- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the Spherical Laplace Neural Operator (SLNO), which combines spatial spectral modeling with temporal responses through scale-conditioned pole–residue representations and internal latent trajectories. The method targets long-horizon rollout prediction of spherical dynamics and is evaluated on a controlled fast–slow system, shallow-water equations, and partial-autoregressive weather forecasting.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses the practically relevant problem of error accumulation in long-horizon prediction of spherical dynamical systems.
The method connects spherical spatial scales with learnable temporal responses, offering an interesting direction for spatiotemporal modeling.
The experiments cover controlled dynamics, spherical shallow-water equations, and weather data, providing some diversity in evaluation tasks.
Critical weaknesses
Insufficient discussion of existing temporal modeling methods. The paper presents explicit temporal structure as key to improving long-horizon rollout prediction, but does not sufficiently analyze how existing Laplace-based, state-space, and memory-based methods model temporal dynamics or what limitations remain. Consequently, the specific research gap addressed by this work is not clearly established.
Duplicated text and an incomplete cross-reference. On page 5, lines 250–251, the description of time broadcasting in the initial block is repeated verbatim, including the malformed junction “block.matching.” On page 4, line 205, the text refers to an appendix for the shared spectral parameterization without identifying the relevant section, Appendix A.2. These issues indicate insufficient proofreading of the final manuscript.
Limited baseline coverage, with relevant temporal modeling baselines missing. The controlled-system and shallow-water experiments compare only against SFNO and GSNO, while the weather experiment compares only against GSNO. Temporal modeling methods directly relevant to the paper’s motivation are not included. The current experiments therefore do not adequately establish the added value of the proposed temporal structure over existing approaches.
Missing ablations on the contribution of explicit temporal modeling. The paper presents explicit temporal structure as key to improving long-horizon rollout prediction, but does not validate its contribution through ablations that remove or replace this structure. Comparisons between the full model and the baselines cannot distinguish gains from explicit temporal modeling from those due to other architectural differences. The link between the central design and the reported long-horizon improvements therefore remains insufficiently validated.
Questions for authors
Could the authors provide ablations that remove or replace the explicit temporal structure, with parameter counts and computational budgets matched as closely as possible, to establish whether this design drives the improvements in long-horizon rollout prediction?
lease provide a fully autoregressive experiment over all dynamic input variables: use the ground-truth state only at initialization, and recursively feed back model predictions thereafter, without supplying ERA5 ground truth at subsequent times. Please compare SLNO and the baselines under this same protocol to assess their long-horizon performance without ground-truth auxiliary inputs.
4 comments
Weakness 4 and Question 1 — Temporal ablations and computational cost
We appreciate the reviewer’s suggestion to test the contribution of explicit temporal structure at comparable parameter counts. On SWE, we evaluate two controls. The first retains the pole–residue response and passes only the latent endpoint between blocks, with each subsequent block treating that endpoint as a constant input. The second replaces the temporal response with a shared, degree-conditioned static spectral map. We match the training schedule at 100 epochs for each configuration. The endpoint-only control has the same parameter count as SLNO, and the static spectral control has 0.38% fewer trainable degrees of freedom. We evaluate all configurations on the same 150 initial conditions per training seed and report mean joint relative rollout error over seeds 666–668. We report measured inference time and peak GPU memory separately below.
| SWE configuration | Real trainable degrees of freedom | 1 h | 5 h | 10 h | 20 h |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SLNO | 1,459,749 | 0.0006422 | 0.0022249 | 0.0023494 | 0.0026888 |
| SLNO (endpoints only) | 1,459,749 | 0.0006408 | 0.0025551 | 0.0058148 | 0.3187674 |
| SLNO (static spectral map) | 1,454,193 | 0.0021277 | 0.0040286 | 0.0061221 | 5.7741058 |
The endpoint-only control has the same number of trainable degrees of freedom as SLNO and a similar mean 1 h error. At 20 h, passing the full latent trajectory reduces mean error by 99.16% relative to passing only the endpoint. The static spectral control has 0.38% fewer trainable degrees of freedom than SLNO. Relative to this control, SLNO reduces mean 20 h error by 99.95%. Appendix F.6 describes both controls and reports the rollout errors in Table 13.
