- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Neural Fiber Operators (NFO) for angular super-resolution reconstruction of Fiber Orientation Distributions (FODs) in diffusion MRI. The authors formulate the mapping from low-angular-resolution FODs to high-angular-resolution FODs as a neural operator learning problem on the sphere. Specifically, starting from the Constrained Spherical Deconvolution (CSD) model, the authors introduce spherical differential operators and Green's functions, and derive a spectral operator through Spherical Harmonic (SH) expansion. The resulting operator acts exclusively on even-degree SH coefficients to preserve the antipodal symmetry of FODs. The proposed operator is then integrated into a patch-based architecture, termed NFONet, which predicts the high-quality FOD at the center voxel using a local 9 × 9 × 9 voxel neighborhood. The experiments include reconstruction on the HCP-YA dataset, zero-shot generalization to the MGH dataset, and cross-domain evaluation on corpus callosum data. The authors also provide tractography and structural connectome evaluations. The reported results demonstrate that the proposed method achieves competitive reconstruction accuracy against the selected baselines while requiring fewer trainable parameters.
Critical strengths
1.The authors evaluate the proposed method not only on the HCP-YA dataset but also on the MGH and corpus callosum datasets, covering different acquisition protocols. NFO consistently outperforms the selected baselines in terms of the reported angular correlation coefficient metric.
2.NFO contains only 2.74M trainable parameters, substantially fewer than FOD-Net and FOD-Swin-Net. Furthermore, the authors provide tractography and structural connectome analyses, extending the evaluation beyond voxel-level SH coefficient prediction.
Critical weaknesses
- The core operator introduced in Eq. (20) is mathematically very similar to the GSNO operator presented in Eq. (12) of Tang et al., Generalized Spherical Neural Operators: Green's Function Formulation (ICLR 2026). Moreover, the emphasized antipodal symmetry and even-degree SH representation are established properties of FOD modeling, while patch-based learning has already been adopted in FOD-Net.
2.The experimental evaluation primarily compares NFO against FOD-Net (2022) and FOD-Swin-Net (2024). Although these are reasonable historical baselines, comparisons limited to conventional CNN- and Transformer-based approaches are insufficient for a paper whose central contribution is a spherical neural operator. In particular, the ICLR 2026 work on GSNO has already evaluated FOD-SFNO, ESCNN, and FOD-GSNO on the same FOD angular super-resolution task. These methods are highly relevant to the present work in terms of both the target problem and operator design, yet they are omitted from the experimental comparisons. Consequently, the current results only demonstrate that NFO outperforms the selected conventional baselines.
3.The authors emphasize the efficiency of the proposed model. However, on the HCP-YA dataset, NFO requires 282.86 s/sample for inference, compared with 161.36 s/sample for FOD-Net and 7.14 s/sample for FOD-Swin-Net. Despite having fewer trainable parameters, NFO exhibits substantially slower inference. Therefore, the paper should clearly distinguish parameter efficiency from computational efficiency and avoid conflating the two.
Questions for authors
- The proposed operator in Eq. (20) is mathematically very similar to the spherical spectral operator presented in Section 4.1, Eq. (12), of Tang et al., Generalized Spherical Neural Operators: Green's Function Formulation (ICLR 2026). Beyond restricting the computation to even-degree SH coefficients, what are the substantive innovations of NFO at the operator level compared with existing SFNO/GSNO formulations?
2.Why are FOD-SFNO, FOD-GSNO, and ESCNN excluded from the experimental comparisons? Given that these methods have already been evaluated on the same FOD angular super-resolution task, could the authors provide direct comparisons under consistent data splits, preprocessing procedures, and training configurations?
3.How would the model perform if the NFO block were replaced with an existing spherical spectral operator within the same NFONet architecture, while retaining the identical even-degree SH representation? To what extent do the reported performance improvements arise from the proposed operator design, rather than from the overall network architecture and training configuration?
3 comments
3. Operator Versus Architecture Contributions (Question 3)
We thank the reviewer for this insightful suggestion. We agree that distinguishing the contribution of spectral parameterization from that of the complete NFONet architecture is important.
We would like to clarify that an NFO block is not equivalent to its degree-wise spectral multiplication. It also incorporates spherical transformations, nonlinear activation, and channel interactions. Replacing the entire block with a bare spectral multiplier would simultaneously remove these components, making it difficult to isolate the contribution of spectral parameterization. Moreover, the equivariant spectral multiplier in Eq. (20) follows the same degree-wise parameterization principle as SFNO on the even-degree SH subspace. Replacing this multiplier with its corresponding SFNO form would therefore not introduce a distinct spectral operation.
To directly investigate an alternative operator parameterization within the same architecture, we implemented NFO + GSNO Correction, incorporating the generalized correction from GSNO into the spectral branch while retaining the remaining NFONet architecture and training protocol. We also conducted component-wise ablations to evaluate the contributions of the spectral branch, 1×1 convolution branch, and residual branch:
| Model | HCP-YA ACC ↑ | MGH ACC ↑ | CC ACC ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| NFO w/o Spectral Branch | 0.6891 | 0.6318 | 0.4956 |
| NFO w/o 1×1 Convolution Branch | 0.7507 | 0.6823 | 0.8328 |
| NFO w/o Residual Branch | 0.7494 | 0.6788 | 0.8296 |
| NFO | 0.7533 | 0.6827 | 0.8333 |
| NFO + GSNO Correction | 0.7539 | 0.6834 | 0.8325 |
Removing the spectral branch decreases ACC by 0.0642, 0.0509, and 0.3377 on HCP-YA, MGH, and CC, respectively. This demonstrates its substantial contribution, particularly under the challenging in-vivo to ex-vivo domain shift. Removing the residual branch also consistently reduces reconstruction accuracy. Introducing the GSNO generalized correction yields marginal changes in ACC and does not provide a consistent improvement over the original spectral parameterization in these experiments.
