- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents Physics-Embedded Flow Matching (PEFM), a framework for paired physiological signal translation that incorporates known physiological relationships into the learned local velocity field. The method derives a physics residual in velocity space and combines it with the standard flow matching objective. For affine interpolation paths and linear physical operators, the paper establishes a connection between local velocity residuals along the generated trajectory and the physical consistency of the final prediction. It also provides an idealized analysis of how physics regularization and error cancellation during multi-step integration can improve prediction accuracy. The framework is evaluated on two datasets for blood pressure waveform reconstruction: one using simulated aortic flow and the other using a flow proxy derived from measured bioimpedance. Both experiments employ a two-element Windkessel model with learned parameters. PEFM achieves the lowest reported waveform RMSE and MAE among the evaluated methods on both datasets, while achieving physical consistency close to WPINN on the measured dataset.
Critical strengths
A key strength of this paper is the formulation of a mathematical representation that translates known physiological relationships into local velocity field regularization terms, thereby eliminating the need for full ODE trajectory unrolling during training. This approach establishes a link between local velocity residuals and endpoint physical consistency, providing a theoretical basis for the proposed scheme. The authors present detailed derivations in both the main text and the appendix, lending the paper a well-structured quality.
Critical weaknesses
-
Evidence supporting the main argument is limited. While the introduction describes the proposal of a flow-matching framework, both validation experiments focus exclusively on blood pressure reconstruction based on the Windkessel relationship. Consequently, the framework's applicability across different physiological mechanisms remains unverified. Although the results demonstrate its utility for blood pressure reconstruction, they are insufficient to establish broader applicability to other physiological signal transformation tasks.
-
The scale of the dataset used for practical application is limited. The real-world dataset comprises only seven subjects. In each data split, three subjects are allocated for training, two for validation, and two for testing. Despite the reporting of results based on five random seeds, the small sample size limits the persuasiveness of conclusions regarding inter-subject robustness and generalization capability.
Questions for authors
Questions 2 and 3 are my primary concerns, and the authors' responses are crucial for my final assessment.
-
As stated in the introduction, can the proposed framework be extended to other physiological signals (e.g., ECG)? What control relationships would this require, and how should the existing physical constraints be adjusted accordingly?
-
Within the scope of the current experimental setup (specifically blood pressure reconstruction), could the authors utilize additional datasets to strengthen the evaluation and assess the framework's robustness and generalization capabilities across different subjects group (like different age, BMI, etc.) and measurement conditions?
-
Within the same scope as Q2, could the authors provide an assessment for downstream tasks to demonstrate the reliability and practical application value of the reconstructed blood pressure signal?
4 comments
W2/Q2, Q3, and References
(W2/Q2) Additional datasets and generalization.
Our original experiments focused on simulated and measured cardiovascular signals, motivated by prior PINN-based studies [3, 4]. To address concerns regarding sample size and generalization, we additionally evaluated PEFM on PWDB [5], containing 3,837 physiologically plausible virtual subjects using the three-element Windkessel model. Subjects span six age groups (25–75 years), heart rates of 62–89 bpm, stroke volumes of 42–82 mL, and systolic pressures of 82–138 mmHg. Each subject contributes one waveform, with subject-disjoint splits of 2,687/575/575 for training/validation/testing.
PWDB results. Test RMSE (mmHg, mean ± std over three seeds) and subject-level paired Wilcoxon -values against PEFM, pooled over seeds.
| Method | RMSE ↓ | p-value |
|---|---|---|
| Supervised | 6.756 ± 0.170 | |
| FM | 8.077 ± 0.118 | |
| WPINN (oracle) | 6.764 ± 0.152 | |
| WPINN (learned) | 6.728 ± 0.180 | |
| PIFM-GN | 8.059 ± 0.144 | |
| PBFM (oracle) | 8.088 ± 0.091 | |
| PBFM (learned) | 8.165 ± 0.258 | |
| PEFM (learned) | 6.415 ± 0.108 | – |
PEFM achieves the lowest RMSE, significantly outperforming all seven baselines (subject-level Wilcoxon and paired seed-level tests, ). It reduces RMSE by 20.6% relative to FM and 4.7% relative to WPINN (learned).
The additional datasets also introduce variations in measurement and physiological conditions: CCVW-ICU includes patients aged 35–91 years under different ventilator settings (pressure support 6–12 cmH₂O; PEEP 4–6 cmH₂O), while EDGAR includes distinct electrode configurations (599-electrode pericardial cage and 240-electrode epicardial sock) and activation protocols.
These experiments strengthen evidence for robustness across simulated subjects and diverse experimental conditions. However, EDGAR does not establish inter-heart generalization, and real-world demographic subgroup analyses, particularly BMI-stratified evaluations, remain future work.
(Q3) Downstream clinical evaluation.
Our original manuscript already evaluates clinically relevant SBP and DBP estimation from reconstructed waveforms (Table 3). On BioZGraphene, PEFM achieves the lowest waveform RMSE (14.2 mmHg) and MAE (11.5 mmHg), the smallest absolute SBP mean error ( mmHg), and a competitive DBP error ( mmHg). These findings support the preservation of clinically relevant BP characteristics, beyond waveform reconstruction accuracy. We will emphasize this evaluation in the revised manuscript.