We also measured inference cost in a separate profiling run using the seed-666 checkpoints. We used the same NVIDIA TITAN X (Pascal), a 256 × 512 grid, batch size 1, and 50 matched initial conditions. Timing covers 20 model forward passes with autoregressive feedback, with GPU synchronization and gradients disabled.
| SWE configuration | Time per 20-step rollout | Peak allocated GPU memory |
|---|---|---|
| SLNO | 3.0622 s | 899.9 MiB |
| SLNO (endpoints only) | 0.2387 s | 297.3 MiB |
| SLNO (static spectral map) | 0.1919 s | 263.5 MiB |
The endpoint-only and static spectral controls reduce measured rollout time by 92.2% and 93.7%, respectively. With 100 training epochs for each configuration and comparable parameter counts, SLNO achieves lower mean 20 h error than both controls and incurs higher measured inference cost. Appendix F.7 gives the profiling protocol and the results of this separate run.
Question 2 — Weather evaluation protocol
We thank the reviewer for raising the distinction between conditional and fully autoregressive forecasting. Following the GSNO WeatherBench study (Tang et al., 2026), we use six forecast targets. GSNO, SFNO, and SLNO are trained for 20 epochs on the same data under the same training protocol. After initialization, each model feeds back its predictions for the six targets, uses ERA5 values for the other 18 dynamic variables at each forecast step, and keeps the three static fields fixed. We now describe this setting explicitly as conditional autoregressive forecasting in Section 5.3 and Appendix G.1.
Selected lead times from Table 3 of the revised paper. Lower wRMSE and higher ACC are better.
| Model | Metric | Day 1 | Day 10 | Day 20 | Day 30 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GSNO | wRMSE | 2.886712 | 3.382735 | 3.459270 | 3.455369 |
| SFNO | wRMSE | 3.021757 | 3.600121 | 3.696192 | 3.719947 |
| SLNO | wRMSE | 2.861572 | 3.333658 | 3.388283 | 3.391095 |
| GSNO | ACC | 0.840906 | 0.785932 | 0.782692 | 0.782854 |
| SFNO | ACC | 0.822061 | 0.749294 | 0.743480 | 0.739562 |
| SLNO | ACC | 0.842786 | 0.788494 | 0.788296 | 0.787944 |
SLNO achieves lower wRMSE and higher ACC than both GSNO and SFNO at all eight lead times reported in the revised paper. At days 20 and 30, SLNO reduces wRMSE by 2.05% and 1.86% relative to GSNO, and by 8.33% and 8.84% relative to SFNO, respectively. These results characterize long-range forecast skill under the six-target conditional rollout protocol with observed ERA5 auxiliary inputs.
Fully autoregressive evaluation. To further address the concern, we also evaluated SLNO, GSNO, and SFNO on the same 512 test initial conditions. Observed ERA5 dynamic fields are used only at initialization. At each subsequent step, each model predicts and feeds back all 24 dynamic variables, while the three static fields remain fixed. We compute wRMSE and ACC over all 24 dynamic variables.
| Model | Score | Day 1 | Day 5 | Day 10 | Day 20 | Day 30 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GSNO | wRMSE ↓ | 3.435872 | 5.636047 | 6.833791 | 7.968619 | 8.696467 |
| SFNO | wRMSE ↓ | 3.562059 | 5.681212 | 6.540290 | 7.607051 | 9.746844 |
| SLNO | wRMSE ↓ | 3.355446 | 5.562950 | 6.769568 | 7.489197 | 7.732783 |
| GSNO | ACC ↑ | 0.845953 | 0.541585 | 0.345775 | 0.257720 | 0.229404 |
| SFNO | ACC ↑ | 0.832429 | 0.511412 | 0.349160 | 0.258348 | 0.179869 |
| SLNO | ACC ↑ | 0.853162 | 0.560250 | 0.359298 | 0.268406 | 0.233431 |
In this fully autoregressive setting, SLNO achieves the lowest wRMSE at days 1, 5, 20, and 30, while SFNO obtains a slightly lower wRMSE at day 10. SLNO achieves the highest ACC at every reported lead time. At day 30, SLNO reduces wRMSE by 11.08% relative to GSNO and 20.66% relative to SFNO.