Together with the FOD-SFNO/FOD-GSNO comparisons, these controlled experiments provide complementary evidence regarding the contributions of spectral learning and the complete nonlinear NFO architecture.
We have included the new results and corresponding analysis in the revised manuscript (Section 5.5), with all additions highlighted in red.
4. Parameter Efficiency and Inference Time (Weakness 3)
We appreciate the reviewer's observation and agree that parameter efficiency and computational efficiency should be clearly distinguished.
Although NFO uses fewer parameters than FOD-Net and FOD-Swin-Net, its repeated spherical spectral transformations and nonlinear operator blocks introduce additional computational overhead. Furthermore, NFO performs voxel-centered reconstruction using local neighborhoods, whereas FOD-Swin-Net employs a more efficient patch-wise reconstruction strategy.
NFO uses only 2.74M parameters, compared with 19.59M for FOD-Net, 48.17M for FOD-Swin-Net, and 74.93M for SDNet. Compared with SDNet, NFO uses approximately 27× fewer parameters and achieves approximately 10× faster inference on HCP-YA, while obtaining best performance across all three datasets.
We have therefore revised the efficiency-related claims to emphasize the accuracy--efficiency trade-off, rather than suggesting universal superiority in inference speed. The computational limitations and runtime comparisons are now explicitly discussed in the revised manuscript (Abstract, Introduction, and Experiments).
We sincerely thank the reviewer again for the valuable and constructive suggestions. We have clarified the theoretical formulation and architectural contributions, expanded the comparisons with existing spherical operators, conducted controlled operator-level and component-wise ablations, and strengthened the discussion of computational efficiency. All corresponding changes are highlighted in red in the revised manuscript.
Dear Reviewer Ln6h,
We hope this message finds you well. We have added experiments and clarifications in response to your constructive feedback, especially the theoretical and architectural novelty, spherical operator comparisons and controlled ablation experiments.
As the discussion phase is nearing its end, we would greatly appreciate any further feedback you may have. Thank you again for your time and consideration.
Best regards,
The Authors
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback and for recognizing the reconstruction accuracy, cross-domain generalization, parameter efficiency, and downstream tractography and connectome evaluations of NFO.
1. Theoretical and Architectural Novelty (Weakness 1 & Question 1)
We thank the reviewer for this important question. We would like to clarify that the main contributions of NFO lie in its fiber operator formulation and dedicated nonlinear operator architecture, rather than the degree-wise spectral multiplication alone.
Theoretically, SFNO and GSNO establish general spherical operator formulations, whereas NFO specifically addresses the CSD-motivated antipodally symmetric fiber system. We formulate FOD angular super-resolution as a spherical function-to-function mapping and derive its Green's-function-based representation within the even-degree SH subspace (Section 4.2). The learned kernel is explicitly parameterized on this subspace to preserve the antipodal symmetry of FODs. We agree that antipodal symmetry and even-degree SH representations are established properties of FODs. Our contribution is not the discovery of these properties, but their incorporation into a fiber-specific operator formulation. The spectral computation follows the established SO(3)-equivariant convolution assumption in Eq. (14), leading to the degree-wise parameterization in Eq. (20).
Architecturally, the spectral multiplication represents only one component of an NFO block. Each block further integrates spherical spectral-spatial transformations, 1×1 channel interactions, and nonlinear activation. Multiple NFO blocks are composed into NFONet, progressively aggregating local spherical fiber representations to reconstruct the target FOD. In contrast, FOD-SFNO and FOD-GSNO in Tang et al. (2026) adapt FOD-Net by replacing its convolutional operations with the corresponding spherical operators (spectral multiplication without spatial transformations&operations). These baselines evaluate spherical operator parameterizations within an existing reconstruction architecture, whereas NFO develops dedicated nonlinear operator blocks and a complete multi-block operator network.
We have clarified these theoretical and architectural distinctions in the revised manuscript (Related Work, Methodology and Appendix B.1.4), with the corresponding changes highlighted in red.
2. Additional Spherical Operator Comparisons (Weakness 2 & Question 2)
We appreciate the suggestion to include more directly relevant spherical operator baselines. The original evaluation focused on established FOD reconstruction architectures, FOD-Net and FOD-Swin-Net. To strengthen the comparisons, we have added SDNet (2024), FOD-SFNO, and FOD-GSNO (2026).
In particular, FOD-SFNO and FOD-GSNO were previously evaluated on the same FOD angular super-resolution task. We implemented these methods following the FOD-Net-based adaptations described in Tang et al. (2026), using consistent data splits, preprocessing, training, and evaluation protocols.
The following table summarizes the mean ACC on held-out HCP-YA and zero-shot MGH/CC datasets:
NFO achieves the highest mean ACC across all three datasets, outperforming FOD-SFNO and FOD-GSNO in both held-out reconstruction and zero-shot generalization. Compared with the strongest competing method, SDNet, NFO improves mean ACC by 0.017, 0.006, and 0.009 on HCP-YA, MGH, and CC, respectively. The revised tables and Appendix provide complete tissue-wise ACC/RMSE results and additional statistics. Regarding ESCNN, the original method of Snoussi and Karimi (2025) estimates FODs directly from reduced dMRI measurements, whereas our task learns the mapping from LAR-FOD to HAR-FOD. In this revision, we prioritize the directly relevant FOD-SFNO and FOD-GSNO baselines and have clarified the relationship to ESCNN in Related Work.
These additional comparisons and their implementation details have been incorporated into the revised manuscript (Section 5.1), with the changes highlighted in red.