- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates how canonical alignment affects the performance of equivariant models in fluid prediction tasks. The authors propose AB-GATr, which combines geometric algebra representations with anchor attention and a multi-branch architecture. Experiments on three hemodynamic datasets and ShapeNet-Car suggest that explicit equivariance is generally beneficial for the evaluated hemodynamic tasks, but may not always help when the data are strongly canonically aligned.
Critical strengths
-
The research question is interesting. Rather than assuming equivariance is always beneficial, the authors investigate how orientation distributions affect model performance. The controlled experiments on ShapeNet-Car are particularly informative.
-
The experimental evaluation is extensive, covering multiple hemodynamic datasets, rotational augmentation, and different architectures. AB-GATr also achieves a promising balance between prediction accuracy and computational efficiency.
Critical weaknesses
-
The contribution of equivariance is not fully isolated. Although AB-GATr performs well, it also differs from the non-equivariant models in parameter count, feature representation, and normalization. Differences across datasets further make it difficult to determine how much of the improvement comes from equivariance itself and the role of canonical alignment.
-
Generalization to unseen base anatomies is not sufficiently clear. aneumo contains many synthetic geometries derived from a limited number of original anatomies. The paper mentions stratification by base anatomy, but it is unclear whether the splits are strictly disjoint at the original anatomy level. This may affect how the generalization results should be interpreted.
Questions for authors
-
Does aneumo use strictly disjoint splits at the original anatomy level? Are all synthetic geometries derived from the same base anatomy assigned to the same split? Could the authors provide results on entirely unseen base anatomies? If the method can be shown to generalize well to completely unseen original anatomical structures, I would be willing to raise the score.
-
AB-GATr and AB-UPT differ in model configuration and normalization. How can the performance gains be attributed specifically to equivariance? Could the authors conduct a more controlled experiment by varying canonical alignment within the same hemodynamic dataset?
-
For ShapeNet-Car, are the geometry, inflow direction, and CFD labels rotated together during evaluation? Given that the model uses only coordinates as input, how does this relate to the discussion that boundary conditions must transform jointly with geometry?
Minor Comments: what is the statistical unit used in the Wilcoxon tests in Table 1, individual test cases or independent runs? Also, the reference information for Suk et al. (2024a) appears to mix the 2024 preprint year with the 2026 journal publication details. In the attention formula at line 230, both inputs are queries. Should the second one be a key? Also, Theorem A.1 seems to require a non-degeneracy assumption, since the zero function provides a counterexample. Could the authors clarify these points?
5 comments
Thank you for the clarifications and additional experiments; I will maintain my original score, as the contribution of equivariance remains difficult to separate from other architectural differences. I understand the focus on vector-valued fields, but pressure is also important in hemodynamic modeling, and its omission from the hemodynamic evaluation should be reflected in the scope of the conclusions. Please also clarify the exact definition of the velocity relative l2 error and whether it is evaluated on all volumetric mesh nodes or a sampled subset.
Thank you for considering our clarifications and additional experiments.
Here, we provide clarification on the relative $ L_2 $ error definition. For each test case $ i $, the relative $ L_2 $ is:
where ($ \mathcal V_i T_i $) the number of evaluated time points, and $ \mathbf{y}, \mathbf{\hat{y}} $ the target and estimated fields, respectively. Evaluation uses all volumetric mesh nodes for volumetric quantities and all surface mesh nodes for surface quantities.
We thank the reviewer for recognising the extent of the evaluation and AB-GATr’s balance between computational cost and performance.
Question 1
Yes, the ANEUMO splits are strictly disjoint at the original anatomy level: all synthetic geometries derived from the same base anatomy are assigned to a single split, with no overlap between training, validation and test sets. Table 1 therefore already assesses generalisation to entirely unseen original anatomies.
Question 2
A) Matching model configuration and training budget
We agree that the models should be made as comparable as possible to ensure a fair comparison. As described in Appendix A.3, AB-UPT and AB-GATr share the number of anchors, dropout rate, pooling radius, and block layout. Differences remain in settings that are model-specific, i.e. their hidden representations and attention configurations due to differences in standard and geometric algebra, respectively. AB-GATr has substantially fewer parameters than AB-UPT (1.6M vs 7M), but incurs ~4 times higher computational costs per epoch and approximately 3–4 times the VRAM usage.
The normalization choices reflect the requirement to preserve equivariance: axis-wise normalisation of vectors generally breaks rotational equivariance, whereas scaling vector targets by a common scalar, such as magnitude, preserves it. We also evaluated magnitude normalization for AB-UPT, but it performed worse than per-axis normalization. We retained the latter to provide the stronger baseline.
As we noted in Appendix A.5, the models required different numbers of epochs to achieve their best observed performance. Following reviewer's suggestions, we have extended this section to include a numerical summary. In the table below, we provide the AB-UPT (rot) performance with doubled training duration from 500 to 1000 epochs on a single AAA-100 fold, retaining the same architecture. We report relative $ L_2 $ errors (%) for velocity ($ u )andWSS( \tau $). Doubling the training did not lead to improvement in performance.
For architectural and training choices that could not be matched directly, we selected the best-performing options among those evaluated for each model.
B) Controlled orientation experiment for AAA-100
Following the reviewer’s suggestion, we extended the controlled orientation study in Fig. 5 to AAA-100. On a single fold, we trained AB-UPT with five rotation-augmentation ranges (0°, 30°, 60°, 90° and 180°) and evaluated each model across the same test ranges. The 0° setting retains native orientations.
As on ShapeNet-Car, AB-UPT generally performs worse when test rotations exceed its training range. However, broader augmentation also improves performance on the native AAA-100 orientations. This differs from ShapeNet-Car and is consistent with AAA-100’s weaker canonical alignment. AB-GATr maintains constant and superior performance across the evaluated rotations.
WSS ($ \tau )/Velocity( u $): relative $ L_2 $ error (%)
Question 3
In the ShapeNet-Car experiment (Fig. 5), the inflow direction is rotated jointly with the geometry. Spatial coordinates, velocity and pressure targets are transformed consistently. The models receive coordinates without a separately encoded inflow direction. Consequently, geometry orientation also provides implicit information about the boundary conditions, and the experiment does not independently isolate these two sources of information. Due to this implicit boundary-conditions encoding the complete problem (geometry + boundary conditions) transforms consistently with respect to E(3).
Minor