- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a spherical neural operator whose spectral convolution is derived from a physics-motivated assumption: that the system's Green's response depends only on the angle between the output location and a preferred axis. This is a departure from existing spherical neural operator, e.g., SFNO that is equivariant under SO3, which AsiNO claims is too strong a constraint and that the system is symmetric only under rotation around a special direction (i.e., AsiNO offers a less restrictive inductive bias). This choice is physically motivated. The proposed scheme is evaluated over spherical shallow water equations (SWE), WeatherBench, and cortical-surface parcellation (NAMIC, Mindboggle) and AsiNO achieves lowest error on most horizons with far fewer parameters.
Critical strengths
- AsiNO imposes a prior on Green's function. This is a novel contribution over prior art that impose symmetries over transformations.
- The results are presented on a diverse selection of benchmarks: simulated SWE, real atmospheric reanalysis (WeatherBench), and biomedical surface parcellation.
- Zero-shot transfer results shown in Table 2 are impressive. These suggest that asymmetric spectral form is grid-invariant.
- AsiNO uses far fewer parameters than existing spherical neural operators (SFNO, GSNO).
Critical weaknesses
- The paper makes no effort of analyzing the learned axes. What directions are actually learned? Do these drift during training?
- The paper will benefit from ablation where SFNO is also restricted to using the same number of parameters as AsiNO (say by reducing the number of channels for SFNO). Without these comparisons, it is not immediately obvious whether AsiNO wins due to inductive bias or because AsiNO forces fewer parameters.
- Each channels learns its own axis (right?). If so, it weakens the inductive bias claim.
- The GA convolution learns two components: \alpha_l and d_c. The reletive contribution of each is not studied. What if d_c is fixed across channels? What if \alpha_l is held constant?
Questions for authors
- What axes d_c do the channels converge to? For WeatherBench, do they cluster near geographic poles, equator, or distributed uniformaly.
- Is it possible to see if AsiNO maintains its performance gains over SFNO when SFNO and AsiNO are parameter matched.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the encouraging and constructive feedback, especially the novelty of our Green's response-based formulation, the diversity of our experimental evaluations, and the promising zero-shot transfer results. We greatly appreciate the insightful suggestions regarding interpretability, parameter-matched comparisons, and operator-level ablations.
Weakness 1 and Question 1: Interpretability of Learned Axes.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for this insightful suggestion. We agree that examining the learned axes can provide further insight into the proposed axis-conditioned responses. We would like to clarify that the learnable axes d are introduced to parameterize latent axis-conditioned response kernels and structure the spectral convolution, rather than directly representing the physical axes of the underlying systems. We have added a preliminary analysis in the revised appendix, with the new content highlighted in red. The learned polar angles are concentrated near the equatorial plane on WeatherBench (90.09∘±4.48∘). Notably, WeatherBench exhibits a broader distribution and more pronounced variations across operator blocks. We further analyze the training dynamics on SWE, observing modest directional adjustments during training.
Importantly, these learned directions parameterize latent axis-conditioned response kernels rather than directly representing the physical axes of the underlying systems. While these latent directions may capture meaningful directional structures, exploring their connections to physical mechanisms in Earth and brain sciences remains an important direction for future work. The present study primarily focuses on validating the effectiveness of physical-response-informed operator learning.
Weakness 2, 3, 4 and Question 2: Controlled Operator-Level Comparisons and Ablations.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for these constructive suggestions. We agree that parameter-matched comparisons and component-level ablations are important for assessing the contribution of the proposed operator formulation.
To address these concerns, we have conducted additional controlled experiments on SWE. All models follow the same non-spectral network design, training settings, and evaluation protocol, with SFNO/GSNO channel widths adjusted to examine comparable parameter budgets. The results are summarized below, and the full H/V/D results (mean ± std) have been added to the revised manuscript, highlighted in red.
Values denote the average MRE across H, V, and D (lower is better).
Parameter-matched comparisons. AsiNO achieves the lowest average MRE. At step 30, AsiNO obtains 0.33352, compared with 8.28860 for SFNO (C=20, 73.889K) and 1.12766 for GSNO (C=8, 68.345K).
Operator-level ablations. Removing the learnable axes dc, sharing one axis across channels within each block, or removing the degree-dependent coefficients αℓ increases the step-30 average MRE from 0.33352 to 0.48432, 0.39679, and 0.65590, respectively. These results support the contributions of both directional modulation and degree-dependent spectral learning. Importantly, allowing channel-wise axes does not impose a single global symmetry axis; instead, each channel retains its axis-conditioned response parameterization while allowing flexibility across channels.
We have incorporated these results and the corresponding analysis into the revised manuscript (Sec. 5.5), with all additions highlighted in red. We appreciate the reviewer's suggestions, which have strengthened the validation of the proposed formulation.
We sincerely appreciate the careful evaluation, and constructive feedback, which have strengthened this manuscript. We have incorporated the corresponding analyses and experiments into the revised manuscript, with the changes highlighted in red.