References
[1] K. Aras et al. Experimental Data and Geometric Analysis Repository—EDGAR. Journal of Electrocardiology, 48(6):975–981, 2015. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jelectrocard.2015.08.008
[2] X. Liu et al. Clinical and ventilator waveforms of Chinese patients during pressure support ventilation. Scientific Data, 13(1):48, 2025. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-025-06364-z
[3] K. Sel et al. Physics-informed neural networks for modeling physiological time series for cuffless blood pressure estimation. npj Digital Medicine, 6:110, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41746-023-00853-4
[4] D. Osman et al. Cardiovascular digital twins using a Windkessel physics informed neural network. npj Digital Medicine, 9:443, 2026. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41746-026-02610-9
[5] P. H. Charlton et al. Modeling arterial pulse waves in healthy aging: a database for in silico evaluation of hemodynamics and pulse wave indexes. American Journal of Physiology-Heart and Circulatory Physiology, 317(5):H1062–H1085, 2019. https://doi.org/10.1152/ajpheart.00218.2019
Overall Score Raised to 2
Thank you for the additional experiments and detailed explanations. The new results address my concerns regarding Q1 and Q2. I will raise my overall score to 2. Regarding Q3, I agree that estimating systolic and diastolic blood pressure (SBP and DBP) from the reconstructed waveforms is clinically meaningful, and Table 3 reports the accuracy of these estimates.
Could the authors describe a deployment scenario for PEFM and explain how the reconstructed blood pressure waveform would be used in that setting?
We thank the reviewer for this follow-up question. One potential deployment scenario is physiological monitoring in intensive care units (ICUs), as demonstrated by our additional CCVW-ICU experiments. In this setting, PEFM could reconstruct transpulmonary pressure waveforms from continuously measured airway flow using the single-compartment respiratory model. These reconstructed waveforms could help clinicians assess respiratory mechanics, monitor changes in lung compliance and airway resistance, and potentially support ventilator management [1, 2], while reducing reliance on direct esophageal pressure measurements.
Beyond this setting, reconstructed blood pressure waveforms could potentially support downstream hemodynamic analysis. Previous studies have used arterial pressure waveforms to assess pulse pressure and vascular tone [3], estimate stroke volume and cardiac output through pulse wave analysis [4, 5], predict fluid responsiveness [6], and investigate hypotension prediction [7]. These applications highlight the potential value of preserving the full pressure waveform beyond conventional blood pressure measurements.
References
[1] Ball, L., Talmor, D., & Pelosi, P. (2024). “Transpulmonary pressure monitoring in critically ill patients: pros and cons.” Critical Care, 28, 177. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13054-024-04950-y
[2] “Fundamental concepts and the latest evidence for esophageal pressure monitoring.” (2023). Journal of Intensive Care. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40560-023-00671-6
[3] Bertrand, M., et al. (2025). “Applied physiology at the bedside: using invasive blood pressure as a true monitoring tool.” Annals of Intensive Care, 15, 192. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13613-025-01608-y
[4] Thomsen, K. K., Kouz, K., & Saugel, B. (2023). “Pulse wave analysis: basic concepts and clinical application in intensive care medicine.” Current Opinion in Critical Care, 29(3), 215–222. https://doi.org/10.1097/MCC.0000000000001039
[5] Wołos, K., et al. (2024). “Non-invasive assessment of stroke volume and cardiovascular parameters based on peripheral pressure waveform.” PLOS Computational Biology, 20(4), e1012013. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1012013
[6] Gupta, C. B., et al. (2024). “Improving the precision of shock resuscitation by predicting fluid responsiveness with machine learning and arterial blood pressure waveform data.” Scientific Reports, 14, 2227. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-50120-5
[7] Yang, H.-L., et al. (2025). “The effect of selection bias on the performance of a deep learning-based intraoperative hypotension prediction model using real-world samples from a publicly available database.” British Journal of Anaesthesia, 135(3), 571–581. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bja.2025.03.024
Q1/W1
We thank the reviewer for their constructive assessment of our formulation and theoretical analysis. We address (W1/Q1) the limited validation across physiological mechanisms by introducing electrophysiological and respiratory experiments, (W2/Q2) the small sample size and generalization concerns through additional datasets with different subject groups and a large-scale subject-disjoint evaluation, and (Q3) the clinical relevance of reconstructed BP through downstream SBP/DBP estimation.
(W1/Q1) Extension to other physiological signals.
PEFM applies whenever a known governing relationship connects source and target signals. For linear relationships, the corresponding operator can be incorporated directly into the velocity-space residual without changing the FM formulation. We demonstrate this on two additional physiological mechanisms.
Electrophysiology (EDGAR [1]). We reconstructed heart-surface potentials from torso measurements using the linear forward model
ytorso(t)=Hxheart(t),
where H is the geometry-dependent transfer matrix. We evaluated two cardiac preparations containing 205 and 927 signal windows, respectively.
EDGAR results. Test RMSE (mV, mean ± std over three seeds) and grouped Wilcoxon p-values against PEFM, pooled over seeds. Grouping is by beat (u020515) or recording run (u180809).
PEFM achieves the lowest mean RMSE on both preparations, improving upon FM by 10.1% and 15.7%, respectively. Improvements over three baselines reach nominal significance in both preparations, although seed-level significance is established only for u020515.
Respiratory mechanics (CCVW-ICU [2]). We reconstructed transpulmonary pressure from airway flow using the single-compartment equation
PL(t)=RQ(t)+EV(t)+P0.
We evaluated 276 breaths from seven mechanically ventilated ICU patients.
CCVW-ICU results. Test RMSE (cmH₂O, mean ± std over three seeds) and patient-grouped Wilcoxon p-values against PEFM (learned), pooled over seeds.
PEFM achieves the lowest mean RMSE, improving upon FM by 30.7% and WPINN (learned) by 11.9%. It outperforms FM on 79% of evaluated breaths, although most patient-grouped comparisons are not significant given the small patient population.
Together, these experiments demonstrate the applicability of PEFM beyond the Windkessel model, with the lowest mean RMSE across all three additional electrophysiological and respiratory settings.