- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
DeepONet represents the solution of a PDE as a function of space and time, which is implicit in time. On the other hand, there are also methods that represent time explicitly. This paper tries to verify the usefulness of the latter.
However, in practice, most neural operator research is already explicit in time. As far as I can tell from Figure 2 and Eq. (1), the proposed method is indistinguishable from a variant of the Fourier neural operator that performs rollout internally. The details of the internal network architecture are different, but I cannot see any novelty beyond the architectural change.
Moreover, many neural operators that perform rollout internally already exist, and the authors themselves cite them, for example RONOM and MemNO. It is fine to claim that "All of these are special cases of the PDON skeleton," but this is just taking the union of many prior works, and I do not think it counts as a contribution.
Using LinOSS for the rollout is novel. But, put the other way around, that is the only real modification, and there is a gap between the stated motivation (a framework that unifies existing work) and what the paper actually does.
Critical strengths
None.
Critical weaknesses
The most serious problem is the reported numbers.
- First, in Table 3, four of the seven numbers for Causal PINN and LNO are identical. The remaining three differ only in the leading digit or the order of magnitude.
- Table 6 is even more abnormal. For the proposed method, the standard deviation is exactly 0.06 times the mean (up to rounding error). For PINN it is 0.05 times, for Causal PINN 0.065 times, and for MemNO 0.07 times. The other methods also show the same exact pattern as far as I have checked.
- FNO(d+1)-LinOSS in Table 1 and FNO (implicit) in Table 3 should be very different methods, but their numbers are identical except for some trailing digits.
Also, Lemma 2 is attributed to Yarotsky (2017), but I could not find the corresponding theorem or lemma in that paper.
Checking all the other theorems and lemmas is beyond what can reasonably be expected of a normal review.
I believe the problems above are, by themselves, sufficient to reject this paper.
Questions for authors
Are the weaknesses above caused by a bug in the code, AI hallucination, or fabrication?