Both protocols and the corresponding results have been added to the revised manuscript and are highlighted in red.
We thank the reviewer again for the constructive comments. All corresponding modifications and added results are highlighted in red in the revised manuscript.
Dear Reviewer KswF,
We hope this message finds you well. We have added new experiments and clarifications in response to your constructive comments. As the discussion phase is nearing its end, we would greatly appreciate any further feedback or remaining concerns you may have.
Thank you again for your time and consideration.
Best regards,
The Authors
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful review and for highlighting the practical importance of long-horizon error accumulation, the connection between spherical spatial scales and learnable temporal responses, and the range of tasks in our evaluation.
Weakness 1 — Related work on temporal modeling
We thank the reviewer for this important comment. We have expanded Section 2 of the revised manuscript. LNO represents temporal dynamics through learned pole--residue responses, while structured state-space and memory-based neural operators propagate temporal information through latent states or observed/input sequences. These approaches establish important mechanisms for temporal modeling, but they do not specifically address the representation studied in SLNO: explicitly conditioning transient temporal responses on spherical spectral scale within a single-state spherical forecasting operator.
In contrast, SLNO generates an internal latent trajectory from the current spherical state, conditions its pole--residue responses directly on the Laplace--Beltrami spectrum, and propagates these scale-dependent temporal responses through successive operator blocks before reading out the forecast endpoint. Thus, the contribution is not temporal modeling alone, but the coupling of spherical spectral structure with explicit within-step temporal responses under a single-state forecasting interface.
We have revised the Related Work section to make this distinction and the resulting research gap explicit. We also added direct temporal baselines and component ablations, reported in our responses to Weaknesses 3--4 and Question 1, to empirically test this distinction. All corresponding revisions are highlighted in red.
Weakness 2 — Duplicated text and incomplete cross-reference
We thank the reviewer for pointing out these issues. In Section 4.3 of the revised manuscript, we removed the repeated description of time broadcasting in the initial block and corrected the sentence containing the editing error. Section 4.1 now explicitly points to Appendix A.2 for the shared spectral parameterization.
Weakness 3 — Temporal modeling baselines
We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We have added a temporal convolutional baseline (TCN) on the spherical shallow-water equations (SWE). TCN uses the same spherical harmonic transforms, four operator blocks, and 25 latent time nodes as SLNO. It maps the current state to latent features at those time nodes. In each subsequent block, a learned degree-dependent map mixes the spherical harmonic channels, followed by a three-tap causal convolution (Bai et al., 2018) applied independently to each channel along the latent time axis. Both models were trained for 100 epochs with three paired seeds (666–668) and evaluated on the same 150 initial conditions per seed. SLNO and TCN have 1,459,749 and 1,456,369 real trainable degrees of freedom, respectively, a difference of 0.23%. The table reports mean joint relative L2 rollout error in physical units at each forecast horizon, averaged over the three paired training seeds.
On SWE, SLNO has lower 20 h rollout error than TCN for each of the three paired training seeds. The reduction in mean error grows from 4.97% at 1 h to 98.86% at 20 h. Appendix F.5 also reports a comparison with LNO on the same SWE evaluation set, where SLNO reduces mean 20 h error by 96.2%.
Appendix F.5 of the revised manuscript describes the TCN architecture and the shared SWE evaluation protocol. Table 12 reports the real trainable degrees of freedom and mean rollout errors for SLNO, LNO, and TCN at 1, 5, 10, and 20 h.