- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a probability-flow ODE-based diffusion posterior sampling framework combining Strang splitting with two-stage measurement guidance for inverse problems. The authors aim to address likelihood approximation bias and computational inefficiency through phase-based alignment and proximal data-fidelity updates. Experiments on image inpainting, sparse-view CT, and seismic full-waveform inversion are presented to demonstrate improvements in reconstruction quality and computational efficiency.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
1) There are fundamental methodological inconsistencies, the novelty is unclear, and justification for the claimed contributions is insufficient. Specifically, the paper's central methodological claims are not adequately supported by its mathematical formulation. The authors repeatedly emphasize that the proposed framework eliminates reliance on posterior-mean-based measurement guidance, yet Eqs. (13) and (18)-(20) explicitly use the Tweedie posterior-mean estimate for data-fidelity updates. I could not find anything in the paper that establishes how these updates resolve the approximation bias that motivates the work. Furthermore, the probability-flow ODE in Eq. (22) appears inconsistent with the SDE in Eq. (21) without an explicitly defined reverse-time convention, while the proximal weighting in Eq. (14) appears to contradict its stated noise-dependent behavior (it is reversed). Algorithm 1 introduces additional inconsistencies with the main formulation, particularly in the definition of the phase-based guidance term. Beyond these mathematical issues, the methodological novelty is unclear to me. The proximal data-fidelity formulation in Section 4.1, CG-based corrections of denoised estimates, and operator-splitting approaches for accelerated guided diffusion are already well-established in the literature. The proposed two-stage strategy also relies on previously developed measurement-alignment techniques. The paper does not sufficiently distinguish its contributions from these existing approaches or explain why their combination constitutes a meaningful methodological advance. Moreover, the relationship between phase retrieval, dynamic time warping, low-frequency guidance, and the actual measurement operators is not clearly formulated.
2) Inadequate experimental validation, insufficient reproducibility, and unsubstantiated claims of reconstruction quality and computational efficiency. The experimental evaluation is unfortunately insufficient to support the paper's broad claims. First, fundamental experimental details are missing (e.g., the number of evaluated images or hyperparameter specifications). The natural-image experiments consider only inpainting, while the CT experiments use synthetic projections of fastMRI images rather than actual CT data. The nonlinear FWI evaluation is supported only by a single qualitative example, without a comprehensive quantitative assessment across test cases or acquisition conditions. Second, the comparisons do not convincingly establish superiority over existing methods. From table captions for both Tab.1 and 2, I suspect that the authors have reported PSNR/SSIM results for a single image which is not consistent with how these results are reported in literature. Furthermore, the baseline discussion is severely inadequate (e.g., what is DPS-ΠGDM?). The qualitative results in Fig. 5 also shows noise residuals for both (e) and (g) which are the proposed methods. Third, the central efficiency claims are not substantiated by systematic runtime or computational-cost comparisons. The proposed iterative proximal updates require additional forward and adjoint evaluations, yet these costs are not accounted for when claiming improvements from fewer diffusion steps. Finally, I can also see some inconsistencies in the reported LPIPS values between Tables 1 and 3. Together with incorrect or misleading figure captions, this raise further concerns about the reliability and clarity of the experimental evaluation.
Questions for authors
-
How many images or test cases were evaluated for each task, and what is the variability of the reported results? Could the authors also clarify the implementation of the competing methods, particularly the baseline labeled DPS-ΠGDM? Original ΠGDM work is a separate method than DPS.
-
Diffusion-based inverse problem solving is a highly saturated and rapidly evolving research area, with numerous advances in efficient posterior sampling introduced in recent years. However, the paper primarily motivates and evaluates its contributions against relatively outdated methods such as DPS and ΠGDM from 2023. Given the substantial progress in fast diffusion-based inverse solvers, could the authors clarify how their method advances beyond the current state of the art and why more recent, competitive approaches are not included in the experimental comparisons?