- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces Physics-Informed MeanFlow (PIMF) to reconstruct PDE coefficients and solution fields from sparse observations. It evaluates guidance losses on a MeanFlow endpoint estimate. This aims to provide more informative guidance early in reconstruction than a diffusion posterior-mean estimate. Training combines SplitMeanFlow pretraining with PDE-residual fine-tuning. Experiments are conducted over five PDE families and nine reconstruction tasks. PIMF-FMinit achieves the lowest mean target error on six tasks. In addition, ablation studies are provided to examine component contributions, runtime, and the consistency of ensemble candidates.
Critical strengths
- The paper is well-written and easy to follow.
- The guidance design addresses a concrete limitation of diffusion-based reconstruction. To evaluate constraints on a MeanFlow endpoint is well motivated. The reduced-budget results suggest that this choice can make sparse-reconstruction more efficient.
- Since the comparison include diffusion, physics-informed training, flow matching, and distillation baselines, the empirical results demonstrate both benefits and failure cases of the proposed algorithm. The authors also separate training-time physics from inference-time guidance.
Critical weaknesses
- The contribution of physics-informed training remains difficult to isolate. In particular, Table 2 shows that observation-guided MeanFlow already provides strong performance. Adding PDE guidance worsens both Helmholtz and Poisson inverse problems. The matched-duration controls in Table 8 also show mixed effects. Residual fine-tuning improves Darcy forward reconstruction but worsens Darcy inverse error from 7.86% to 9.33%. Therefore, these results support MeanFlow-based guidance more clearly than the proposed physics-informed training process, which limits the novelty of the approach.
- The reduced-budget comparison does not separate sampling efficiency from guidance settings. The experiments retain weights selected for 2000 iterations. Algorithm 1 applies guidance updates without explicit time-step scaling. Thus, changing the iteration count affects both the transport discretization and the accumulated guidance. Runtime measurements provide useful insights into Helmholtz forward reconstruction. However, coverage across other tasks is limited, and PIDDM is missing from the corresponding comparison in terms of runtime. These gaps are significant, as computational efficiency is one of the main motivations.
- The physical constraints do not consistently validate the reconstructed coefficient-solution pairs. For Darcy, the residual pattern differs from that of the solver used to generate the data. This raises concerns that residual minimization may, in some cases, contradict the data distribution. Table 11 also shows that 42% of the Darcy ensemble candidates exhibit a relative inconsistency in the forward solution of more than 10%. In NSNB, the proxy residual value neither enforces incompressibility nor verifies the governing dynamics. It essentially provides no guidance. The authors acknowledge these limitations but significantly restrict the evidence for physical validity across the entire benchmark suite. The most rigorous checks are limited to Poisson and Helmholtz.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors provide matched-duration, physics-free MeanFlow controls for the remaining PDE families? Do the reduced-budget gains persist without residual fine-tuning? This would clarify which improvements require the proposed physics component.
- Are guidance updates scaled by the time increment anywhere in the implementation? If not, do the reduced-budget rankings persist after tuning guidance separately for each budget?
- Do the main rankings remain stable when guidance weights are selected on a disjoint validation subset? In addition, please clarify whether any results were repeated across independent training seeds.
2 comments
I'd like to thank the authors for their response. The authors address several of my experimental concerns, such as per-budget hyper-parameter tuning, runtime comparisons, and reproducibility. In addition, I appreciate the stronger physical-consistency evidence on Poisson and Helmholtz.
However, the new ablation studies indicate that most of the performance gains may come from MeanFlow rather than physics-informed tuning, which reinforces my concern about the contribution of the physics-informed component. Furthermore, the physical effectiveness of reconstructions on Darcy and NSNB remains insufficiently investigated. Since my major concern about the main contribution of the proposed work remains unresolved, I maintain my original score.
We thank the reviewer for the evaluation of our training objective, guidance, and evaluation protocol. We address the questions and weaknesses as follows.
W1+Q1. Isolating the contribution of physics-informed training on Helmholtz and Burgers
The ablations now cover all non-proxy datasets (App. E.4, Table 11). The physics loss is a bit beneficial on Poisson, Darcy forward and Burgers, degrades Darcy inverse and Helmholtz forward, and irrelevant for Helmholtz inverse. The models were retrained for this rebuttal; within each row, the two runs differ only in the physics weight. They are separate runs from the Table 1, so absolute values differ from it. For Burgers, the submitted PIMF model was under-tuned. We keep the submitted Table 1 unchanged. The update would only improve PIMF trained from scratch relative to the baselines, so Table 1 is conservative for our method, and PIMF-FMinit, on which our main claims rest, is not affected. Helmholtz has a higher variance in results.
On Darcy inverse, most of the weakness comes from the guidance estimate rather than from training (Section 7; App. F). With the same weights, the posterior-mean estimate achieves a 4.15% instead of 9.33% on the 1000 test instances (we explain the motivation in our response to Reviewer 1VMP, W1+Q2).
The reduced-budget gains are still there without residual fine-tuning. The table below is Poisson forward, with weights re-tuned per budget, on 50 instances.
These gains therefore come mainly from the MeanFlow model, not from the physics loss.
W2+Q2. Are guidance updates scaled by the time increment? Do rankings persist after per-budget tuning?
To the first question, no. Guidance updates are not scaled in any method depending on the time. Every sampler uses a constant guidance weight, and only the transport step is multiplied by the step length (Algorithm 1). Fewer iterations therefore mean less total guidance. The only rescaling is applied when the PDE guidance is added, as in DiffusionPDE, and that value is not fine-tuned (like them, we multiply the observation guidance by 0.1; App. C.1).
We re-tuned all five methods (App. H, Table 16). On Helmholtz forward at N=100, DiffusionPDE reaches 19.2, PIDM 17.5, FmPDE 3.57, PIMF from scratch 2.20 and PIMF-FMinit 2.22. PIMF-FMinit is first or tied at every budget. The full table is given in our response to Reviewer 1VMP (W2+Q1).
On runtime, PIDDM is now measured (see our response to Reviewer qnSJ, W2+Q2). Timing on Helmholtz is the same in both directions (within 1%), and all 2D tasks share the network and sampler (App. G, Tables 14,15).
Q3. Do rankings hold with weights selected on a disjoint validation subset? Were results repeated across training seeds?
Validation subset. The weights were searched on one test instance (Appendix C.1). Without the selection instances (0 and 1), no entry of Table 1 changes by more than 0.04 percentage points (App. D.1, Table 7). As the answer to reviewer 1VMP, DiffusionPDE (which we use as the baseline) doesn't clearly explain how they choose the hyperparameters.
Seeds. The submission used a single training seed. We re-trained all five PIMF-FMinit models from the end of Stage 1 and tested them on the same 1000 samples (App. D.2, Table 8).
Seven tasks reproduce, Helmholtz inverse improves, and Poisson inverse worsens, which might need more hyperparameter tuning. We will upload the checkpoints to our GitHub repository.
W3. The physical constraints do not consistently validate the reconstructed pairs
These are the benchmark's residuals, shared with the baselines. On Poisson and Helmholtz, where they are actually a rigorous check, 0–2% of PIMF candidates are inconsistent with the forward solve, against 60–72% for DiffusionPDE. We restrict our physical-validity claims to these two PDEs.
The residual on Darcy, which also guides DiffusionPDE and FmPDE, separates true from mismatched pairs (6.2×) but does not directly imply that they are valid.
On NSNB, it is a proxy (App. B), so it does not say much this sense.
In the revised manuscript, we state the Darcy and NSNB limitations (Section 7).