify this claim.
  2. The inference speed improvement over DPS is a positive result as mentioned, but it’s really a weak claim. This inference speed improvement is essentially due to not using it, rather than using the kinematic solver (which the authors do not necessarily claim). The key point from the benchmarks is that the Sobolev loss function is doing all the heavy lifting, making the solver kind of a superfluous method.
  3. The authors stick to one architecture size and evaluate from there. While this is not an issue by itself, the authors don’t mention what happens when hyperparameters or architecture changes/increases in parameter count. Again, maybe the kinematic solver becomes even less of an issue with slightly larger models.
  4. I found the paper difficult to read. The language is somewhat unusual, like the word “transcend” where perhaps what is meant is “generalize”, or how “state” is not clearly defined anywhere. What do you mean by “sensor”? Looking at earlier work referenced above on flow matching and inverse problems, I don’t see this kind of terminology.
  5. I see unjustified language such as lines 58-59 “pathologically weak measurement gradients” (what is “pathological” about it?), and “precipitating severe mode collapse” (how does it “precipitate”?). The paper is riddled with language like this, and I urge the authors to think carefully about the words used to describe certain phenomena.
  6. I’m not sure the authors did a sufficient job finding baseline flow matching methods for inverse problems. CFM is a vanilla flow matching method that is important to compare against, but there are a few others [1-5]. The authors should benchmark against some of them or at least mention them in related works. Currently, the work is not well-situated in the inverse problem + flow matching landscape. Below are just a few papers after a quick search: [1] Pokle et al. “Training-free Linear Image Inverses via Flows”, TMLR 2024 [2] Martin et al. “PnP-Flow: Plug-and-Play Image Restoration with Flow Matching”, ICLR 2025 [3] Feng et al. “On the Guidance of Flow Matching”, ICML 2025 [4] Askari et al. “Latent Refinement via Flow Matching for Training-free Linear Inverse Problem Solving”, NeurIPS 2025 [5] Pourya et al. “Flower: A Flow-Matching Solver for Inverse Problems”, ICLR 2026

Without significant changes to the readability and motivations of the paper and additional benchmarking, I lean towards rejection. It seems like an interesting contribution and theoretically well-motivated, but it lacks sufficient comparison to other inverse problem methods, and its empirical motivation/justification remains unclear beyond the high frequency problem. If that is indeed the main problem addressed by this paper, then it needs to be thoroughly justified as to why it’s important and compared to other flow matching methods besides CFM for inverse problems to see if they really suffer (greatly) from this issue.

Additional feedback: There are many arXiv references that have been published more than a year ago. The authors should go through the references and make sure the published versions are referenced.

Questions for authors

What is Chi? (lines 114-115) What is a “state”?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.