- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper constructed a multi-fidelity and multi-anatomy pretraining corpus comprising 5,310 vascular geometries that can yield more than 100,000 probe-conditioned pretraining instances. Building upon this, the authors introduced a flow-state proxy-supervised vascular pretraining framework (HemoPT) without the need for paired computational fluid dynamics (CFD) fields. HemoPT uses directional probes to learn the spatial information of the vascular lumen, and is later associated with representative vascular flow states, producing geometry-specific hemodynamic proxies. The authors then pre-trained a transolver encoder for downstream velocity-field regression across different data regimes.
Critical strengths
-
The data-imbalance issue of abundant unpaired vascular geometries but scarce and costly paired geometry-flow data is well-targeted, and the exploration of how to leverage heterogeneous, unlabeled vascular geometries is well-motivated.
-
The construction of the multi-fidelity corpus, the dataset information and the QC & processing pipeline, are described. The authors also included the code, which further details the implementation and promotes reproducibility.
-
Multiple levels of low-data regime (i.e. 25%, 50%, 75%), multiple corpus scales are utilized, and different tier compositions are included.
Critical weaknesses
-
The proposed flow proxy seems to have a fixed direction within each geometry. Equations A1-5 stated that each geometry is assigned one PCA-based frame, and the centerline used in Equations A7 and A8 is a straight line along the first principal axis, which doesn’t necessarily represent the centerline of all the branches in more complex models. Equations A14 to A18 further state that U1-U4 share the same direction vector e with different magnitude, and Table A11 shows that these four primitives receive most (86.5%, at epoch 200) of the mean routing weight on the pretraining corpus. The authors should discuss and clarify how the proxy could provide meaningful flow supervision on the branching or curved geometries.
-
It’s unclear whether proxy design (i.e. dynamic routing and physical consistency losses) improves the transferred encoder. GeoPT-Vasc [1] has the same transolver backbone as HemoPT and the main design novelty is the flow-proxy branch. The authors showed in Table 2 the flow proxy and physical loss ablation, but the authors did not include a comparison between different encoders pre-trained with the proxy targets generated under each Table 2 configuration. Thus it is hard to conclude with the existing results that dynamic routing and physical consistency losses benefit the transfer.
-
The authors mentioned in the related work session several applications adopted by other related literature, like wall shear stress estimation, and fractional flow reserve prediction, but only the velocity-field regression are adopted as the method’s down-streaming applications. More evaluation tasks should be used to highlight the benefit of pre-taining and bring more insights/evaluations of the model. In addition, experiments with linear probes and frozen encoder should be included to show and examine the rationality of the learned representation.
-
Other readability issues: Certain figures like Figure 5, Figure A.1, Figure A.2 are hard to read, the texts in the figure are too small, and Figure A.2 is incomplete.
[1] Wu, H., Guo, M., Li, Z., Dou, Z., Long, M., He, K., & Matusik, W. (2026). Geopt: Scaling physics simulation via lifted geometric pre-training. arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.20399.
Questions for authors
So far the model’s input only considers the geometry and doesn’t seem to be able to adapt to different flow conditions. Could other factors potentially affect the flow that could potentially be considered (e.g., inlet flow rate)?
I thank the authors for the additional experiments and clarifications. The paired runs strengthen the evidence that the flow proxy provides benefits beyond spatial pretraining, particularly on Aneumo and ICA-Sim. I also appreciate the more qualified interpretation of the flow templates and the case-level uncertainty analysis. Nevertheless, the incremental gains remain modest, the 4DFlow confidence intervals include zero, and VMR-AOCOA results remain mixed with high absolute errors. The boundary-condition families and their variation across cases also remain insufficiently specified. Overall, the rebuttal meaningfully addresses several concerns, but does not fully establish the strength and generality of the central flow-proxy contribution. I therefore maintain my recommendation.